Before you start
What you'll be able to answer
- Why can an interest rate not fall far below zero? And why did the Bank of England stop cutting its rate above zero in 2009?
- What can a central bank do once its interest rate is close to zero?
- Did interest rates stay close to zero for long?
Where this sits
Quantitative Easing · this module is lit
- 1998The Bank of England Act gives interest rate decisions to a committee at the Bank; the Chancellor keeps the target
- Mar 2009Bank Rate is cut to 0.5 per cent, and the Bank starts buying government bonds with newly created money
- Aug 2013The Bank says it will not consider raising interest rates at least until unemployment falls to 7 per cent
- Mar 2020Bank Rate is cut to a new low
- Jan 2022Banks' reserves at the Bank reach their highest level
- Sep 2022The Bank buys government bonds again, to stop forced selling by pension funds
- Oct 2022Consumer price inflation reaches 11.1 per cent
- Nov 2022The Bank starts selling its bonds to investors, among the first central banks to do so
- Aug 2023Bank Rate reaches its peak after rises at consecutive meetings
- Apr 2026The Governor writes an open letter to the Chancellor after inflation overshoots the target
Bank Rate was cut close to zero in March 2009
On 5 March 2009 the Bank of England's Monetary Policy Committee met. Its nine members set Bank Rate, the Bank's main interest rate. Bank Rate had been 5 per cent five months earlier. Five cuts had taken it to 1 per cent. Output, what the economy produces, was still shrinking.
The Committee aims for inflation of 2 per cent, and saw a real risk of inflation falling below that target. The members first argued over whether another cut would still help. Then they cut Bank Rate to 0.5 per cent.
Why can a central bank not keep cutting its interest rate further and further below zero?
Savers can always switch to cash, and no law is needed to stop the cuts.
Cash stops interest rates falling far below zero
A central bank's interest rate changes what borrowing costs and what savers earn. A cut makes borrowing cheaper and saving less rewarding, so people spend sooner. Once the rate is near zero, further cuts become hard. Savers can always hold banknotes instead, and banknotes pay no interest. Suppose a bank charged savers to keep money in their accounts. If the charge were large, savers would take their money out as cash instead.
So in a deep enough downturn a central bank can run out of room to cut its rate. It then needs other tools. America's central bank, the Federal Reserve, cut its rate almost to zero in December 2008, less than three months before the Bank of England stopped cutting.
The Bank judged that further cuts could hurt lending
The Bank of England stopped above zero mainly because of the effect on lenders. Savings accounts already paid very little and could hardly go lower. Some loan contracts said the borrower's rate would move with Bank Rate. Each cut lowered what banks and building societies (savings and mortgage lenders) earned on those loans.
Lenders would earn less on loans while paying savers about the same. Their profits would fall, and they could afford to lend less. The Committee also feared that years of very low rates could harm money markets, where banks lend to each other.
On the other side, a cut would still help the economy a little, through the exchange rate and through the prices of assets such as shares. The Committee weighed both sides, made one more cut, and stopped. Where to stop was a judgement, and the Bank later went lower.
Check yourself
In March 2009, why did the Bank of England judge that cutting Bank Rate much further could do harm?
The Federal Reserve cut its rate almost to zero only months before Britain. One central bank got there about ten years before Britain came close. Which one?
The Bank of Japan, in February 1999, when prices in Japan were falling.
Japan cut its rate almost to zero ten years earlier
Japan got there first. Prices in Japan began to fall in the late 1990s. In February 1999 the Bank of Japan began pushing its overnight rate, the rate banks charge each other for one-day loans, as low as possible. Two months later the Bank of Japan promised to keep the rate there until the fear of falling prices had passed. From 2001 to 2006 it also created new money and used it to buy assets, such as bonds and shares.
Japan's short-term rate stayed at or close to zero for most of the next 25 years. In 2016 the Bank of Japan set one of its interest rates slightly below zero.
The Bank had four main ways to add help once rate cuts ran out
Bank Rate was now as low as the Committee judged useful. Yet the Committee still thought the economy needed more help. Without more help, inflation would fall below the target in the years ahead. A central bank in that position has four main options. It can push its rate below zero anyway and accept the side effects described below. It can promise to keep the rate low for longer than people expect. It can lend to banks cheaply if they lend that money to households and firms. Or it can create new money, as extra balances that banks hold at the central bank, and use it to buy bonds from investors.
Your decision
You sit on the Committee in March 2009. Which do you reach for first?
Holding money in a bank would then cost something, so savers and banks would try to put their money elsewhere.
Where it was triedThe European Central Bank took one of its rates below zero in June 2014, and the Bank of Japan did the same in 2016.
What it costsIt cuts lenders' profits, which is what the Committee feared in 2009. Pushed too far, it sends savers to cash.
