- Market-orientated strategy
- A market-orientated strategy is a development policy that removes barriers to markets, so that prices, profits and competition decide what is produced and where capital goes.
- Interventionist strategy
- An interventionist strategy is a development policy in which the state steers resources itself, by spending, protecting, owning or controlling prices.
Market-orientated strategies
Can you name the six market-orientated strategies the specification lists?
Each one takes a barrier away and leaves the decision to the market.
Trade liberalisation is cutting tariffs, quotas and other barriers to trade, which exposes home firms to world competition and opens world markets to them.
Can you think of an example?
Tariffs on imported machinery are cut, so firms buy better equipment at world prices and protected firms must cut costs or close.
Promoting foreign direct investment means making it easier for foreign firms to build or buy factories, mines and offices in the country.
Can you think of an example?
Foreign firms may now own their plants outright. A foreign carmaker builds one, bringing capital, jobs and skills.
Removing government subsidies means ending payments and cheap loans to chosen firms or products, so that firms compete on equal terms.
Can you think of an example?
Governments in fast-growing Asian economies sometimes chose industries for cheap loans or subsidies, and found that more market incentives for firms and workers were a key ingredient in faster growth.
A floating exchange rate is one set by supply and demand in the foreign exchange market, with no central bank target to defend.
Can you think of an example?
The central bank stops spending reserves to hold the currency up. It falls, and exports become cheaper abroad.
Microfinance is small loans, savings accounts and other financial services for poor people whom ordinary banks do not serve.
Can you think of an example?
Village women each borrow enough to buy a sewing machine, and the group guarantees each member's loan.
Privatisation is the sale of state-owned firms to private owners, who then run them for profit.
Can you think of an example?
The state telephone company is sold to investors, who extend the network to win paying customers.
Check yourself
Three of these are market-orientated strategies. Which one is interventionist?
Interventionist strategies use the state where markets have fallen short
The East Asian economies that grew fastest did not leave everything to markets: their governments backed heavy investment in education and sent students abroad to study the most efficient industries. Interventionist strategies use the state in this way: investing in education and training, building infrastructure such as roads, power and water, protecting infant industries, managing the exchange rate with foreign currency reserves, requiring joint ventures with global companies, and running buffer stocks to steady commodity prices.
Their main weakness is government failure. Schools and roads cost money a poor government may have to borrow, and take years to pay off. Protection meant to be short-term often lasts a very long time, and support goes more often to established industries with political power than to promising new ones.
Market-orientated strategies depend on rules the poorest countries often lack
Markets reward investment only where a legal system protects property rights and enforces contracts. Many low-income countries lack that stability, so they struggle to attract foreign investment at all.
Foreign capital can also leave as fast as it came. In 1997 and 1998 foreign investors pulled their money out of the stock and bond markets, property and banks of Thailand, Indonesia, Malaysia and South Korea, plunging them into deep recession. A factory is harder to move, but its owner can still close it when costs rise. While it runs, much of its profit is sent home to foreign shareholders rather than reinvested. And removing a subsidy on fuel or food hits the poorest households hardest, because such necessities take a larger share of their income.
Check yourself
A foreign firm opens a copper mine in a low-income country and sends most of the mine's profits to its shareholders abroad. Which weakness of a market-orientated strategy does this show?
Isn't promoting FDI interventionist, since the government is doing it?
No. Every strategy is a government choice, so ask who decides afterwards. Promoting FDI leaves foreign firms to choose what to build and where. A required joint venture is interventionist because the state sets the terms of ownership. Likewise a floating exchange rate is market-orientated and a managed one interventionist.
Name the strategy and its group, then give the chain to growth: "trade liberalisation exposes firms to competition, so costs fall and exports rise". Evaluate against the country in the extract, such as weak property rights or a government short of revenue, and judge which strategy suits it.
Check yourself
A central bank spends its foreign currency reserves buying its own currency to keep it within a target band. Which group does this belong to, and what is its main risk?
Exam question
Explain one market-orientated strategy a low-income country could use to promote development, and one reason it may not succeed. [4]
Promoting foreign direct investment, for example by cutting red tape and letting foreign firms own their operations. Foreign firms bring capital, jobs, technology and export earnings the country cannot raise from its own low savings. It may not succeed because much of the profit is sent home to foreign shareholders rather than reinvested, and if property rights are weak or costs rise the firm may never come, or may leave.
One mark for a market-orientated strategy, one for explaining how it promotes growth or development, one for a reason it may fail, and one for developing that reason in the country's context.
Market-orientated strategies remove barriers and let markets decide. They need secure property rights, capital and profits can flow abroad, and the poor bear price rises when subsidies go. Interventionist strategies use the state to invest, protect, own and steer prices. They risk government failure, high cost and long delays.