Learn › Economic history › The 2008 Financial Crisis

The 2008 Financial Crisis

The Collapse of Lehman Brothers

The Lehman weekend

Nine steps, about fourteen minutes, a question at each and one decision you take yourself. You need no economics and no preparation, only a willingness to guess before you are told.

Step 1 of 9

The question

Twice in six months, American officials saved a firm that had run out of money. The third time, they did not. After that, much of the rest of the financial system had to be rescued.

In March 2008 Bear Stearns, an American investment bank, could not borrow the money it needed to keep going. It was sold to another bank with a loan from the Federal Reserve, America's central bank. In September the American government took control of two big mortgage companies. Everyone had always assumed the government would pay those two companies' debts if they got into trouble. Eight days after that takeover, Lehman Brothers, another investment bank, ran out of money too.

What you'll be able to answer

  1. Why did the market expect a large firm that ran out of money to be rescued?
  2. Why was Lehman Brothers not rescued, and why is that still argued over?
  3. What did the authorities do after Lehman Brothers failed?
Where this sits in the series

The 2008 Financial Crisis · this module is lit

  1. Jul 2006American house prices peak
  2. Aug 2007Lending between banks stops
  3. Sep 2007Savers queue at Northern Rock
  4. Mar 2008Bear Stearns is rescued
  5. Sep 2008Lehman Brothers fails and the runs spread
  6. Oct 2008Britain buys shares in its banks
  7. Mar 2009Bank Rate hits its lowest and bond buying begins
  8. Jun 2009America's recession ends
  9. Apr 2017Lloyds money is all back
  10. May 2025The last NatWest shares are sold
Why it matters and what it covers

You will make the American authorities' decision yourself, for the weekend of 13 and 14 September 2008, knowing only what was known then. After you choose, you find out what was actually done. You also hear an argument that is still going: did the law allow the authorities to lend to Lehman?

The nine steps start with the firm saved in March and end with the one measure that was not a loan.

Step 1 · March 2008

The firm that was rescued

Take a guess

Bear Stearns ran out of money in March 2008 and did not fail. What did the Federal Reserve do?

Bear Stearns was one of the five largest American investment banks. An investment bank trades and lends for companies and governments, and holds no savings for the public. In March 2008 Bear Stearns could no longer borrow the money it needed to keep going, and it did not go bankrupt.

Rules name a public body to deal with any bank that holds people's savings and fails. Bear Stearns held no savings, so no rule made anybody responsible for it, and nothing said it would be helped at all.

The Federal Reserve Board, which runs America's , met on Sunday 16 March 2008 and announced a new lending scheme. The scheme was for the firms that buy and sell government debt directly with the central bank. It opened the next morning.

central bank
The bank a government sets up to issue its money and set the interest rate the rest of the banking system builds on. It deals with banks and with the state rather than with the public.

For scaleThe Federal Reserve had not lent widely to firms outside banking since the 1930s, seventy years earlier.

Step 2 · 7 September 2008

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac

On 7 September 2008 the American government took control of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. People had always assumed the government would pay these two mortgage companies' debts if they got into trouble.

Neither company lent to households itself. Each bought mortgages from the banks that did and sold them on to investors. Each promised those investors they would still be paid if households stopped paying. The American mortgage market depended on that promise.

The government used : it took control of each company without buying it. It chose the managers and made the decisions the owners used to make.

Owners' money is what a company's owners have put in and left there. Losses use up owners' money before lenders lose anything. A commission set up later by Congress counted how much lending the two companies had for each dollar of owners' money.

The people who had lent to the two companies went on being paid. The people who owned them kept shares that paid nothing.

conservatorship
Conservatorship is when a government body takes control of a failing company without buying it. The body chooses the managers and makes the decisions the owners used to make. The owners keep their shares, but the shares stop paying them anything.

By the end of 2007, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac together owned or guaranteed a huge amount of loans. For each dollar of their owners' money, how many dollars of loans was that?

For scaleThe same commission found that the five largest American investment banks had up to $40 of loans and other assets for each dollar of their owners' money.

Step 3 · 13-14 September 2008

The weekend

Lehman Brothers, another of the five largest American investment banks, could not borrow the money it needed in September 2008. It needed either a buyer or a loan by Monday morning.

Since March the Federal Reserve had lent to firms like Lehman under an emergency lending law, the only law that lets it lend to a firm that is not a bank. It may lend only against something valuable the borrower pledges as security, called collateral, and only if the collateral is good enough.

