- Protectionism
- Protectionism is government policy to reduce or block imports, often to shield domestic producers and workers from foreign competition.
- Free trade
- Free trade is trade in which countries allow each other's imports without tariffs, quotas or other barriers set by government.
Forms of protectionism
Can you name the four forms of protectionism?
Only a tariff is a tax on imports. The other three are non-tariff barriers: they protect home firms without taxing imports, and each works on something different.
A tariff is a tax that a government imposes on imported goods and services, which makes imports more expensive for consumers.
Can you think of an example?
A 10 per cent tariff on imported cheese adds £1 to a £10 wheel of French brie before it reaches the shop. The tariff works through the price, and the £1 goes to the government.
An import quota is a numerical limit on the quantity of a product that a country can import.
Can you think of an example?
A cap of 5,000 tonnes a year on imported lamb is a quota. Once the cap is reached, no more lamb comes in at any price, and the government collects nothing on what does.
A regulatory barrier is any rule, standard, inspection or paperwork a nation draws up to make importing products more costly or difficult.
Can you think of an example?
A rule that every lorry of imported meat must wait at the port for a vet's inspection is a regulatory barrier. Nothing is taxed or counted, but each delay adds to the cost of importing.
A subsidy to domestic producers is a government payment to home firms that lowers their costs, so they can sell more cheaply and win sales from imports.
Can you think of an example?
The government pays British steelmakers £50 for every tonne they make. They cut their price and imported steel loses sales, with no tax on imports and no limit on their amount. Taxpayers, not buyers, pay for this protection.
Check yourself
Three of these are non-tariff barriers. Which one is not?
A quota raises the price too, but the extra goes to whoever can import
A quota also pushes the price up, to the level where buyers want exactly the quota more than home firms supply. There is no tax, so the government collects nothing. Some of the higher price paid by home consumers ends up with the foreign producers allowed to sell inside the quota, because they now sell at the higher price.
Free tradeAt the world price Pw, home firms supply Q1, buyers want Q4, and imports fill the gap.
Check yourself
The UK limits imports of a good to a set number of tonnes a year and the domestic price rises. Who receives the extra money buyers pay on the imports?
Isn't a safety rule just a safety rule, rather than a trade barrier?
It can be both. A rule requiring certain safety standards can limit imports just as effectively as a high tariff or a low quota. Rules of origin work the same way: they decide which country counts as the "Made in" country, and a firm may change where it finishes a product to get round them. What makes a rule a barrier is its effect on imports, not what it says it is for.
Classify a barrier by what it acts on. A tax on each import is a tariff. Everything else is a non-tariff barrier: a limit on the amount is a quota, a rule, standard or form is a regulatory barrier, and a payment to home firms is a subsidy. Then say who gains the extra money: the government under a tariff, and firms holding the right to import under a quota.
Check yourself
A quota caps imports, and the price rises from Pw to Pq. Which area is the extra buyers pay on the imports still allowed in?
A is the extra home firms earn by selling their own output, up to Q2, at the higher price. It is a gain to home producers, not a payment on imports.
B covers home output from Q1 to Q2, made at a cost above the world price. Nobody receives it: it is part of the deadweight loss.
Yes. C is the rise in price, Pw to Pq, times the imports still allowed in, Q2 to Q3. With no tax, it goes to the firms allowed to sell inside the quota.
Exam question
Distinguish between a tariff and an import quota. [2]
A tariff is a tax on imports, which raises their price and earns the government revenue. An import quota is a limit on the quantity of a good that can be imported, and earns the government nothing.
One mark for each accurate definition. Setting them side by side, a tax on the price against a limit on the quantity, is what the command word distinguish asks for.
Protectionism takes four main forms. A tariff is a tax on imports. The other three are non-tariff barriers. An import quota is a numerical limit on the quantity that can be imported. A regulatory barrier is any rule, inspection or paperwork that makes importing more costly or difficult. A subsidy to domestic producers lowers home firms' costs so they win sales from imports. Only the tariff raises money for the government.