Before you start
What you'll be able to answer
- What did the Bank of England's own economists say the first round of bond buying did to output and inflation?
- Why might the Bank's bond buying have a bigger effect at some times than at others?
- Why did a House of Lords committee and the Bank of England disagree about the bond buying?
Where this sits
Quantitative Easing · this module is lit
- 1998The Bank of England Act gives interest rate decisions to a committee at the Bank; the Chancellor keeps the target
- Mar 2009Bank Rate is cut to 0.5 per cent, and the Bank starts buying government bonds with newly created money
- Aug 2013The Bank says it will not consider raising interest rates at least until unemployment falls to 7 per cent
- Mar 2020Bank Rate is cut to a new low
- Jan 2022Banks' reserves at the Bank reach their highest level
- Sep 2022The Bank buys government bonds again, to stop forced selling by pension funds
- Oct 2022Consumer price inflation reaches 11.1 per cent
- Nov 2022The Bank starts selling its bonds to investors, among the first central banks to do so
- Aug 2023Bank Rate reaches its peak after rises at consecutive meetings
- Apr 2026The Governor writes an open letter to the Chancellor after inflation overshoots the target
A House of Lords committee asked what twelve years of bond buying had done
In July 2021 the Economic Affairs Committee of the House of Lords published a report. Its title was a question: "Quantitative easing: a dangerous addiction?" Since 2009 the Bank of England had been buying gilts, the government's bonds, on and off, and it still was. Quantitative easing is the name for this buying. The committee had heard from economists in Britain and abroad. It wanted to know what the buying had done to output (how much the economy produces) and to prices, and whether anyone could measure those effects.
Economists at the Bank of England estimated how much the first round of buying raised the country's output. How large do you think their estimate was?
Between 1 and 5 per cent: the next section gives their range.
Bank economists said the first round raised inflation as much as a large rate cut
In 2011 three Bank of England economists studied the first £200 billion of gilt buying, by January 2010. They said the buying lowered long-term interest rates and raised the prices of shares and bonds. Households and firms then spent more, raising output and then prices.
Their models estimated what would have happened without the buying. At its peak, the buying raised output by 1.5 to 2 per cent and inflation by ¾ to 1½ percentage points. They reckoned the same rise in inflation would have needed a cut of 150 to 300 basis points (hundredths of a percentage point) in Bank Rate, the Bank's main interest rate.
In 2009 Bank Rate was 0.5 per cent, about as low as it could go. The Monetary Policy Committee sets interest rates. It judged that spending would be too weak for inflation to reach the Bank's target. So it began buying gilts.
Researchers compared studies of quantitative easing by economists at central banks with studies by university economists. Which reported larger effects on output?
The central bank studies.
Central bank studies find larger effects than academic ones
In 2020 Brian Fabo, Martina Jančoková, Elisabeth Kempf and Ľuboš Pástor compared the two kinds of study for the National Bureau of Economic Research, a US research body. Papers by central bank economists reported larger effects of quantitative easing on output and inflation than papers by academic economists did. Central bank economists who reported larger effects on output also tended to do better in their careers. The authors' first title for the paper was "Fifty Shades of QE: Conflicts of Interest in Economic Research".
The Bank of England's own Independent Evaluation Office reports to the Bank's board. In 2021 it added a caution. There is less research on how the buying affected output and inflation than on how it affected bond yields, the interest rates that bonds pay. Effects on output and inflation take longer to appear. They are also harder to separate from everything else going on.
Check yourself
Bank Rate was 0.5 per cent. The smaller cut the Bank's economists named was 150 basis points, which is 1.5 percentage points. How many times 0.5 per cent was that cut?
3
Three times: 150 basis points is 1.5 percentage points, three times 0.5 per cent.
Check yourself
Suppose the buying had lowered long-term interest rates, but households and firms had spent no more than before. In the chain of effects the Bank's economists described, what would that have meant for output?
The buying moves bond prices more in a crisis
Studies find that the effect depends on when the buying happens. In a crisis, many investors are held back by what they already hold and owe. They cannot take on more bonds. So few investors can buy the bonds that others want to sell, and a large buyer moves prices a great deal. In calm markets, other investors are free to trade. So the same amount of buying moves prices less.
