Learn › Economic theory › Advanced theory

Advanced theory

Nash equilibrium and the prisoner's dilemma

Find a Nash equilibrium and say why it can leave both players worse off

Specification: AQA 4.1.5.5 Edexcel 3.4.4

Game theory turns oligopoly interdependence into a table of payoffs

At A-level, oligopoly means interdependence: each firm's best move depends on what its rivals do. Game theory makes that exact. It studies situations in which players make decisions and then receive payoffs that depend on what the other players decide. Take two firms choosing whether to advertise. Advertising costs money and mostly wins customers from the rival, so if both advertise the gains cancel out and only the costs remain.

The advertising game: profits in £ million, Firm A firstA two-by-two payoff matrix. Rows are Firm A advertising or not; columns are Firm B advertising or not. Both advertise: 3 and 3. A advertises, B does not: 6 and 2. B advertises, A does not: 2 and 6. Neither advertises: 5 and 5.B: AdvertiseB: Don'tA: AdvertiseA: Don't3, 36, 22, 65, 5
Each cell gives Firm A's profit, then Firm B's, in £ million. Illustrative figures.
Take a guess

Two firms can advertise or not. Advertising costs money and mainly steals customers from the rival. What do you think they end up doing?

Advertising is the best reply whatever the rival does, so both advertise

Take Firm A's side. If B advertises, A earns £3 million by advertising and £2 million by not, so A advertises. If B does not advertise, A earns £6 million by advertising and £5 million by not, so A advertises again. Advertising is A's dominant strategy: the one it will pursue regardless of B's decision. B's position is the mirror image, so both advertise and each earns £3 million.

Check yourself

In the advertising game, why does Firm A advertise even when it is sure Firm B will not?

Both firms would do better holding back, yet neither can get there alone

If neither advertised, each would earn £5 million instead of £3 million. Both prefer that outcome, but neither can reach it alone: a firm that holds back while its rival advertises falls to £2 million. This is a prisoner's dilemma, where the gains from cooperation are larger than the rewards from pursuing self-interest. The outcome in which both advertise is Pareto-inferior: another outcome makes both players better off and leaves nobody worse off.

Check yourself

Which statement about the outcome in which both firms advertise is true?

An equilibrium needs no dominant strategy, and a game can have two

Both advertising is a Nash equilibrium: given what the other does, neither firm can gain by changing its own choice. Many games have no dominant strategy. Two carmakers choosing a charging socket each want to match the other. Both picking socket X is an equilibrium, and so is both picking socket Y, because neither gains by switching alone. The model says where play can come to rest, not which resting point is reached: history, convention or a regulator picks.

Check yourself

Two firms each choose to expand or hold. In each cell Firm A's profit comes first, then Firm B's, in £ million. Which cell is the Nash equilibrium?

Expand or hold: profits in £ million, Firm A firstA two-by-two payoff matrix with four cells, P, Q, R and S. Rows are Firm A expanding or holding; columns are Firm B expanding or holding. P: 4 and 2. Q: 7 and 3. R: 3 and 5. S: 6 and 4.B: ExpandB: HoldA: ExpandA: HoldP: 4, 2Q: 7, 3R: 3, 5S: 6, 4
Key terms
Nash equilibrium
A Nash equilibrium is a set of strategies, one for each player, in which no player can do better by changing strategy while the others keep theirs.
Dominant strategy
A dominant strategy is a choice that gives a player a higher payoff than any alternative, whatever the other players choose.

Four ideas for reading a two-player game

Can you name the four ideas you need to read a two-player game?

Common mistake

Doesn't a Nash equilibrium mean the best outcome for everyone?

No. A Nash equilibrium is a resting point: no player can do better by changing alone. The advertising game shows the gap. Both advertising is the equilibrium, yet both holding back would give each firm £5 million instead of £3 million. The equilibrium test moves one player at a time; the efficiency test asks whether some other outcome would make everyone better off together. A game's equilibrium can pass that test or fail it, and a game with two equilibria can have one that is better for both players than the other.

Exam tip

To find the equilibrium in a two-by-two matrix, take each player in turn. For each of the rival's strategies, mark the player's best reply. A cell where both payoffs are marked is a Nash equilibrium. Then ask whether any other cell makes both players better off. In an interview, say the method aloud as you go: the interviewer is listening to how you reason, not only to the answer.

Exam question

Two petrol stations face each other across a road. Both would earn more if both charged a high price, yet they keep undercutting each other. Is that an equilibrium, and is it a good outcome? [4]

Exam question

Britain drives on the left and most of Europe on the right. Is either side better, and what would it take for Britain to switch? [4]

Exam question

Two drivers meet at a bridge only wide enough for one car. Draw me the game. Where does it come to rest, and who wins? [4]

What to take away

A game sets out players, strategies and payoffs, often in a payoff matrix. A dominant strategy is best whatever the rival does. A Nash equilibrium is a set of choices where no player gains by changing alone. In a prisoner's dilemma each player's dominant strategy leads to an equilibrium that is Pareto-inferior: both would do better cooperating. A coordination game has more than one equilibrium, and history or rules decide which one is reached.