- Average tax rate
- The average tax rate is the total tax a person pays divided by their total income, the share of income that goes in tax.
- Marginal tax rate
- The marginal tax rate is the rate of tax paid on the last pound of income, set by the band that pound falls in.
Three kinds of tax by the share of income they take
Can you name the three ways a tax can be classified by the share of income it takes?
Each is judged by how the average tax rate changes as income rises.
A progressive tax collects a greater share of income from those with high incomes than from those with lower incomes, so its average rate rises with income.
Can you think of an example?
UK income tax is 0% up to £12,570, 20% to £50,270, 40% to £125,140 and 45% above that, so the share of income paid rises as income rises.
A proportional tax takes the same percentage of income whatever the level of income, so its average rate stays flat.
Can you think of an example?
A flat tax of 10 per cent on all income takes £2,000 from someone earning £20,000 and £10,000 from someone earning £100,000: a tenth of each income.
A regressive tax takes a smaller share of income from people with higher incomes, so its average rate falls as income rises.
Can you think of an example?
In 2019-20 the poorest fifth of UK households paid 30.1 per cent of their disposable income in indirect taxes such as VAT; the richest fifth paid 11.3 per cent.
Check yourself
Three of these describe a progressive tax. Which one does not?
The test is the share of income, not the number of pounds
A tax is progressive when high-income groups face a higher average tax rate than low-income groups. If those with higher incomes pay a higher amount but still face a lower average tax rate, the tax is regressive. A proportional tax sits between the two, taking the same share from everyone. Progressive taxes narrow the gaps between incomes: in 2023-24 UK direct taxes reduced income inequality, measured by the Gini coefficient, by 4.4 percentage points.
ProportionalA proportional tax takes the same share of every income, so its average rate is a flat line.
Check yourself
Each line shows how a tax's average rate changes with income. Label each line.
Curve A: Regressive. A slopes down: richer people pay a smaller share of their income in this tax, even if the pounds they pay are larger.
Curve B: Progressive. B slopes up: the share of income paid in tax rises as income rises, so higher earners bear a bigger share.
Curve C: Proportional. C is flat: the tax takes the same percentage of income at every level, so the burden is the same share for all.
Rising marginal rates make income tax progressive
UK income tax charges each band of income at its own rate: nothing on the Personal Allowance of £12,570, 20 per cent on taxable income up to £50,270, 40 per cent up to £125,140 and 45 per cent above that. A higher rate applies only to the income inside its band, never to the whole income. So a person's marginal rate is always at least their average rate, and the average rate climbs gradually as income rises.
Can you work out the average tax rate of someone earning £60,000?
Someone earning £60,000 pays nothing on the first £12,570, 20 per cent on the next £37,700, which is £7,540, and 40 per cent on the last £9,730, which is £3,892. Total tax is £11,432. Their marginal rate is 40 per cent, but their average rate is £11,432 divided by £60,000, about 19.1 per cent.
If richer people pay more VAT, isn't VAT progressive?
No. The richest fifth of UK households paid about 2.7 times as much indirect tax in pounds as the poorest fifth in 2017-18, because they spend more. But they paid much less as a share of their income: 14.3 per cent against 27.1 per cent. Low-income households spend most or all of their income, so taxes on spending take a bigger share of it. Measured against spending rather than income, the gap is much smaller.
Always classify by the average rate, and show it. Work out tax as a percentage of income for two people, then say which way it moves: "£200 is 2 per cent of £10,000 but 0.4 per cent of £50,000, so the tax is regressive." Never classify from the pounds paid, or from the marginal rate alone.
Check yourself
Using the UK income tax bands, someone earning £30,000 pays £3,486 in income tax. What is their average tax rate, as a percentage to one decimal place?
11.6
Average rate is total tax divided by total income: £3,486 divided by £30,000 is 0.1162, or 11.6 per cent. Their marginal rate is 20 per cent, the rate on their last pound.
Check yourself
Every adult must pay a fixed £200 a year for a licence, whatever their income. How is this tax best classified?
Exam question
Explain why VAT is usually described as a regressive tax, even though high-income households pay more VAT than low-income households. [4]
A regressive tax is one whose average rate falls as income rises. High-income households pay more VAT in pounds because they spend more, but low-income households spend a larger share of their income, often all of it, so VAT takes a bigger share of their income: in 2019-20 the poorest fifth paid about 30 per cent of disposable income in indirect taxes and the richest fifth about 11 per cent.
One mark for the definition by average rate, one for richer households paying more in pounds, one for poorer households spending a larger share of income, and one for applying it: VAT is a larger share of low incomes.
A tax is classified by its average rate: tax paid as a share of income. A progressive tax takes a greater share from those with high incomes, as UK income tax does through rising marginal rates. A proportional tax takes the same share from everyone. A regressive tax takes a smaller share from those with higher incomes, as taxes on spending such as VAT do, even though richer households pay more in pounds.