Lehman was the fourth largest American investment bank, with $639 billion of assets, meaning things it owned. Part of that was property, and bonds paid for out of property loans: $111 billion at the end of 2007. That part alone was more than four times all of its owners' money.

Investors lend to all these firms. They cannot tell which firm will fail next. So if one fails, they may stop lending to all of them at once.

The dates of the rescues16 March and 7 September 2008Bear Stearns six months ago and the two mortgage companies a week ago. Every large firm in this market has watched both.
Who is obliged to rescue an investment bankno rule saysIt holds no savings, so nothing makes anyone responsible for it. Nothing forbids a rescue either.
What Lehman held$639 billionThe fourth largest American investment bank. $111 billion of what it owned at the end of last year was property and bonds based on property. Nobody is buying those this weekend, so their price is a guess.
What the law requires of a Federal Reserve loancollateral good enoughIt may lend only if Lehman pledges something valuable and the lender judges it good enough to cover the loan. The property is part of what Lehman would have to pledge, and nobody will say this weekend what it is worth.

You are among the American authorities over the weekend of 13 and 14 September 2008. Lehman Brothers cannot borrow what it needs for Monday, no buyer has agreed to take it, and the table above is what you have. What do you do?

Step 4 · the law

Could Lehman have been lent to?

Take a guess

Why did the American authorities say they had not rescued Lehman Brothers?

Lehman Brothers filed for bankruptcy on 15 September 2008, and people have argued ever since about whether the Federal Reserve could lawfully have lent to it instead.

The emergency lending law allows the Federal Reserve to lend only against collateral pledged to it. The Federal Reserve itself must also judge the collateral good enough. A firm with nothing good enough to pledge cannot be lent to under this law.

The same law had been used for Bear Stearns six months earlier, and was used again within a week of Lehman Brothers filing.

For scaleThe same law had been used for Bear Stearns six months earlier, and was used again the day after Lehman filed.

Step 5 · 16 September 2008

The insurer, the day after Lehman filed

On 16 September 2008 the Federal Reserve lent to American International Group, known as AIG, an insurance company it had no responsibility for.

The Federal Reserve Board allowed one of its regional banks, the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, to lend up to $85 billion. It used the same emergency lending law as for Bear Stearns. The Federal Reserve said it acted with the full support of the Treasury, the American government's finance department.

AIG took no deposits and was not a bank, and the Federal Reserve had never been responsible for looking at its accounts.

Until 2008 the Federal Reserve lent to banks. After September it was lending to a firm that sold insurance.

The first loan to AIG was for up to $85 billion. At most, how much did the Federal Reserve and the Treasury commit to AIG in total?

For scaleThe most AIG ever actually had at one time was $141.8 billion, in April 2009. The government also took 79.9 per cent of the ownership of the company.

Step 6 · who may be lent to

Who a central bank may lend to

In 2008 the Federal Reserve built new lending schemes in a matter of months, using an emergency lending law that had sat almost unused since the 1930s.

The law had been written for an emergency and then left alone for seventy years. Its wording turned out to cover far more kinds of firm than the banks the Federal Reserve had been responsible for in those seventy years.

The Federal Reserve's scheme for the firms that trade government debt opened on 17 March 2008. None of those firms held savings for the public. An insurance company was lent to in September.

What was new about the Federal Reserve's lending in 2008?

Step 7 · dollars abroad

Dollars for other central banks

The Federal Reserve lent dollars to other central banks, which lent them on to the banks in their own countries.

Each of these arrangements is a swap. The Federal Reserve gives the other central bank dollars and takes its currency in return, and on a set date each gets its own currency back. The other central bank owes the dollars back. The banks it passes them on to owe the Federal Reserve nothing.

The most the Bank of England owed at any one time under one of these arrangements was $74 billion, in October 2008.

The most the Bank of England owed at any one time was $74 billion. The European Central Bank is the central bank for the countries that use the euro. Was its figure higher or lower?

vs

A tie counts as correct either way.

Dollars the Federal Reserve lent to other central banksUS$ billion still owed, end of month
0150300450600200720092010Lehman fails

Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Assets: Central Bank Liquidity Swaps (SWPT), via FRED

For scaleIn December 2007 the Federal Reserve had agreed to lend other central banks up to $24 billion in total. After Lehman Brothers filed, that limit rose to nearly $620 billion.

