- Inflation targeting
- Inflation targeting is a rule that requires a central bank to focus primarily on keeping inflation low.
- Countercyclical policy
- Countercyclical policy moves in the opposite direction to the business cycle, loosening in downturns and tightening in upswings.
Pitfalls for monetary policy
Can you name the three pitfalls that can blunt monetary policy?
Each one weakens the link between a decision by the central bank and what happens to spending.
A change in interest rates takes a long and uncertain time to work through lending, spending and prices, with its main effects perhaps one to three years later.
Can you think of an example?
The Monetary Policy Committee raises Bank Rate to curb inflation, but by the time spending slows the economy is already cooling, and the rise deepens the downturn.
Excess reserves are reserves banks choose to hold rather than lend, so extra reserves from loose policy may never reach borrowers.
Can you think of an example?
In a recession Bank Rate is cut, but banks fear borrowers will not repay and keep the extra reserves, while firms with falling sales do not want loans anyway.
The zero lower bound is the floor that stops a central bank cutting its nominal interest rate much below zero, however deep the recession.
Can you think of an example?
Bank Rate is already close to zero and prices are falling, so the real interest rate stays positive and the usual rate cut is no longer available.
Check yourself
Bank Rate is cut sharply in a recession, but banks keep most of the new reserves rather than lend them. Which pitfall is this?
An independent central bank can act quickly and without an eye on the next election
A central bank insulated from day-to-day politics can make tough decisions fast: a Budget takes months to debate and pass, but interest-rate decisions happen far more rapidly. Handing the power to create money to politicians tempts them to expand it to fund their projects, which ends in inflation. Most central bankers see fighting inflation as their main task, and many countries, including the UK, have made inflation targeting a legal requirement. Low, steady inflation lets firms focus on real economic issues rather than protecting themselves from rising prices.
OverheatingDemand at AD0 pushes the economy up the steep part of SRAS: output Y0, price level P0.
Pulling on the string works, but pushing on it may not
Tight policy can definitely raise interest rates and reduce aggregate demand. In the US, rates raised from 5.5 per cent in 1977 to 16.4 per cent in 1981 brought inflation from over ten per cent down to 3.2 per cent by 1983, but at the cost of back-to-back recessions, with unemployment rising from 5.8 to 9.7 per cent. Loose policy is less certain. Japan held its policy rate at or near zero from 1999 to 2003 and expanded its money supply by about half in two years, with no substantial effect on aggregate demand.
Check yourself
Why do central bankers say monetary policy is like a string: pulling works, pushing may not?
The answer depends on which way policy is pushing and how deep the slump is
Monetary policy is well suited to cooling an overheating economy, and usually does have real effects in both directions after its inconveniently long lag. It is weakest in a deep recession with falling prices: if the nominal rate is zero and prices fall five per cent a year, the real interest rate is five per cent and cannot be cut further. Some economists also want central banks to watch asset prices and lending booms, a proposal that remains controversial.
Weigh monetary policy on four things. Direction: tightening is more reliable than loosening. Timing: effects come one to three years later. The state of the economy: near capacity a rate rise cuts inflation cheaply; in a deep slump a cut may do little. Independence: fast, credible decisions. End by naming which of these decides the case.
Check yourself
In which situation is a cut in Bank Rate least likely to raise aggregate demand?
Exam question
Evaluate the effectiveness of monetary policy in stabilising the UK economy. [8]
Changes in Bank Rate pass through to other interest rates, so a rise cuts investment and big-ticket consumption and shifts aggregate demand left, and a cut does the reverse. An independent Monetary Policy Committee can act quickly and without political pressure, and near capacity a rate rise brings inflation down at little cost in output. But the effects take perhaps one to three years to arrive, so policy may act on yesterday's problem. Loosening is less reliable than tightening: in a deep recession banks may hold excess reserves and firms may not borrow, and once Bank Rate is near zero, especially with falling prices, it cannot be cut further. Judgement: effective at restraining inflation, much weaker at ending a deep recession, which is when quantitative easing or fiscal policy is needed.
Levels reward the transmission chain, evaluation naming what effectiveness depends on (direction, lags, the state of the economy, the zero lower bound), and a judgement that follows from it.
An independent central bank targeting inflation can act quickly, and tight policy reliably cuts aggregate demand, so monetary policy is well suited to cooling an overheating economy. Against it: long and variable lags of one to three years; banks holding excess reserves and cautious borrowers in a slump; and the zero lower bound, which bites hardest when prices are falling. Pulling on the string works; pushing may not.