Before you start
What you'll be able to answer
- Which households gained most when the Bank of England bought gilts (government bonds), and why?
- What did the Bank of England's gilt purchases do to the gap between higher and lower incomes?
- Why do a House of Lords committee and the Bank of England disagree about whether the gilt purchases made wealth in Britain more unequal?
- Why does the government's interest bill now rise as soon as Bank Rate, the Bank of England's main interest rate, goes up?
Where this sits
Quantitative Easing · this module is lit
- 1998The Bank of England Act gives interest rate decisions to a committee at the Bank; the Chancellor keeps the target
- Mar 2009Bank Rate is cut to 0.5 per cent, and the Bank starts buying government bonds with newly created money
- Aug 2013The Bank says it will not consider raising interest rates at least until unemployment falls to 7 per cent
- Mar 2020Bank Rate is cut to a new low
- Jan 2022Banks' reserves at the Bank reach their highest level
- Sep 2022The Bank buys government bonds again, to stop forced selling by pension funds
- Oct 2022Consumer price inflation reaches 11.1 per cent
- Nov 2022The Bank starts selling its bonds to investors, among the first central banks to do so
- Aug 2023Bank Rate reaches its peak after rises at consecutive meetings
- Apr 2026The Governor writes an open letter to the Chancellor after inflation overshoots the target
The Bank of England set out who had gained from its gilt purchases
On 12 July 2012 the Bank of England published a paper on who had gained and who had lost from its purchases of gilts. Gilts are bonds that the UK government sells to borrow money. Bank Rate, the Bank's main interest rate, had been 0.5 per cent since March 2009. Savers were earning little. The Bank sets its policy for the whole economy, the paper said. But any policy change helps some households more than others.
The Bank's purchases pushed up the prices of shares and bonds. Which households do you think gained the most, in pounds?
Households that already owned the most: the next section shows why.
Higher prices for shares and bonds made the households that owned them richer
The Bank bought gilts from investors. The investors used the money to buy other assets, such as company shares and bonds. With more buyers, the prices of those assets rose. Anyone who owned them became richer, and the more they owned, the more pounds they gained.
The Bank estimated that its first round of buying raised households' financial wealth by about 16 per cent. Financial wealth means savings and investments, minus debts. The estimate counts part of households' pensions.
Ownership was very uneven. Line up households from the least to the most financial assets. In a 2011 survey for the Bank, the household in the middle (the median) held about £1,500 in savings accounts, shares and other financial assets, not counting pensions. The richest 5 per cent of households held £175,000 each on average. Between them, they held about two-fifths of all households' financial assets.
A research body, the Resolution Foundation, estimated that the wealthiest tenth of families took the largest share of the gain
In 2019 the Resolution Foundation, a research body that studies living standards, estimated who gained wealth from the purchases. It compared Great Britain in 2006-08 with 2012-14. It used the Bank's own estimates of what the purchases did. The Bank's survey had counted financial assets only. The Foundation also counted gains from higher house prices and private pension pots. It also counted the effect of inflation: rising prices make savings worth less and debts easier to repay.
Add up the gains of all families. On the Foundation's estimate, 40 per cent of that total went to the wealthiest tenth of families. Only 12 per cent went to the whole bottom half.
Check yourself
A family rents its home and keeps all its savings in a bank account. Why did the rise in asset prices do little for it?
The purchases also helped protect jobs and pay. Measured as a share of their income, which households do you think gained most from that protection?
Households in the bottom half by income. The next section shows why.
On the Resolution Foundation's estimate, support for jobs and pay helped the bottom half most
The purchases supported the economy, and that kept spending up. More spending meant more people kept or found work. With fewer people out of work, pay rose faster. The Resolution Foundation estimated that this raised incomes by 4.3 per cent for households in the bottom half by income. For the top half, the rise was 3.2 per cent. The difference arose because the jobs protected were more often held by lower earners. Incomes at the bottom rose by a bigger share, so on the Foundation's estimate the gap in incomes narrowed.
Ben Broadbent, a Deputy Governor of the Bank, made the same point to the House of Lords Economic Affairs Committee. The House of Lords is Parliament's upper chamber. Broadbent said the purchases had narrowed the gap between high and low incomes "at the margin", meaning a little. They did so by limiting job losses among lower-paid workers.
The Lords committee and the Bank disagreed about how to measure the gains
In July 2021 the committee said the purchases had "benefited wealthy asset holders disproportionately by artificially inflating asset prices". It also said "quantitative easing has exacerbated wealth inequalities". Quantitative easing is the name for the Bank's gilt buying. Put simply, the committee said the wealthy gained more than their share, and the buying made wealth gaps worse.