Step 8 · April 2008

What the Bank of England accepted

Go back to 21 April 2008, when the Bank of England began a new scheme. British banks gave it mortgage bonds and took UK Treasury bills in exchange. Treasury bills are short-term government debt. The Bank of England called each exchange a swap, though no dollars and no other country were involved.

In 2008 nobody would buy a mortgage bond, and a Treasury bill can be sold for cash on any day. The Bank of England did not buy the bonds. Any losses on the home loans behind them stayed with the banks.

Each swap lasted one year and could be renewed, up to three years in all. Banks kept making new swaps as the first ones ended. Only bonds with the top safety grade were accepted. The home loans behind those bonds had to be British or European, and made by the end of 2007.

The Bank of England announced this in April 2008 as a temporary measure. For how many years did it go on?

For scaleAt its peak the scheme had lent £185 billion of Treasury bills. That was more than twice the size of the Bank of England's balance sheet, meaning everything it owned, before the crisis.

Step 9 · the promise

Lending, and a promise

The lending came to hundreds of billions of dollars in 2008, and the runs went on. Savers and lenders kept demanding their money back all at once.

A loan gave a bank money to pay the people who asked first. Everyone else still feared the money would run out before their turn, so they kept asking too.

On 14 October 2008 the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, the American body that runs , promised that lenders would get their money back on new debt that banks issued. It made the same promise for business accounts that paid no interest.

A government that promises to pay what a bank cannot removes the reason to rush. If nobody rushes, the government has nothing to pay out. So governments can promise more than they could ever pay, and in October 2008 they made that promise.

deposit insurance
A government promise to pay savers back, up to a set amount, if their bank fails. It stops a queue at one bank turning into a queue at every bank.

Three of these are loans. Which one is not?

Your score
0 points

Your score will appear here.

The key questions

Can you answer each one now? Tap to check.

Why did the market expect a large firm that ran out of money to be rescued?

RevealBear Stearns ran out of money in March 2008 and was sold with the help of a Federal Reserve loan. In September the government took control of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Every large firm had watched firms like itself being rescued.

Why was Lehman Brothers not rescued, and why is that still argued over?

RevealThe authorities said it had nothing good enough to pledge for a loan. But the same law had been used for other firms whose collateral raised the same worry. So both sides of the argument have evidence on the record.

What did the authorities do after Lehman Brothers failed?

RevealThe Federal Reserve lent to AIG, an insurer, and lent dollars to other central banks. When lending did not stop the runs, governments promised to pay banks' savers and lenders.

The numbers

Can you remember each figure? Tap to check.

Bear Stearns, March 2008

Revealsold to another bank, with a loan from the Federal Reserve

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, end of 2007

Reveal75 dollars of loans owned or guaranteed for every dollar of their owners' money

The weekend of 13 and 14 September 2008

Reveal$639 billion of assets, no buyer, no rescue, and a bankruptcy filing on the 15th

Why there was no rescue

Revealthe authorities said Lehman had nothing good enough to pledge, and that is still argued

AIG, from 16 September 2008

Revealup to $85 billion at first, and about $182.3 billion committed at the maximum

Who the Federal Reserve could lend to

Revealany individual, partnership or corporation, under a law from the 1930s

Dollars lent to other central banks, at their largest

Reveal$291 billion to the European Central Bank, $122 billion to the Bank of Japan, $74 billion to the Bank of England

The Bank of England's swaps, from 21 April 2008

Revealbanks gave mortgage bonds and took Treasury bills, for up to three years, and the last swap ended in January 2012

What stopped the runs

Reveala promise to pay, not a loan

You met three terms in this module

, ,

central bank
The bank a government sets up to issue its money and set the interest rate the rest of the banking system builds on. It deals with banks and with the state rather than with the public.
conservatorship
Conservatorship is when a government body takes control of a failing company without buying it. The body chooses the managers and makes the decisions the owners used to make. The owners keep their shares, but the shares stop paying them anything.
deposit insurance
A government promise to pay savers back, up to a set amount, if their bank fails. It stops a queue at one bank turning into a queue at every bank.

Every rescue made the next one harder to refuse. In October 2008 a promise to pay, which lent nothing, stopped the runs.

