Learn › Economic history › Quantitative Easing

Your decisions

The decisions you took

The 9 decisions in Quantitative Easing, what you chose at each, and what was done at the time.

  1. Decision 1 of 9

    Inflation Targeting at the Bank of England

    You have not taken this one yet.

  2. Decision 2 of 9

    The Zero Lower Bound

    You have not taken this one yet.

  3. Decision 3 of 9

    How Quantitative Easing Works

    You have not taken this one yet.

  4. Decision 4 of 9

    The Scale of Quantitative Easing

    You have not taken this one yet.

  5. Decision 5 of 9

    The Evidence on Quantitative Easing

    You have not taken this one yet.

  6. Decision 6 of 9

    Quantitative Easing and Inequality

    You have not taken this one yet.

  7. Decision 7 of 9

    The Cost of Quantitative Easing

    You have not taken this one yet.

  8. Decision 8 of 9

    Quantitative Tightening and Rate Rises

    You have not taken this one yet.

  9. Decision 9 of 9

    The Limits of Quantitative Tightening

    You have not taken this one yet.

The decade those choices sit against

The argument this series makes, in 32 steps. It is the same spine every module is built on, and no module states more of it than its own share.

  1. The Government, not the Bank, chooses the inflation target the Bank has to hit, and it is 2 per cent.
  2. The Bank hits that target by setting one interest rate, and every other tool it has is secondary to it.
  3. A change in that rate reaches prices slowly and by several routes at once, taking about eighteen months to two years.
  4. Because savers can hold cash instead, that rate cannot be cut far below zero, so a deep enough slump exhausts the tool.
  5. So in March 2009 the Bank created new central bank reserves and used them to buy government bonds from investors.
  6. The bonds were bought second-hand from pension funds and insurers, never from the government direct.
  7. What the Bank created was not banknotes but reserves, which banks hold at the Bank and cannot spend into the economy.
  8. So banks' reserves at the Bank rose about fortyfold and consumer prices went on rising at roughly the target rate for eleven years.
  9. Buying on that scale pushed bond prices up and long-term borrowing costs down, by roughly half a point for every tenth of national income bought.
  10. The investors who sold gilts had to hold something else, so they bought other assets and pushed those prices up too.
  11. Cheaper borrowing and higher asset prices raised output and inflation by about what a large rate cut would have done.
  12. The effect is much larger when markets are broken than when they are calm, so it is not one policy with one strength.
  13. Whether it did much over a decade is disputed by the two British institutions that examined it, and both published.
  14. Because it worked by raising asset prices, the first gains landed on the households that already owned assets.
  15. The same policy also raised jobs and pay, and by more for the bottom half of earners than for the top.
  16. So it widened the gap in wealth and narrowed the gap in income, and which of those you count decides the verdict.
  17. Savers were on the other side of it and received about seventy billion pounds less deposit interest than at September 2008 levels, which the Bank puts down mainly to cuts in Bank Rate.
  18. Underneath all of it the purchases swapped fixed-rate government debt for reserves that pay Bank Rate, so the state now borrows short and floating.
  19. So a rise in Bank Rate now reaches the public finances at once, and the Office for Budget Responsibility put the extra debt interest in 2025-26 at about twenty billion pounds if short- and long-term rates were both one point higher.
  20. The programme paid the Treasury about a hundred and twenty-four billion pounds and then began paying it back the other way.
  21. Every penny of that loss falls on the Treasury, under an indemnity it has published once, and it may reach two hundred and eighty billion pounds.
  22. Because the fiscal rules count that cash, a decision about interest rates is now also a decision about what a government can spend.
  23. Paying Bank Rate on every pound of those reserves hands the banks tens of billions a year that a tiered system would keep, and nobody will own the decision.
  24. Then inflation came back hard and the price level never returned: prices are about thirty per cent above their January 2021 level.
  25. How much of that the purchases caused is unsettled: the newest work finds them harder on inflation than a rate cut, the older work found no effect at all.
  26. Correcting it took fourteen consecutive rate rises, and mortgage holders on low-to-middle incomes would carry twice the share the richest did.
  27. Each of those rises raised the government's own bill at once through the reserves the purchases created, so fighting inflation and funding public services became the same lever.
  28. From November 2022 the Bank began selling the bonds to investors, among the first central banks to sell rather than wait, cutting the stock by nearly half.
  29. Whether the selling tightens much is disputed: the Bank puts it at a small part of the rise in the extra yield on long-term gilts, and the Commons Treasury Committee said the Bank was taking a leap in the dark by not tracking it separately.
  30. The selling no longer stops where reserves would get scarce: the Bank now lends banks the reserves they need against collateral, because if reserves get scarce it loses its grip on short-term rates.
  31. In the middle of selling, the Bank bought gilts again for a different reason - to stop a forced-selling spiral in the pension industry.
  32. It can be used again if the rate floor binds again, and selling makes room for it; it may do less next time if long-term rates start near their lows.

Back to Quantitative Easing

Country data from the World Bank (CC BY 4.0) and the UNDP Human Development Report (CC BY 3.0 IGO)
Games · Learn · Atlas · Read · Feedback · Privacy · Contact