A long-term loan runs across many years of short-term rates. So lenders set long-term rates by what they expect short-term rates to be over those years. If people believe the promise, they expect low rates for longer, and long-term borrowing gets cheaper today.
Where it was triedThe Bank of Japan made this kind of promise in April 1999.
What it costsIt works only if people believe it. It also makes it hard for the Bank to raise rates if the economy recovers sooner than expected.
The cheap loans are tied directly to the loans that households and firms need. Bond buying works first through prices in financial markets.
Where it was triedBritain set up a scheme like this in July 2012.
What it costsIt helps only if banks want to lend and borrowers want to borrow, and a scheme takes months to design.
A bond pays a fixed amount each year. When the central bank buys many bonds, their price rises. A buyer then pays more for the same fixed payments, so the yearly return on the money paid is smaller. That return is the long-term interest rate, so long-term interest rates fall. The investors who sold the bonds then have money to buy other assets, such as shares.
Where it was triedThe Bank of Japan created new money and used it to buy assets from 2001 to 2006.
What it costsNobody knew how large the effect would be, and the Bank would end up holding a very large stock of bonds.
The Committee voted unanimously to create £75 billion of new money. It would use the money within three months to buy assets, mostly government bonds.
What followedThe Bank added to its purchases in later rounds, and over the following years it tried some of the other ways too.
The Bank lent cheaply to banks that lent more
In July 2012 the Bank of England and the Treasury, the government's finance ministry, started the Funding for Lending Scheme. Banks and building societies could borrow from the Bank for a long period at lower rates than they would pay elsewhere. The more they lent to households and firms, the more they could borrow.
Banks paid for this borrowing with a yearly fee. The size of the fee depended on how much each bank lent. A bank that kept its lending up paid a fee of 0.25 per cent a year. A bank whose lending shrank paid up to 1.5 per cent.
Bond buying works differently. It changes prices in financial markets, such as bond prices. Households and firms feel the effect only when those changes lower what they pay to borrow.
Check yourself
Why could the lending scheme reach households and firms more directly than buying bonds?
Check yourself
Predict: in August 2013 the Bank promised not to raise Bank Rate before unemployment had fallen to a set level. Unemployment was then about 7.7 per cent. What level did the Bank choose, in per cent?
7 %
7 per cent, less than one percentage point below where unemployment stood when the promise was made.
In 2013 the Bank promised to keep Bank Rate low
In August 2013 the Bank tried a promise. It said it would not raise Bank Rate before unemployment fell to a threshold of 7 per cent. The promise would lapse if inflation or the safety of the financial system was put at risk. If people believe a promise like this, they expect Bank Rate to stay low for years. Lenders then charge less for long-term loans today, without any cut.
Unemployment fell below the threshold by early 2014, and Bank Rate still did not rise. Reaching the threshold meant only that the Bank would think again about raising the rate. The first rise came in November 2017.
Check yourself
Three of these are tools the Bank of England used once it had cut Bank Rate close to zero. Which one did it never use?
Bank Rate stayed close to zero until 2022
The chart shows how long rates stayed down. Bank Rate stayed at the level set in March 2009 for more than seven years. It was cut in August 2016, then raised in November 2017 and August 2018. Despite those rises, it stayed at 0.75 per cent or below until May 2022.
Bank Rate was still low when the Covid-19 pandemic reached Britain, so there was little room to cut. Two cuts in March 2020 took Bank Rate to 0.1 per cent, a new low. The Bank bought more bonds at the same time. Bank Rate stayed at that low until December 2021. From 2009 to 2022 Bank Rate, the Bank's main tool, was usually too close to zero to cut much further.
Source: Bank of England Database, Official Bank Rate, end of month (IUMBEDR). Open Government Licence v3.0.
Check yourself
Look at the right-hand end of the chart. Where was Bank Rate by the end of 2022?
Check yourself
The key questions
Why can an interest rate not fall far below zero? And why did the Bank of England stop cutting its rate above zero in 2009?
In 2009 the Bank judged that further cuts would squeeze the profits of banks and building societies, and so their lending. More generally, savers can always hold cash, which pays nothing, so a rate far below zero would drive money out of banks.
What can a central bank do once its interest rate is close to zero?
Push the rate below zero, promise to keep it low, lend cheaply to banks on condition they lend, or create money and buy bonds. The Bank of England used the last three, starting with bond buying.
Did interest rates stay close to zero for long?
Yes. Japan's rate stayed close to zero for most of the time since 1999, and Bank Rate stayed close to zero until 2022.
The numbers
Check yourself
In March 2009 the Bank of England stopped cutting Bank Rate while it was still above zero. Which worry mattered most?
Check yourself
With Bank Rate cut close to zero in March 2009, what did the Bank of England turn to first?
Check yourself
After March 2009, how long did Bank Rate stay close to zero?