Take it further

Where every figure came from

[1] What was done for Bear Stearns, and the new lending facility of the same day: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, press release, 16 March 2008. Read twice. "The Board also approved the financing arrangement announced by JPMorgan Chase & Co. and The Bear Stearns Companies Inc." The same release created the Primary Dealer Credit Facility, "a lending facility to improve the ability of primary dealers to provide financing to participants in securitization markets", open from Monday 17 March 2008 for a minimum of six months, and states that "Credit extended to primary dealers under this facility may be collateralized by a broad range of investment-grade debt securities."
[2] The two mortgage companies taken over: Federal Housing Finance Agency, statement of Director James B. Lockhart, 7 September 2008, and the agency's conservatorship history. Read twice, and the two readings disagree on the date by one day. The news conference announcing it was held on 7 September 2008 and opened "FHFA has placed Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac into conservatorship"; the agency's history page says "On September 6, 2008, with the consent of both Fannie Mae's and Freddie Mac's (the Enterprises) boards of directors, the Director of FHFA exercised statutory authority to place each Enterprise into conservatorship." The action was the 6th and the announcement was the 7th. The module prints the 7th, which is the date the BIS timeline gives and the date a reader would have learned it. On what it meant: "As conservator, FHFA has the powers of the management, boards, and shareholders of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac", and "the common stock and preferred stock dividends will be eliminated, but the common and all preferred stocks will continue to remain outstanding."
[3] How much the two companies owed against what they owned, and what Lehman was holding: Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission, The Financial Crisis Inquiry Report, Official Government Edition, January 2011. READ TWICE OFF THE GOVINFO COPY, identical both times: "by the end of 2007, Fannie's and Freddie's combined leverage ratio, including loans they owned and guaranteed, stood at 75 to 1", and "By the end of 2007, Lehman had amassed $111 billion in commercial and residential real estate holdings and securities, which was almost twice what it held just two years before, and more than four times its total equity." Read a third time on 2 September 2026 for the benchmark on step 2, and the report says it twice: "The investment banks had leverage ratios, by one measure, of up to 40 to 1. This means that for every $40 of assets, they held only $1 of capital", and, in the summary, "their leverage ratios were as high as 40 to 1, meaning for every $40 in assets, there was only $1 in capital to cover losses." ON EXTRACTION: the pipeline has carried since module 2 the instruction that FCIC figures must be read off a rendered image because extraction deletes the numerals. That is true of the Stanford copy. This copy is better but not clean: a plain text extraction returns every numeral as a private-use glyph in the range U+F642 to U+F64B, where U+F643 is zero and the digits run up from it, so the numerals are all there and a naive reader of the extraction sees none of them. Decode that range and the figures are exact.
[4] The dates, from a timeline written to record them rather than to win an argument: Bank for International Settlements, 79th Annual Report, June 2009, chapter II. Read twice. Against 7 September 2008: "Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are taken into government conservatorship." Against 15 September 2008: "Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection." The timeline's entry for 30 September 2008, on the Irish guarantee of six banks, is NOT USED: Ireland is out of scope for the 2008 series by a decision taken at stage 3.
[5] What the law let the Federal Reserve do, and the argument about Lehman that has not ended: Congressional Research Service, Federal Reserve: Emergency Lending, R44185, 27 March 2020. Read twice, identical both times. On what the law required before 2010, the borrower had to present "notes, drafts, and bills of exchange endorsed or otherwise secured to the satisfaction of the Federal Reserve Bank." On who could borrow, the original statute permitted assistance to "any individual, partnership, or corporation." And on Lehman: "Then-Chairman Bernanke later testified that the Fed declined to assist Lehman Brothers because it held inadequate collateral-although some of the Fed's other interventions under Section 13(3) featured concerns about inadequate collateral." One institution, both sides of the dispute, in one sentence, which is why the argument is carried from here rather than from the commission's majority and its dissenting views.
[6] How large Lehman Brothers was, and the day it filed: Congressional Research Service, Lehman Brothers and IndyMac: Comparing Resolution Regimes, R40928, 12 October 2009. Read twice, identical both times: "Before filing a Chapter 11 bankruptcy petition on September 15, 2008, Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. (LBHI) was a global financial institution... It was the fourth largest U.S. investment bank with $639 billion in assets." THIS REPORT DOES NOT GIVE WHAT LEHMAN OWED, and neither does any other institution read for the 2008 work. The spine's $613 billion was retired at stage 4 on 2 September 2026 and the board carries assets instead; the whole search is recorded in the research file at link 22, under claimAmended.
