- Tariff
- A tariff is a tax that a government places on imported goods and services, which makes imports more expensive for consumers.
- Deadweight loss
- Deadweight loss is the loss in social surplus that occurs when an economy produces at an inefficient quantity.
Free tradeAt the world price Pw, home firms supply Q1 and buyers want Q4. Imports fill the gap between them.
The tariff moves the price up from the world price Pw to Pt, and domestic firms raise their output from Q1 to Q2.
- With free trade the country buys at the world price Pw. Home firms supply Q1 at that price, and imports fill the gap between Q1 and what buyers want.
- The tariff adds its full amount to the price of every import, so the domestic price rises from Pw to Pt. Home firms now meet a higher price and move up their supply curve, selling more at a higher price.
- Producer surplus rises by the strip between Pw and Pt, out as far as the supply curve. That gain is why protected producers ask for tariffs.
Check yourself
A tariff lifts the UK price of steel from the world price to a higher price. Why do UK steelmakers now produce more?
Home firms gain from the tariff and the government collects revenue. How do you think buyers' losses compare with those gains?
Buyers lose the whole strip between Pw and Pt out to the demand curve. Producers and the government take part of it, but two triangles go to nobody, so the country as a whole is worse off.
Buyers cut backAt Pt buyers cut their purchases from Q4 to Q3, so imports shrink to the gap between Q2 and Q3.
The same move up from Pw to Pt cuts what domestic buyers purchase from Q4 to Q3, so imports shrink from both ends.
- Imports were the gap from Q1 to Q4. After the tariff they are the gap from Q2 to Q3, narrowed by extra home output at one end and by lost purchases at the other.
- Consumer surplus falls by the whole strip between Pw and Pt, out as far as the demand curve. The first slice of that loss is the home producers' gain.
- The government collects the tariff on every import still bought: the rectangle between Pw and Pt, from Q2 to Q3. That money is not lost to the country, only moved.
- Two triangles go to nobody. Between Q1 and Q2, home firms make units dearer than imports would have cost. Between Q3 and Q4, buyers give up units they valued above the world price. Together they are the deadweight loss.
Check yourself
The UK puts a tariff on imported bicycles. What happens to the number of bicycles made in the UK and the number imported?
Doesn't a tariff just move sales from foreign firms to British ones?
No. Restricting imports can look like nothing more than taking sales from foreign producers and giving them to domestic ones. But firms sell to consumers, and to other firms, who are also affected by the barrier. Those buyers pay a higher price and buy a smaller quantity. Consumers lose more than producers gain, so the country ends up with a lower social surplus, and the policy imposes real costs at home.
Draw the diagram and label the world price, the price with the tariff and all four quantities, then name each welfare area by its edges. Consumer surplus falls; producer surplus rises; the government gains revenue, the tariff times the imports still bought; and two triangles, one either side of the imports, are the deadweight loss. Finish by saying which groups gain and which lose.
Check yourself
A tariff raises the price from the world price to the tariff price. Name each shaded area.
Area A: Tariff revenue. A is the tariff on each unit, Pt minus Pw, times the imports still bought, Q2 to Q3. The government collects it.
Area B: Gain in producer surplus. B is the strip between the two prices out to the supply curve: home firms sell up to Q2 at the higher price.
Area C: Deadweight loss. C covers units from Q1 to Q2 that home firms make at a cost above the world price. Nobody gains that area.
Check yourself
The world price of a good is £40 and the UK adds a tariff of £5 per unit. After the tariff, the UK imports 200 units. How much revenue does the government collect?
£1000
£5 × 200 = £1,000. Revenue is the tariff on each unit times the imports still bought after the tariff, the rectangle between the two prices.
Exam question
Using a diagram, explain the effect of a tariff on consumers, domestic producers and the government. [4]
Diagram: domestic supply and demand, a horizontal world price Pw, and Pt = Pw + tariff above it, with Q1 to Q4 marked. The tariff raises the domestic price from Pw to Pt. Consumers buy less, from Q4 to Q3, and lose consumer surplus. Domestic producers supply more, from Q1 to Q2, and gain producer surplus. The government gains revenue equal to the tariff times the imports from Q2 to Q3. Consumers lose more than the other two gain: the difference is the deadweight loss.
One mark for a correctly labelled diagram and one each for the effect on consumers, producers and the government, with the deadweight loss needed for full marks. Each effect needs its direction and named area.
A tariff is a tax on imports. It lifts the domestic price above the world price, so home firms supply more and home buyers buy less, and imports fall from both ends. Producers gain surplus and the government gains revenue on the imports still bought. Consumers lose surplus, and they lose more than the other two gain: the difference is the deadweight loss.