Learn › Economic history › Quantitative Easing

Quantitative Easing

The Cost of Quantitative Easing

Explain why quantitative easing first paid the Treasury and then began to cost it, why the Treasury carries the losses and what that does to the line between the Bank and the government, and why economists still disagree about whether it helped cause the inflation of 2022.

Before you start

What you'll be able to answer

  1. Why did the Bank of England's purchases of gilts (government bonds) first bring money to the Treasury, and then start costing it?
  2. Who pays when the purchases lose money? And why does that mean the Bank's interest rate decisions change what the government pays?
  3. Did the Bank's gilt purchases help cause the inflation of 2022?

Where this sits

Quantitative Easing · this module is lit

  1. 1998The Bank of England Act gives interest rate decisions to a committee at the Bank; the Chancellor keeps the target
  2. Mar 2009Bank Rate is cut to 0.5 per cent, and the Bank starts buying government bonds with newly created money
  3. Aug 2013The Bank says it will not consider raising interest rates at least until unemployment falls to 7 per cent
  4. Mar 2020Bank Rate is cut to a new low
  5. Jan 2022Banks' reserves at the Bank reach their highest level
  6. Sep 2022The Bank buys government bonds again, to stop forced selling by pension funds
  7. Oct 2022Consumer price inflation reaches 11.1 per cent
  8. Nov 2022The Bank starts selling its bonds to investors, among the first central banks to do so
  9. Aug 2023Bank Rate reaches its peak after rises at consecutive meetings
  10. Apr 2026The Governor writes an open letter to the Chancellor after inflation overshoots the target

In 2012 the Bank of England's gilts earned more than they cost to hold

In November 2012 the Bank of England held its gilts (government bonds) in a company it owned. That company had a growing pile of cash from the interest on the gilts. The Chancellor, George Osborne, is the minister in charge of the government's money. He and Mervyn King, the Governor (head) of the Bank, had to decide what to do with this extra cash, the surplus.

Take a guess

The company earns interest on its gilts. The Bank of England paid for the gilts with new money that it created. That money ended up in commercial banks' accounts at the Bank, where it forms the banks' reserves. The company borrowed this money from the Bank. It pays the Bank interest at Bank Rate, the Bank's own interest rate. When do you think the company makes a surplus?

The purchases made a surplus while Bank Rate stayed low

The company is the Asset Purchase Facility (APF), and it sits inside the Bank. Each gilt pays the APF a fixed rate of interest, set on the day the government first sold that gilt. The Bank charges the APF Bank Rate on the loan that bought its gilts. The Bank also pays Bank Rate to commercial banks on the reserves they hold with it. Unlike the gilt interest, Bank Rate can change. From 2009 Bank Rate stayed below the interest the gilts paid, so more came in than went out.

The APF's surplus had built up since 2009. The Treasury, the government department in charge of its money, had promised to cover any loss the APF made. So in the end, any gain or loss the APF made was the government's.

The Treasury could leave the surplus in the APF or take it

By November 2012 the APF held far more gilts than at the start. It was also expected to keep going for much longer than first planned. Its surplus was held as cash in an account. Passing the cash to the Treasury would let the government pay off some of its debt now. But the Governor expected Bank Rate to rise later and the gilts to be sold. Once Bank Rate rose, the APF would make losses. The Treasury would then have to pay most of the cash back to the APF. If the cash stayed in the APF, the money would already be there to cover those losses.

Your decision

You are the Chancellor in November 2012. What do you do with the surplus?

Money went to the Treasury for a decade, then flowed back

The APF's payments to the Treasury added up to £123.9 billion. That running total peaked at the end of September 2022. By then Bank Rate was rising. The APF pays Bank Rate on its loan from the Bank, so its costs were rising too. They began to exceed the interest its gilts paid. In October 2022 the Treasury made its first payment to the APF, and it has paid every quarter since.

Count everything since 2009. By the end of June 2026 the Treasury had received £16.2 billion more from the APF than it had paid to it. The Bank expects the Treasury to keep paying the APF until all the gilts are sold. The Bank also argues that its purchases made it cheaper for the government to borrow. On one set of the Bank's assumptions, the interest saved covers much or all of the Treasury's payments to the APF.

Check yourself

The section above gives two totals: £123.9 billion at the peak and £16.2 billion in June 2026. Roughly how many billion pounds did the Treasury pay the APF between October 2022 and June 2026?

The Treasury pays every loss, under a document published in 2024

The Treasury's promise to cover the APF's losses is a legal document, the Deed of Indemnity. In November 2023 a House of Lords committee asked again for it to be published. It said the deed "commits the taxpayer to paying any financial losses" from quantitative easing (QE). QE means the Bank buying gilts with money it created. On 19 November 2024, after a ruling by the Information Commissioner's Office, the Treasury released a partly blacked-out copy.

