- Debt relief
- Debt relief means that a country's debt can be partially or totally forgiven, or the growth of the debt can be slowed or stopped.
- Debt rescheduling
- Debt rescheduling is relief in which the dates when interest or repayments fall due are delayed or rearranged, without cancelling the debt.
Two ideas for weighing debt relief
Can you name the two ideas an answer on debt relief has to weigh?
One is a risk in how borrowers behave; the other is the usual guard against it.
Moral hazard is when people take more risk because they are protected from its cost than they would if they bore that cost themselves.
Can you think of an example?
A government that expects its debts to be cancelled again borrows more freely and takes less care over whether its projects will pay back.
Conditionality is granting relief or loans only once the recipient meets agreed terms, such as committing to policies that reduce poverty.
Can you think of an example?
To have its debts cancelled under HIPC, a country must commit to poverty reduction through policy changes and show a good track record.
HIPC and the MDRI cancel debts for the poorest countries that meet conditions
The Heavily Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) Initiative was launched by the IMF and the World Bank in 1996 and revised in 1999 to deliver twice as much relief. It aims to ensure no poor country faces a debt burden it cannot manage. Creditors give relief to countries that complete the HIPC process, which means meeting set criteria, committing to reduce poverty through policy changes and building a good track record.
The Multilateral Debt Relief Initiative (MDRI) goes further: countries completing the HIPC process get 100 per cent relief on their debts to the World Bank, the IMF and the African Development Bank.
Check yourself
A low-income country has just completed the HIPC process. What does the MDRI add?
Supporters say relief frees money for schools, hospitals and growth
In 2011 the UK's development secretary, Andrew Mitchell, said debt relief lets poor countries spend more on schools, hospitals and other services that boost growth and cut poverty. Money that would have gone to foreign creditors can go on them instead. A UK white paper in 2023 cited the UN's estimate that 3.3 billion people live in countries where interest on debt is greater than spending on health or education.
Relief works only if every creditor shares it. The UK's Debt Relief (Developing Countries) Act 2010 stopped so-called vulture funds, creditors that had sometimes bought the debt cheaply, suing HIPCs in UK courts for its full value. The government put the saving to poor countries at £145 million over six years.
A country's debts have been cancelled once. What does economic theory expect to happen to its borrowing afterwards?
Theory says protection from a cost encourages risk. If a government expects its debts to be written off again, it has less reason to borrow carefully or to spend the money well.
Critics warn that relief invites moral hazard, and debt has built up again
The economic objection is moral hazard. A government that expects its debts to be written off has less reason to borrow carefully or to spend the money on projects that pay back. Relief is not free either: the UK counted debt it cancelled as aid spending.
In 2023 a UK white paper reported that nearly sixty per cent of low-income countries were in, or at high risk of, debt distress. It blamed slow growth, low tax revenue, investment that did not pay back and too little export income to repay foreign-currency loans, so moral hazard is one possible cause, not a proven one.
Check yourself
Which of these is an example of moral hazard arising from debt relief?
Conditions guard against moral hazard, but they take time and can fail
Conditions are the usual response to moral hazard: relief comes only after a country commits to reducing poverty and builds a track record over time.
Conditions have costs. A UK government paper in 2005 found that conditions trying to buy reform from an unwilling government rarely worked. Relief can also stall while creditors negotiate: under the G20's newer Common Framework, Zambia waited more than 18 months between a staff-level agreement with the IMF and a deal with its official creditors.
Explain one benefit, such as money freed for health and education, and one cost, such as moral hazard, each tied to a named case: HIPC, the MDRI, the UK's vulture fund law or Zambia's wait. Then judge by naming what success depends on: savings reaching the poor, every creditor taking part, and the causes of new debt being tackled.
Check yourself
Three of these are arguments for debt relief. Which one is an argument against?
Exam question
Evaluate debt relief as a strategy for promoting development in low-income countries. [10]
For: relief frees money that went on debt interest for schools, hospitals and infrastructure; the UN estimates 3.3 billion people live where interest exceeds health or education spending. HIPC and the MDRI cancelled debts for the poorest countries, and the UK's 2010 Act stopped vulture funds undermining relief. Against: moral hazard, as governments expecting relief borrow less carefully; cancelled debt is counted as aid spending, so it has an opportunity cost; and debt distress has returned, with nearly sixty per cent of low-income countries in or at high risk of it in 2023. Conditions answer moral hazard but take time and rarely work on an unwilling government, and relief can stall while creditors negotiate, as Zambia's wait shows. Judgement: relief helps most when it is conditional on spending the savings on the poor, every creditor takes part, and the causes of new debt are tackled.
Up to four marks for explained points each way with evidence, up to three for analysis linking relief to spending, investment and growth, and up to three for a judgement naming what success depends on.
Debt relief forgives debt or slows its growth; rescheduling only moves the dates. HIPC relieves the poorest countries that commit to reducing poverty, and the MDRI then cancels their debts to three multilateral lenders. Relief frees money for schools and hospitals, but risks moral hazard, and debt distress has returned. Conditions answer moral hazard but take time and fail without a willing government.