Learn › Economic theory › Firms and competition

Firms and competition

The shutdown point

Draw the shutdown point and say when a loss-making firm keeps producing, shuts down or leaves

Specification: AQA 4.1.5.3 Edexcel 3.3.4

Key terms
Shutdown point
The shutdown point is where the marginal cost curve crosses the average variable cost curve, marking the price below which a firm cannot cover its variable costs.
Break-even point
The break-even point is where the marginal cost curve crosses the average cost curve, marking the price at which the firm earns only normal profit.
A firm keeps producing at a loss while price covers average variable cost
Profit, then a loss the firm acceptsVertical axis: Price and cost. Horizontal axis: Output. MC: an upward-sloping curve. ATC: a downward-sloping curve. AVC: a downward-sloping curve. P1: a horizontal line. P2: a horizontal line. P1 meets MC, at price P1 and Q1 on the horizontal axis. P2 meets MC, at price P2 and Q2 on the horizontal axis. Shaded area A: supernormal profit. Shaded area B: loss.ABQ1P1Q2P2MCATCAVC
1 of 3

CostsMC cuts AVC and ATC at their lowest points.

Check yourself

A firm has fixed costs of £1,000 a week. At its best output of 500 units the price is £6, average variable cost is £5 and average total cost is £7. How many pounds a week does it lose if it keeps producing?

Take a guess

Price falls below the lowest point on the AVC curve. If the firm still produced where P = MC, how would its loss compare with its fixed costs?

Below the lowest average variable cost the firm shuts down
The shutdown pointVertical axis: Price and cost. Horizontal axis: Output. MC: an upward-sloping curve. ATC: a downward-sloping curve. AVC: a downward-sloping curve. P2: a horizontal line. P3: a horizontal line. P2 meets MC, at price P2 and Q2 on the horizontal axis. S: MC meets AVC. P3 meets MC, at price P3 and Q3 on the horizontal axis.Q2P2Q3P3MCATCAVCS
1 of 3

Price P2At P2 the firm makes Q2 and covers its average variable cost.

Check yourself

Price has fallen below a firm's average total cost but stays above its average variable cost, and it is expected to stay there. What does the firm do?

Common mistake

Shouldn't a firm that is making a loss close straight away?

Not in the short run. The firm has already paid for fixed costs such as equipment, and closing does not get them back: a firm that produces nothing still loses its whole fixed cost. So the choice is between two losses, and the smaller one wins. While price is above average variable cost, producing covers the variable costs and some of the fixed costs, so it loses less than closing.

Exam tip

Draw MC cutting AVC and ATC at their lowest points, with AVC below ATC and the gap between them narrowing as output rises. Label the two crossings: the shutdown point on AVC and the break-even point on ATC. Then state both rules: in the short run shut down if P < AVC; in the long run leave if P < ATC.

Check yourself

Which point on this firm's cost curves is the shutdown point?

A firm's cost curvesVertical axis: Price and cost. Horizontal axis: Output. MC: an upward-sloping curve. ATC: a downward-sloping curve. AVC: a downward-sloping curve. A: MC meets ATC. B: MC meets AVC.MCATCAVCABC

Exam question

A firm in a perfectly competitive market finds that the price has fallen below its average total cost but not below its average variable cost. Explain what it will do in the short run and in the long run. [4]

What to take away

A price-taking firm produces where P = MC. Above average total cost it earns supernormal profit. Between average variable cost and average total cost it makes a loss but keeps producing in the short run, since it covers its variable costs and some fixed costs. Below the shutdown point, where MC crosses AVC, it shuts down. In the long run it leaves if price stays below ATC.