- Labour-leisure budget constraint
- A labour-leisure budget constraint shows every combination of leisure and income a person can have, given the hours available and the wage paid for each hour worked.
- Backward-bending labour supply curve
- A backward-bending labour supply curve is one on which the hours a person offers rise with the wage at first and then fall as the wage rises further.
Why a wage rise pulls two ways
Can you name the three ideas that decide how a wage rise changes the hours you work?
At A-level the labour supply curve slopes up: a higher wage draws out more hours. Put the choice on an indifference curve diagram and a wage rise turns out to be a price change like any other, with a substitution effect and an income effect.
The price of leisure is the wage: each hour not worked costs the pay that hour would have earned.
Can you think of an example?
A shop worker on £12 an hour who takes Saturday afternoon off gives up about £48 for four hours. Her wage rises to £15, and the same afternoon now costs £60, so leisure has become dearer.
The substitution effect of a wage rise is the move towards more work and less leisure, because leisure's opportunity cost has increased.
Can you think of an example?
At a higher hourly rate each hour of overtime earns more, so, holding her level of wellbeing fixed, a worker gives up some evenings off to work extra shifts.
The income effect of a wage rise is the move towards more of both leisure and income, since both are normal goods and the person is better off.
Can you think of an example?
A freelance designer's day rate rises by a third, so she is better off. Being better off, she wants more time as well as more money: she takes Fridays off, and four days still pay more than five used to.
Your hourly wage rises from £8 to £16. Will you work more hours, fewer, or can economics not say?
Both first answers are half right. Work pays more per hour, which pulls towards more hours, but you are also richer, which pulls towards more leisure. Which wins depends on the person.
BeforeAt £8 an hour the best choice is A on IC1: L1 hours of leisure and income Y1.
The wage rise pivots out the budget line, so the choice moves from A to B: income rises from Y1 to Y3 and leisure from L1 to L3.
- The line ends at 80 hours of leisure and no income, which no wage can change. Its slope is minus the wage, so a rise from £8 to £16 an hour pivots it out and steeper around that end.
- Substitution: the compensated line CL has the new slope but touches the old curve IC1, at C. Leisure is dearer, so leisure falls from L1 to L2, about 28 hours, and work rises.
- Income: shifting CL out to BL2 takes the worker to IC2 at B. Here the income effect is larger, so leisure ends at L3, 48 hours, more than the 40 at A: she works 32 hours and earns £512, up from £320.
Check yourself
The wage rises and the budget line pivots from BL1 to BL2. A is the old choice. At which new choice is the substitution effect on leisure stronger than the income effect?
D is straight above A: the same leisure, so the same hours worked. The two effects on leisure exactly cancel and all the gain is taken as income.
F has less leisure than A, so the worker works more hours. The substitution effect towards work has outweighed the income effect towards leisure.
G has more leisure than A, so the worker works fewer hours. The income effect has won, as it did for the worker at B earlier.
Low wagesAt low wages the substitution effect wins: a higher wage brings more hours, so SL slopes up.
At low wages hours rise with the wage, but as the wage rises from W1 to W2 the curve bends back and hours fall from H1 to H2.
- Each point on the labour supply curve is a best choice from the labour-leisure diagram at one wage. Where the substitution effect wins, hours rise with the wage and the curve slopes up.
- Income effects grow as the wage rises, because the same hours now bring a much higher income. Past some wage, more leisure is worth more to the worker than more pay.
- Then a further rise, from W1 to W2, cuts hours from H1 to H2 and the curve bends back. For a whole market the curve usually still slopes up, because higher wages draw in new workers.
Check yourself
A worker's hourly wage rises. Which pair of effects does the wage rise have on the hours of leisure she takes?
Doesn't a higher wage always mean more hours of work?
Not for every person. A higher wage makes leisure dearer, so it pulls towards more work: that is the substitution effect. But it also makes the worker better off, and a better-off person wants more leisure as well as more income: that is the income effect. A worker whose income effect is stronger responds to a raise by working fewer hours. Some take all the gain as income and work the same hours; others work more. The upward-sloping curve at A-level is the case where substitution wins.
Put leisure on the horizontal axis, not hours worked, and read work as the gap between the leisure chosen and the hours available. The budget line's slope is minus the wage, so a wage rise pivots it around the all-leisure end. Then split the move with a compensated line, name which effect wins, and read off the hours.
Exam question
Does a cut in income tax make people work more? [4]
Not necessarily. A lower tax rate raises the take-home wage, which pivots the labour-leisure budget line out. The substitution effect makes leisure dearer and pulls towards more hours. The income effect makes people better off and pulls towards more leisure. Hours rise only if the substitution effect is stronger, so the answer depends on preferences. Second earners and people deciding whether to work at all tend to respond most; many full-time workers barely change. The model assumes people can choose their hours; many jobs come with fixed hours.
Treat the tax cut as a wage rise, split it into the two effects, and say the outcome is an empirical question. Knowing that responses differ between groups, and naming the fixed-hours assumption, is what lifts an interview answer.
Exam question
You win £1 million on the lottery. Would you keep working the same hours? What does that tell an economist? [4]
A lottery win is a pure income effect: it shifts the budget line out parallel without changing the wage, so leisure is no dearer. With leisure a normal good, the model predicts more leisure and fewer hours, and many winners do cut back or retire. Comparing this with a wage rise shows why wage rises are ambiguous: they add a substitution effect towards work that a windfall lacks. The prediction assumes leisure is normal and work is valued only for its pay; people who enjoy their work, or value its status, may not cut back at all.
Spot that a windfall changes income but not the price of leisure, so only the income effect operates. Using it to explain why a wage rise is ambiguous, and naming the assumption that work gives no satisfaction of its own, shows real understanding.
Exam question
Hospitals raise overtime pay for doctors, and some senior doctors respond by taking on fewer extra shifts. Is that irrational? [4]
No. Higher pay per extra shift makes an evening off dearer, a substitution effect towards more shifts. But a doctor who already works many extra shifts gains on all of them, so the income effect can be large, and someone already well off may value time off highly. If the income effect wins, the individual's supply curve bends back and fewer shifts is a rational choice. Other forces can push the same way, such as tax rules that take a large share of extra pay. It assumes shifts are optional and doctors know what each one earns.
The best answer says the behaviour is consistent with the model: the income effect is large for someone already working many extra shifts, which can put them on the backward-bending part of the curve. Mentioning that tax can cut the effective wage, and that shifts must be optional, tests the assumptions.
Put leisure on one axis and income on the other. The budget line ends at all the available hours taken as leisure, and its slope is minus the wage. A wage rise pivots it out. The substitution effect pulls towards work, because leisure is dearer; the income effect pulls towards leisure, because the worker is better off. If the income effect wins, hours fall and the individual labour supply curve bends back.