The economist Patrick Honohan wrote for the Peterson Institute in July 2025. The US Federal Reserve and the European Central Bank have no such promise, he points out. In Britain the Treasury pays promptly for each loss. Using the Bank's estimates, Honohan put the Treasury's payments from 2022 onwards, including future ones, at up to £280 billion. That is about 12 per cent of GDP (the value of a year's UK output).

Check yourself

Suppose Bank Rate rises again while the APF still holds many gilts. What happens to the payments between the Treasury and the APF?

Interest rate decisions now change what the government pays

In Britain the government sets the inflation target. The Bank sets the interest rate to meet that target. The Treasury has promised to cover the APF's losses, so the Bank's rate decisions now affect the government's budget. When the Bank raises Bank Rate to bring inflation down, the APF's losses grow. The Treasury then pays more to cover them.

The government has a rule that taxes should pay for its day-to-day spending. In Honohan's view, the payments to the APF have made that rule harder to keep. As a result, he says, the government has had less money for its plans. The Lords committee also asked for a clear split of jobs between the Bank and the Treasury. It wanted this split to be clear wherever interest rate decisions and government budgets affect each other.

Take a guess

The APF's losses come from paying Bank Rate on the money that bought its gilts, which sits as banks' reserves. If the Bank paid banks less than Bank Rate on part of their reserves, that cost would fall, and so would the Treasury's payments. Who do you think would decide whether to do it?

It is not clear who would decide to pay less interest on reserves

One way for the Bank to pay less interest on reserves is tiering. Under tiering, banks would probably have to hold a set amount of reserves that earn no interest, or less than Bank Rate. It is not clear whether the Bank or the Chancellor would make this decision. Both say they do not want to change the current arrangement.

The Governor, Andrew Bailey, says a law making banks hold a set amount of reserves would be fiscal policy. Fiscal policy means decisions on taxes and spending. He says it "must be enacted by the Government and Parliament". The government says monetary policy, meaning decisions on interest rates and QE, is for the Bank's Monetary Policy Committee. It says it has "no plans to change the way reserves are remunerated", that is, paid interest. So the cost carries on. Each side says the decision belongs to the other.

Inflation came back, and prices stayed higher than in 2021

Inflation came back after the pandemic. Consumer price inflation, the rise in prices over a year, reached 11.1 per cent in October 2022.

Inflation then fell. Slower inflation means prices are still rising, only more slowly. By June 2026 consumer prices were 30.7 per cent higher than in January 2021. The chart shows the level of prices each month, so a steeper line means faster inflation.

UK consumer prices, 2016 to 2026A monthly measure of UK prices. The level of prices in 2015 is set at 100.
95105115125135145201620182020202220242026January 2021Fastest yearly rise in prices, 11.1%

Source: Office for National Statistics, CPI index 00: all items (D7BT). Open Government Licence v3.0.

Check yourself

Look at the chart. How much did prices rise from January 2016 to January 2021? How much did they rise from January 2021 to January 2026? How do the two rises compare?

Whether the purchases helped cause the 2022 inflation is unsettled

Many commentators blame QE for part of the rise in prices after the pandemic. Neither study below measures that rise. A 2015 Peterson Institute report on the United States found that the inflation people feared from QE had not appeared so far.

In January 2024 the economist Tomasz Wieladek, of the investment firm T. Rowe Price, compared QE with interest rate cuts that moved interest rates by the same amount. Using data from before the pandemic, he found that in Britain and the United States QE raised inflation two to four times as much as the rate cuts did. He found no sign of a different effect on output, the amount the economy produces. The two studies cover different periods, so both can be right. Neither settles how much of the 2022 rise came from the purchases.

Check yourself

The key questions

Why did the Bank of England's purchases of gilts (government bonds) first bring money to the Treasury, and then start costing it?

Who pays when the purchases lose money? And why does that mean the Bank's interest rate decisions change what the government pays?

Did the Bank's gilt purchases help cause the inflation of 2022?

The numbers

Payments from the APF to the Treasury at their peak, end of September 2022 (Bank of England)
Net total passed to the Treasury, counting the surplus built up since 2009, end of June 2026 (Bank of England)
Possible payments from the Treasury from 2022 on, on the Bank's published estimates (Honohan, Peterson Institute)
Consumer price inflation, October 2022 (ONS)
Rise in consumer prices, January 2021 to June 2026 (Commons Library)

Check yourself

Why did money flow from the APF to the Treasury for a decade, and then the other way?

Check yourself

How settled is the question of whether quantitative easing helped cause the inflation of 2022?

Check yourself

Who pays when the APF makes a loss?