Without trade, every extra unit costs what the country itself gives up
Without trade, a country that wants more of a good must face its own opportunity cost. A UK worker can make 12 aircraft parts or 6 rolls of cloth, and a Vietnamese worker 2 parts or 4 rolls. With ten workers each, split evenly, the UK has 60 parts and 30 rolls and Vietnam has 10 parts and 20 rolls. Every extra part Vietnam makes costs it two rolls of cloth.
The UK can make more parts and more cloth than Vietnam. If the two countries move workers between the goods, can their combined output of both goods rise?
Yes. A part costs Vietnam 2 rolls and the UK half a roll, so moving Vietnam's workers into cloth and some UK workers into parts raises the total of both goods, with the same workers as before.
Shifting workers towards the lower-cost good raises total output
Now each country moves resources towards its comparative advantage. Vietnam puts all ten workers on cloth and makes 40 rolls. The UK moves two workers from cloth to parts and makes 84 parts and 18 rolls. Between them the two countries now make 84 parts instead of 70, and 58 rolls instead of 50, with the same workers as before.
A trading price between the two costs leaves both with more
A trade benefits both sides if its price lies between the two countries' opportunity costs. A part costs the UK half a roll and Vietnam two rolls, so suppose they swap one part for one roll. The UK sends 14 parts for 14 rolls and ends with 70 parts and 32 rolls, against 60 and 30 before. Vietnam ends with 14 parts and 26 rolls, against 10 and 20.
Check yourself
An aircraft part costs the UK 0.5 roll of cloth to make and costs Vietnam 2 rolls. The UK exports parts. Which price could benefit both countries?
Each country ends up beyond what it could produce alone
Working alone, Vietnam could not have had 14 parts and 26 rolls: the 7 workers needed for 14 parts would leave 3 for cloth, and they make only 12 rolls. Vietnam gets its parts where they are cheap to make, and the UK gets its cloth where it is cheap.
AloneWorking alone, Vietnam can make any mix on its line, from 20 parts to 40 rolls. It chose 10 parts and 20 rolls.
Check yourself
The line shows every mix of parts and cloth the UK's workers can make on their own. Which point can the UK reach only by trading?
A lies inside the line. The UK can make this mix on its own and still have workers to spare, so no trade is needed to reach it.
Yes. B lies beyond the line: it takes more of both goods than the UK's own workers can make, so the UK can reach it only by trading.
C sits on the line, so the UK's own workers can make exactly this mix by themselves. No trade is needed to reach it.
- Gain from trade
- A gain from trade is the extra a country can consume, beyond what it could produce on its own, as a result of specialisation and trade.
- Specialisation
- Specialisation is when a country shifts resources to focus on producing a good in which it has a comparative advantage.
Other benefits of trade
Can you name three benefits of trade besides the gain from specialising?
Specialising is only one gain.
Lower prices and more choice come from buying goods where they cost least, including goods a country cannot make itself.
Can you think of an example?
Bananas and coffee cannot be grown commercially in Britain, yet every supermarket sells them.
Economies of scale are the lower average costs of producing more, which a world market allows where a home market is too small.
Can you think of an example?
A Welsh factory making aircraft wings for planemakers worldwide spreads its costs over far more wings than Britain alone would buy.
More competition from foreign firms pushes home firms to cut costs, raise quality and innovate, or lose sales.
Can you think of an example?
When Japanese carmakers began selling in Britain, British carmakers had to improve the reliability of their cars to keep buyers.
If the UK is better at making both goods, how can buying from Vietnam help it?
Because the UK's workers are limited too. Every UK worker making cloth is a worker not making parts, so each roll made at home costs the UK two parts. Buying the roll from Vietnam for one part costs it half as much. Being better at everything does not make everything cheap to produce: the cost of a good is what the same workers could have made instead.
Show the gain as a before-and-after comparison. State what each country had before trade and what it has after, and show it has more of at least one good and less of neither. Then give the reason: each specialised where its opportunity cost was lower and traded at a price between the two costs. "Trade is beneficial" on its own earns nothing.
Check yourself
Three of these are needed for both countries to gain from trade. Which one is not?
Exam question
Explain how two countries can both gain from specialising and trading, even when one of them is better at producing both goods. [4]
Each good has a different opportunity cost in each country. When each specialises in the good it gives up least to make, total output of both goods rises. If they then trade at a price between their two opportunity costs, each gets its import for less than it would cost to make at home, so both can consume more than they could produce alone.
One mark each for different opportunity costs, specialisation raising total output, a price between the two costs, and consumption beyond what each could produce alone. Absolute advantage in both goods changes none of these steps.
Without trade, a country gets more of a good only by giving up what its own resources could have made instead. When each country shifts resources towards its comparative advantage, total output of both goods rises. Trading at a price between the two opportunity costs then lets each consume more than it could produce alone. That extra is the gain from trade, and it holds even when one country is better at producing everything.