The Bank replied in September 2021 that owners had gained in proportion to what they held. If every asset rises by the same percentage, a larger holding gains more pounds. The Bank said those bigger pound gains reflect how unequal wealth already was.
In 2019 the Resolution Foundation had measured the gains two ways: in pounds, and as a share of what each group already had. Higher asset prices widened the gap in pounds. As a share, gains were broadly similar across wealth groups. So on that measure, wealth inequality barely changed.
Check yourself
Work from the Bank's argument: suppose every household's financial assets rose in value by 10 per cent. The median household, in the middle with £1,500, gains £150. How many pounds does a household in the top 5 per cent, with £175,000, gain?
£17500
£17,500. Both gains are 10 per cent of what each household already had. But the gap between them in pounds grows by £17,350 (£17,500 minus £150).
Savers earned far less interest, and the Bank said cuts in Bank Rate were the main cause
Savers lost out. Banks set the interest on most savings accounts in line with short-term interest rates. Those rates move with Bank Rate. So when Bank Rate fell, savers' interest fell too. The Bank took the interest households were getting in September 2008 as its starting level. Compared with that level, households had received about £70 billion less interest in total by April 2012. The Bank said this fall came mostly from cuts in Bank Rate. Its gilt purchases mattered much less. The chart shows the interest rate on households' instant-access savings accounts.
Source: Bank of England Database, effective interest rate on households' interest-bearing sight deposits (CFMHSCV). Open Government Licence v3.0.
Check yourself
Look at the chart. Through 2010 and 2011, roughly what rate did households earn on these accounts?
The Bank paid for the gilts with new money it created, called reserves. Commercial banks hold this money in accounts at the Bank, and the Bank pays interest on it at Bank Rate. When Bank Rate rises today, who do you think receives the extra interest?
The commercial banks that hold the reserves. The next section shows why.
After the purchases, part of the government's interest bill moves with Bank Rate
The Bank pays Bank Rate on the reserves it created. It earns fixed interest on its gilts. If Bank Rate is above that, the Bank makes a loss. The Treasury, the government's finance department, covers it. So a higher Bank Rate costs the government more, even on fixed-rate gilts.
In March 2021 the Office for Budget Responsibility, the official forecaster, looked at short- and long-term rates both one percentage point above its forecast. The 2025-26 interest bill would then be £20.8 billion higher. That is 0.8 per cent of GDP, the total value of what the economy produces in a year.
In October 2022 Paul Tucker, a former central banker, wrote for the Institute for Fiscal Studies. He proposed paying little or nothing on a large part of the reserves. That could save £30 billion to £45 billion in each of the next two financial years.
Check yourself
Imagine the Bank had bought no gilts. Then all the government's debt would still be gilts paying a fixed rate. What would a rise in interest rates have done to its interest bill?
Check yourself
The key questions
Which households gained most when the Bank of England bought gilts (government bonds), and why?
The purchases pushed up the prices of shares, bonds and other assets. The more a household owned, the more pounds it gained, and ownership was very uneven.
What did the Bank of England's gilt purchases do to the gap between higher and lower incomes?
On the Resolution Foundation's estimate, the purchases narrowed the gap between higher and lower incomes. Their support for jobs and pay mattered most for lower earners. Ben Broadbent, a Deputy Governor of the Bank, said the same.
Why do a House of Lords committee and the Bank of England disagree about whether the gilt purchases made wealth in Britain more unequal?
The committee says asset holders gained more than their share and wealth inequality got worse. The Bank says they gained in proportion to what they held, which reflects existing gaps in wealth. On the Resolution Foundation's estimate, the gap in pounds widened. Gains as a share of existing wealth were broadly similar across wealth groups. Income gaps narrowed.
Why does the government's interest bill now rise as soon as Bank Rate, the Bank of England's main interest rate, goes up?
The Bank bought gilts, which pay fixed interest, with reserves it created. It pays Bank Rate on those reserves to the banks that hold them. So when Bank Rate rises, the Bank's costs rise at once, and the Treasury covers any loss.
The numbers
Check yourself
Why did the largest share of the gain in pounds from higher asset prices go to households that were already wealthy?
Check yourself
On the Resolution Foundation's estimate, what did the purchases' support for jobs and pay do to the gap in incomes?
Check yourself
The Lords committee said the purchases helped asset holders by more than their share ("disproportionately"). What did the Bank reply?
Check yourself
What interest rate does the Bank pay on the reserves it created to buy the gilts?