- Shutdown point
- The shutdown point is where the marginal cost curve crosses the average variable cost curve, marking the price below which a firm cannot cover its variable costs.
- Break-even point
- The break-even point is where the marginal cost curve crosses the average cost curve, marking the price at which the firm earns only normal profit.
CostsMC cuts AVC and ATC at their lowest points.
Price moves down from P1 to P2 and output from Q1 to Q2: P2 is below average total cost but above average variable cost, so production continues.
- The firm is a price taker, so price is its marginal revenue, and it produces where P = MC. At P1 price is above ATC, so it earns supernormal profit, area A.
- At P2 price is below ATC, so the firm makes a loss, area B. Shutting down would cut variable costs to zero, but fixed costs such as rent are already committed and must still be paid.
- P2 is above AVC, so each unit sold pays its variable cost and leaves something towards fixed costs.
Check yourself
A firm has fixed costs of £1,000 a week. At its best output of 500 units the price is £6, average variable cost is £5 and average total cost is £7. How many pounds a week does it lose if it keeps producing?
500
The loss per unit is £7 − £6 = £1, so across 500 units the loss is £500 a week. Shutting down would lose the whole £1,000 of fixed cost, so producing loses less.
Price falls below the lowest point on the AVC curve. If the firm still produced where P = MC, how would its loss compare with its fixed costs?
Below AVC each unit sold does not even pay its own variable cost, so producing adds to the loss. The firm would lose all its fixed costs and more, so it shuts down.
Price P2At P2 the firm makes Q2 and covers its average variable cost.
Price moves down from P2 to P3, below the shutdown point: output falls from Q2 to Q3, but producing Q3 loses more than fixed costs, so the firm shuts down.
- The shutdown point is where MC crosses AVC, at the lowest point of AVC. Below that price, revenue does not cover variable costs.
- At P3, producing Q3 loses all of fixed cost plus the gap between AVC and price on every unit. Shutting down limits the loss to fixed cost.
- In the long run no cost is fixed. A firm whose price stays below ATC, as at P2, leaves the market when its leases and contracts end, so in the long run it needs price to cover ATC.
Check yourself
Price has fallen below a firm's average total cost but stays above its average variable cost, and it is expected to stay there. What does the firm do?
Shouldn't a firm that is making a loss close straight away?
Not in the short run. The firm has already paid for fixed costs such as equipment, and closing does not get them back: a firm that produces nothing still loses its whole fixed cost. So the choice is between two losses, and the smaller one wins. While price is above average variable cost, producing covers the variable costs and some of the fixed costs, so it loses less than closing.
Draw MC cutting AVC and ATC at their lowest points, with AVC below ATC and the gap between them narrowing as output rises. Label the two crossings: the shutdown point on AVC and the break-even point on ATC. Then state both rules: in the short run shut down if P < AVC; in the long run leave if P < ATC.
Check yourself
Which point on this firm's cost curves is the shutdown point?
A is where MC crosses ATC at its lowest point: the break-even point, where price just covers average total cost and the firm earns normal profit.
B is where MC crosses AVC at its lowest point. Below that price the firm cannot cover its variable costs, so it shuts down.
C is the lowest point of MC. MC reaches its minimum before AVC does, so this price is below the shutdown point, not at it.
Exam question
A firm in a perfectly competitive market finds that the price has fallen below its average total cost but not below its average variable cost. Explain what it will do in the short run and in the long run. [4]
In the short run it keeps producing where P = MC. Price covers average variable cost, so each unit pays its variable cost and contributes towards fixed costs, which must be paid whether or not it produces; its loss is smaller than its fixed costs. In the long run all costs are variable, so if price stays below average total cost the firm leaves the market when its fixed commitments end.
One mark for continuing to produce in the short run; one for price covering AVC with a contribution to fixed costs; one for the loss being smaller than fixed costs from closing; one for exit in the long run because price is below ATC.
A price-taking firm produces where P = MC. Above average total cost it earns supernormal profit. Between average variable cost and average total cost it makes a loss but keeps producing in the short run, since it covers its variable costs and some fixed costs. Below the shutdown point, where MC crosses AVC, it shuts down. In the long run it leaves if price stays below ATC.