Learn › Economic theory › Firms and competition

Firms and competition

Technological change and creative destruction

Trace how an innovation lowers costs, changes market structure and drives out older firms

Specification: AQA 4.1.4.8, 4.1.5.8

Technological change starts as an invention and reaches the market as an innovation

Technological change combines two steps. Invention is an advance in knowledge: a new idea, design or discovery. Innovation is putting that advance to use in a new product or service, or in a new way of producing. An invention can sit unused for years, and only the innovation changes what firms sell or how they make it.

A new process lowers costs and shifts the cost curve down

A firm looks for the method that makes its output at the lowest cost, because lower costs raise profit and because a rival that finds a cheaper method can undercut it. A new process that needs fewer inputs for each unit lowers the average cost of every level of output, so the average cost curve shifts down from AC1 to AC2. The firm can keep its price and earn more on each unit, or cut its price and take customers from rivals still using the old method.

A new process lowers average costVertical axis: Cost per unit. Horizontal axis: Output. AC1: a downward-sloping curve. AC2: a downward-sloping curve. A point at C1 on the vertical axis and Q1 on the horizontal axis. A point at C2 on the vertical axis.Q1C1C2AC1AC2
1 of 2

Old methodWith the old method, making Q1 costs C1 per unit on AC1.

Output Q1 cost C1 per unit with the old method and costs C2 with the new one.

Check yourself

A bakery installs ovens that bake each loaf with half the energy and less labour. What happens to its average cost curve?

A bakery's average costVertical axis: Cost per loaf. Horizontal axis: Loaves a day. AC1: a downward-sloping curve.AC1AC2

Technology can change how many firms a market supports

New technology can also change the shape of the long-run average cost curve, and with it the size of firms in an industry. The assembly line and the large department store stretched economies of scale over a larger output, so large producers gained an edge and markets came to be supplied by fewer, bigger firms. Other changes run the other way. Gas turbines generate electricity at a competitive cost in plants far smaller than the old coal-fired stations, which lets smaller firms compete. Online selling lets a small firm reach buyers across the country, while some digital markets tend towards one dominant firm.

Check yourself

A new technology lets small plants make a product at the same average cost as large ones. What is the likely effect on the market?

Take a guess

A new firm launches a product that does the same job better and more cheaply. What do you think happens to the firms selling the old product?

New products and firms replace old ones

An innovative firm usually gains a temporary edge over its competitors and earns above-normal profit until they catch up. That profit draws in imitators and the next innovators. Buyers switch to the new product, so firms selling the old one lose sales, and those that cannot adapt make losses and leave the market. Their workers and capital move to other uses. Online rental and streaming, for example, emptied the high street of DVD rental shops. The economist Joseph Schumpeter called this process creative destruction: the new is built by destroying the old, and today's leading firm is exposed to the next innovator.

Key terms
Creative destruction
Creative destruction is the process by which innovations bring new products, methods and firms into a market and drive out the older ones they replace.
Innovation
Innovation is putting an advance in knowledge to use in a new product or service, or in a new way of producing.
Common mistake

Doesn't creative destruction just mean firms going bust and jobs being lost?

Not only. When a business fails, workers lose their jobs, investors lose their money and owners can lose years of work. The same process moves labour and capital away from products buyers no longer want and towards ones they value more, and it lowers the cost of making what stays. Over time the economy gains new products and lower costs, the gains that dynamic efficiency measures.

Exam tip

Answer as a chain, one link per step: an invention becomes an innovation; the innovation cuts costs or creates a product; the innovator earns supernormal profit; rivals copy it or new firms enter; firms using the old method lose sales and exit. Then say what happens to market structure: fewer, larger firms where economies of scale grow, more, smaller firms where they shrink.

Check yourself

Three of these are innovations. Which one is only an invention so far?

Exam question

Explain how technological change can lead to creative destruction in a market. [4]

What to take away

Technological change combines invention, an advance in knowledge, with innovation, putting that advance to use. A new process shifts the cost curves down; a change in economies of scale can leave a market with fewer, bigger firms or more, smaller ones. The innovator earns above-normal profit until rivals catch up, and firms tied to the old method lose sales and exit. Schumpeter called this creative destruction.