[7] The loan to an insurance company, the day after Lehman: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, press release, 16 September 2008. Read twice. The Board "authorized the Federal Reserve Bank of New York" to "lend up to $85 billion to the American International Group (AIG)", under "section 13(3) of the Federal Reserve Act", and "with the full support of the Treasury Department". Read again on 2 September 2026 for the benchmark on step 5: "The loan is collateralized by all the assets of AIG, and of its primary non-regulated subsidiaries", and "The U.S. government will receive a 79.9 percent equity interest in AIG." The spine says the loan was made "by the Federal Reserve and not by the Treasury"; that is half right and the module says only the half the release supports.
[8] What the whole of it came to in the end: Congressional Research Service, Government Assistance for AIG: Summary and Cost, R42953, 13 October 2017. Read twice: "At the maximum, the Federal Reserve (Fed) and the Treasury committed approximately $182.3 billion in specific extraordinary assistance for AIG and another $15.2 billion through a more widely available lending facility." The $15.2 billion does not print: it is a different programme open to many firms, and adding it to the headline would invent a fifth figure that no institution publishes. Read twice again on 2 September 2026 for the step 5 benchmark under RULE 64: "The amount actually disbursed to assist AIG reached a maximum of $141.8 billion in April 2009." That is the committed/disbursed distinction, and two naive readers asked for it by name.
[9] The dollars lent to other central banks: Linda S. Goldberg, Craig Kennedy and Jason Miu, Central Bank Dollar Swap Lines and Overseas Dollar Funding Costs, Federal Reserve Bank of New York Economic Policy Review, May 2011. Read twice: Federal Reserve monthly balance data show that central bank dollar swap balances peaked at these levels: the European Central Bank, $291 billion (December 2008); the Bank of Japan, $122 billion (December 2008); the Bank of England, $74 billion (October 2008), and the authorised amount rose from $24 billion in total in December 2007 to nearly $620 billion after the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers. The Swiss National Bank's $25.18 billion is an amount OUTSTANDING AT 31 DECEMBER 2008 rather than a peak, and is not printed beside the three peaks.
[10] What the Bank of England lent against, and on what terms: Bank of England, news release: Special Liquidity Scheme, 21 April 2008. Read twice. Banks could exchange "high quality mortgage-backed and other securities for UK Treasury Bills"; the eligible assets were "AAA-rated securities backed by UK and European residential mortgages", formed only from loans already held at the end of 2007; each swap runs for 1 year and can be rolled over, to a maximum of 3 years in all; and "Responsibility for losses on their loans, however, stays with the banks."
[11] How long the emergency lasted after it stopped being news: Bank of England, The Bank of England's Special Liquidity Scheme, Quarterly Bulletin 2012 Q1. Read twice: the final SLS transactions ran out in January 2012, and the SLS ended then. Read twice again on 2 September 2026, for the step 8 benchmark and the new explainer, off the article PDF as well as the page. On the size: at its highest, the Scheme had lent Treasury bills worth £185 billion at face value, which was more than double the Bank’s balance sheet before the financial crisis. On why a Treasury bill is worth having: "In turn, banks could use these Treasury bills in private markets to obtain cash." And on what the scheme was for: it worked by helping banks to fund assets that could not be moved off their balance sheets after some asset-backed securities markets closed from 2007 onwards. NOTE FOR ANY LATER READER: this PDF is set in two columns and a plain text extraction interleaves them, so the peak sentence comes out with the box reference spliced through its middle. Both reads interleave identically and the sentence de-interleaves the same way each time.
[12] The promise, and what it was expected to do: Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Temporary Liquidity Guarantee Program, final rule, Federal Register, 26 November 2008. Read twice. Announced 14 October 2008. The programme guaranteed "the payment of certain newly-issued senior unsecured debt" and "certain noninterest-bearing transaction accounts", was "designed to avoid or mitigate adverse effects on economic conditions or financial stability", and was expected to work by "preserving confidence in the banking system and encouraging liquidity in order to ease lending to creditworthy businesses and consumers." NO SIZE IS PRINTED from this source or any other: what the guarantees came to is spine link 29 and belongs to module 5. The content model names four more institutions for this link and none was reached; the FDIC's own crisis-response volume returns 403 and was not retried.
[13] The episode chart: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Assets: Central Bank Liquidity Swaps: Wednesday Level (SWPT), retrieved from FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. Public domain, citation requested (FRED's marking for this Board of Governors series). Retrieved 30 September 2026. Weekly levels taken at the last Wednesday of each month, October 2007 to June 2010, converted from millions to billions of dollars. It counts dollars actually lent, which stayed below the nearly $620 billion authorised.

Country data from the World Bank (CC BY 4.0) and the UNDP Human Development Report (CC BY 3.0 IGO)
Games · Learn · Atlas · Read · Feedback · Privacy · Contact