Isabel Schnabel is a member of the European Central Bank's Executive Board. In May 2024 she cited evidence from the countries that use the euro. It suggests the effect on long-term interest rates could be as much as 40 per cent smaller outside a crisis. The Bank of England has said the buying may work best when markets are not functioning normally. The Lords committee found strong evidence that the buying works in a crisis.
Check yourself
Why does the same amount of buying move bond prices less in calm markets than in a crisis?
Output fell before the buying began and took years to recover
Output is measured as GDP: the value of everything the economy produces, with price rises taken out. UK output began to fall in 2008. By the middle of 2009 it was about 6 per cent below its peak early in 2008. It then grew slowly. The chart shows how long it took to get back to that peak.
The line cannot show what the buying did, because much else changed at the same time. So the Bank's economists compared what happened with an estimate of what would have happened without the buying. Nobody can observe what would have happened without the buying. The Lords committee said this is difficult to establish.
Source: Office for National Statistics, GDP chained volume measures, seasonally adjusted (ABMI). Open Government Licence v3.0.
Check yourself
Look at the chart. In which year did output first get back above its level early in 2008?
The Lords committee concluded that the purchases had done little for growth over the decade. What do you think the Bank of England said?
It disagreed, and said the research did not support the conclusion.
The Lords committee and the Bank disagreed about the decade after 2009
The committee concluded that the buying in 2009, along with extra government borrowing, had prevented a repeat of the Great Depression. But over the previous decade, it concluded, quantitative easing had had "a limited impact" on growth and on total spending in the economy. It noted that central bank research tends to find better results for the buying than academic research does. The committee also found little evidence that the buying had raised bank lending, investment, or spending by wealthy people who own assets.
The Bank replied in September 2021. It said the research that exists does not support the committee's finding of a limited impact. It cited its own economists' estimates. The committee's two conclusions clashed, the Bank said. If the buying had only a limited effect on spending, it could not have stopped a repeat of the Great Depression.
The committee also asked Parliament to check the Bank's work more
In 2021 the committee said the Bank published too little about how the buying affects the economy. Without that detail, Parliament and the public could not check the Bank's decisions. In November 2023 it asked for more.
Since 1997 the Bank has set interest rates, instead of ministers. The Bank of England Act 1998 made this law. This is the Bank's independence. The committee said that if ministers challenged the Bank's decisions, they would harm that independence. So Parliament has to check the Bank's work. The committee said a "democratic deficit" had emerged: elected people did not check the Bank's big decisions enough. It recommended a review by Parliament of the Bank's job, results and workings every five years.
The Bank's Governor, Andrew Bailey, replied in January 2024. He said the Bank answers to Parliament. He added that many recommendations were for the government or Parliament, not the Bank.
Check yourself
Did the Lords committee and the Bank disagree about whether the first round of buying in 2009 helped?
Check yourself
The key questions
What did the Bank of England's own economists say the first round of bond buying did to output and inflation?
They used models to estimate what would have happened without the buying. On that estimate, output and inflation both rose. The rise in inflation was about what a large cut in Bank Rate would have caused. Central bank studies tend to find larger effects than academic ones.
Why might the Bank's bond buying have a bigger effect at some times than at others?
Studies find the buying works best in a crisis. Few investors can buy then, so a large buyer moves prices a great deal. In calm markets, other investors trade against it. An ECB board member, Isabel Schnabel, said euro-area evidence suggests the effect on long-term interest rates could be markedly smaller outside a crisis.
Why did a House of Lords committee and the Bank of England disagree about the bond buying?
The committee said the buying helped in 2009. It also said the buying had a limited impact on growth over the next decade. The Bank said the research does not support that finding of a limited impact. Separately, the committee wanted Parliament to review the Bank every five years. The Bank said it already answers to Parliament.
The numbers
Check yourself
What did the Bank of England's economists estimate the first round of bond buying did to output and inflation?
Check yourself
When do studies find that the bond buying moves interest rates most?
Check yourself
What did the Lords committee recommend in 2023 so that the Bank would answer more fully for its decisions?