- Sales maximisation
- Sales maximisation is producing the largest output a firm can sell without making a loss, where average revenue equals average cost.
- Revenue maximisation
- Revenue maximisation is producing the output at which total revenue is as large as possible, where marginal revenue is zero.
Revenue and costAverage revenue AR, marginal revenue MR, marginal cost MC and average cost AC.
Moving down AR from the profit-maximising point P1, Q1 to the revenue-maximising point P2, Q2, output rises and price falls.
- A profit maximiser makes Q1, where MR = MC. Up to Q1 each extra unit adds more to revenue than to cost; past it the next unit costs more than it brings in. Price P1 is read off AR, and supernormal profit is area A.
- A revenue maximiser ignores cost and makes Q2, where MR = 0. Up to Q2 each extra unit adds to total revenue; past it MR is negative and total revenue falls.
- Marginal cost is above zero, so MR meets MC before it reaches zero: Q2 lies to the right of Q1, and P2 below P1.
Check yourself
At its current output a firm has marginal revenue of £3 and marginal cost of £5. It aims to maximise revenue. What should it do?
A firm wants to sell as many units as it can without making a loss. On this diagram, where do you think it produces compared with the revenue maximiser?
At Q2 price is still above average cost, so the firm can sell more and still cover its costs. It keeps going until price falls to average cost, at a larger output.
Revenue maximisationThe revenue maximiser makes Q2, where MR is zero, at price P2.
Moving further down AR from P2, Q2 to P3, Q3, where AR meets AC, output rises again and price falls to average cost.
- A sales maximiser makes as many units as it can while covering its costs, normal profit included. That is Q3, where AR cuts AC from above.
- At Q3 price P3 equals average cost, so supernormal profit is zero. Any output past Q3 sells at a price below average cost: a loss.
- Managers whose pay or standing grows with the size of the firm may prefer this output to the one the owners want, and a larger market share can bring economies of scale and deter entry.
Check yourself
Which point shows the price and output a sales-maximising firm chooses?
A is on AR above the output where MR meets MC: the profit-maximising point, with the highest price and the smallest output of the three objectives.
B is on AR above the output where MR reaches zero: the revenue-maximising point. Price is still above average cost there, so a sales maximiser can go further.
C is where AR cuts AC from above, the largest output the firm can sell while covering its costs, with only normal profit left.
Doesn't the firm that sells the most make the most profit?
No. Past Q1 each extra unit costs more to make than it adds to revenue, so profit falls as output rises towards Q2 and Q3. Selling more at a lower price raises total revenue up to Q2 while profit is already falling, because profit takes costs into account and revenue does not. At Q3 the firm sells the most it can without a loss, and its supernormal profit has gone.
Draw AR and MR from the same point on the price axis, MR twice as steep, and a U-shaped AC with MC through its lowest point. Mark three outputs: where MR = MC, where MR meets the output axis, and where AR cuts AC on the right. Read each price up to AR, never to MR. The sales-maximising output lies beyond the revenue-maximising one only when price there is still above AC, so draw AC low enough to show this.
Check yourself
A firm's total revenue is £500 at 20 units, £560 at 30 units, £580 at 40 units and £570 at 50 units. How many units does a revenue maximiser make?
40
Total revenue peaks at £580 at 40 units. From 30 to 40 units marginal revenue is £20 ÷ 10 = £2 a unit, above zero; from 40 to 50 it is −£10 ÷ 10 = −£1 a unit, so selling more cuts revenue.
Exam question
Using a diagram, explain why a sales-maximising firm produces a larger output than a profit-maximising firm. [4]
A profit maximiser produces where MR = MC, at Q1, and charges the price on AR above it, earning supernormal profit because price is above average cost. A sales maximiser produces the largest output it can without a loss, where AR = AC, at Q3. Between Q1 and Q3 price is still above average cost, so the firm can keep selling more at lower prices, giving up supernormal profit until only normal profit is left.
One mark for a diagram with AR, MR, MC and AC; one for Q1 at MR = MC; one for Q3 at AR = AC; one for explaining that the extra output is sold at a lower price that still covers average cost, so supernormal profit falls to zero.
On one diagram a firm has three outputs to choose from. Profit maximisation is where MR = MC. Revenue maximisation is where MR = 0, at a larger output and lower price, because profit takes costs into account and revenue does not. Sales maximisation is where AR = AC, the largest output the firm can sell without a loss, with only normal profit left.