- Substitution effect
- The substitution effect is the change in the quantity bought because a price change makes one good relatively cheaper and another relatively dearer.
- Income effect
- The income effect is the change in the quantity bought because a price change alters the buying power of a given income.
The pieces of the split
Can you name the four ideas you need to split a price change in two?
At A-level a demand curve slopes down because a cheaper good is bought instead of others and leaves buyers better off. These four ideas pull those two reasons apart on an indifference curve diagram.
A compensated budget line is drawn parallel to the new budget line but tangent to the original indifference curve, so relative prices change and utility does not.
Can you think of an example?
The price of X falls and the budget line pivots out. Slide the new line back in, keeping its slope, until it just touches the old curve. What it slides back is the gain in buying power; the rest is pure substitution.
A normal good is one where a rise in income leads to a rise in the quantity consumed, and a fall in income to a fall.
Can you think of an example?
Cinema tickets get cheaper. They are now cheaper than other nights out, so you swap towards them, and the money saved buys more of everything, tickets included. Both effects push the same way.
An inferior good is one whose quantity consumed falls as income rises, because people can now afford the more expensive choices they prefer.
Can you think of an example?
Own-brand beans get cheaper, so you swap towards them. But the saving leaves you better off, and some of it goes back on the branded tin, so the income effect pulls the quantity of own-brand beans down.
A Giffen good is an inferior good whose income effect is larger than its substitution effect, so a rise in its price raises the quantity demanded.
Can you think of an example?
Robert Jensen and Nolan Miller gave poor households in Hunan, China, vouchers that cut the price of rice. Some bought less rice and more meat: rice took so much of their budget that the saving let them trade up.
Check yourself
The price of a good falls. Which of these is always true, whatever kind of good it is?
BeforeOn BL1 the best choice is A on IC1, with X1 of good X.
Holding utility at IC1, the cheaper X moves the choice along IC1 from A to C, and the quantity of X rises from X1 to X2.
- The price of X falls, so the budget line pivots out around the other-goods end, from BL1 to BL2. It is flatter because X now costs less of other goods.
- Draw the compensated line CL parallel to BL2 and tangent to IC1. It has the new relative prices but leaves the consumer no better off than at A.
- CL touches IC1 at C, further right than A. The move from A to C is the substitution effect, and on a convex curve it always raises the quantity of the good that got cheaper.
Check yourself
The price of X has fallen. Label each of the three lines.
Curve L: Original budget line. L is the steepest line and touches U at the old choice. It shows the old prices, when X cost more of other goods.
Curve M: New budget line. M starts at the same point on the other-goods axis as L but reaches further along X, because the same income now buys more X.
Curve N: Compensated budget line. N is parallel to M, so it has the new relative prices, but it is pulled in to touch the original curve U, so utility is unchanged.
The substitution effect has moved the choice from X1 to X2. Now give back the extra buying power. If X is an inferior good, what happens to the quantity of X?
For an inferior good, more buying power means less of it, as people trade up. So the income effect pulls the quantity back from X2. Only if it pulls back past X1 is X a Giffen good.
After substitutionThe substitution effect has taken the choice from A to C on IC1: X1 to X2.
Giving back the buying power shifts CL out to BL2, so the choice moves from C to B on IC2 and a normal good X rises from X2 to X3.
- CL and BL2 are parallel, so relative prices are the same on both. The move from C to B is caused only by the higher buying power the price fall created: the income effect.
- Here X is a normal good, so B lies to the right of C. The total rise from X1 to X3 is the substitution effect, X1 to X2, plus the income effect, X2 to X3.
- Had X been inferior, B would lie to the left of C. If it lay even left of A, the income effect would outweigh the substitution effect and X would be a Giffen good.
Check yourself
The price of X falls, pivoting BL1 out to BL2. A is the old choice and C the substitution-effect point. Which new choice would make X a Giffen good?
P has more X than C, so the income effect added to the substitution effect. X is a normal good here.
Q has less X than C but more than A. The income effect is negative, so X is inferior, but the substitution effect is larger and quantity still rises.
R has less X than A. The negative income effect outweighs the substitution effect, so a cheaper X is bought in smaller quantity: a Giffen good.
Does the income effect mean my income has changed?
No. Money income is exactly the same before and after. The income effect is about buying power: when the price of something you buy falls, the same pounds stretch further, as if you were a little richer, and when it rises they stretch less far. It might be more accurate to call it a buying-power effect. On the diagram that is why the income effect is a parallel shift between CL and BL2: relative prices stay fixed and only buying power changes.
Draw it in a fixed order: old line and tangency A, new line pivoted around the end on the axis of the good whose price did not change, then the compensated line parallel to the new one and touching the old curve at C, then the new tangency B. Label A to C as substitution and C to B as income, and say whether the good is normal, inferior or Giffen from where B sits.
Exam question
Petrol doubles in price. Why might a family that drives a lot cut back on holidays as well as on driving? [4]
The substitution effect makes driving dearer relative to other things, so the family drives less and switches towards buses or trains. The income effect is the bigger story for a family whose budget goes heavily on petrol: the same income now buys much less, so they cut back on normal goods across the board, holidays included. The larger the share of the budget a good takes, the larger its income effect. The answer assumes holidays are a normal good and that the family cannot easily avoid driving in the short run.
Name both effects, apply each to the family, and explain why the income effect is large here: petrol takes a big share of the budget. Then flag the assumptions, holidays being normal and driving hard to cut quickly.
Exam question
Can a higher price ever make people buy more of something? Why is it so rare? [4]
Yes: theory allows it for a Giffen good, and Jensen and Miller found it for rice among poor households in Hunan. It must be inferior, and its income effect must outweigh the substitution effect. A rise in the price of a staple like rice leaves a very poor household much poorer, so it cuts back on meat and fills the gap with more rice. That needs the good to be inferior and to take a large share of the budget, with no close substitutes, which is a rare combination. Luxury goods bought for status, whose appeal rises with price, are a different story about tastes, not this income effect.
A strong answer gives both conditions (inferior, and income effect bigger than substitution), explains why a large budget share makes the income effect big, and says why the combination is rare. Separating it from status goods is the extra an interviewer probes for.
Exam question
Bus fares fall, yet some people take fewer buses. How can that be? [4]
Cheaper buses have a substitution effect that always pulls towards more bus trips. But the lower fare also raises buying power. For some people bus travel is an inferior good: with more to spend, they switch to taxis or put money towards a car. If that income effect is stronger than the substitution effect, their bus trips fall. For regular commuters the fare saving is small against their budget, so this is unlikely for most; the answer assumes buses really are inferior for this group.
The interviewer wants the split: substitution always raises bus use, the income effect of an inferior good cuts it, and the result depends on which is larger. Noting that the income effect is small when fares are a small share of the budget shows judgement.
A price change has two effects. The substitution effect is the move along the original indifference curve to the point where a line with the new slope touches it, and it always shifts spending towards the good that got cheaper. The income effect is the parallel shift from that compensated line to the new budget line. It raises the quantity of a normal good and lowers that of an inferior good; if it outweighs substitution, the good is a Giffen good.