- Economic development
- Economic development is a broad improvement in people's standard of living, including their health, education, freedom from poverty and the choices open to them.
- Economic growth
- Economic growth is a rise in a country's real output of goods and services over time, measured by the change in real GDP.
Reasons growth can happen without development
Can you name four reasons growth can happen without development?
Each is a way real GDP can rise while most people's lives improve little.
If most of the extra income goes to the richest households, average output rises while most people's lives change little.
Can you think of an example?
Profits from a new copper mine go to its owners and a small group of skilled staff.
Output can rise while air, water or working conditions get worse, cutting well-being that GDP does not count.
Can you think of an example?
A boom in steel output fills a city's air with smoke and sends more people to hospital.
Spending on repairs or security adds to GDP without leaving people better off than before.
Can you think of an example?
Rebuilding after a flood adds to GDP, but people are no better off than before the flood.
If population rises as fast as real GDP, output per person stays the same, so average living standards do not rise.
Can you think of an example?
Real GDP and population each grow by the same percentage a year, so GDP per head is flat.
Growth measures more output, while development measures better lives
Economic growth is a rise in real GDP: more goods and services produced, after allowing for inflation. It is one number, and it measures production well.
Development is wider. It covers health, schooling, poverty, the environment and the choices people can make about their lives. GDP counts spending on some of these, but not how well people actually live, and it leaves out leisure and damage to the environment. So GDP can rise while the standard of living falls, if health or the environment gets worse.
Check yourself
A country's real GDP grows by 6 per cent a year for a decade. Most of the gain goes to a small group, and life expectancy and school enrolment barely change. Which describes it?
Development can come with little growth, and over time the two usually move together
Development does not have to wait for fast growth. A government that pays for clean water, vaccination and primary schooling can raise life expectancy and literacy while output grows slowly.
Over long periods the two tend to go together. In most countries a much higher GDP per head comes with better education, health and environmental protection, because more output can pay for schools, hospitals and cleaner production. Growth makes development possible; it does not guarantee it.
Check yourself
Three of these are signs of economic development. Which one, on its own, shows only economic growth?
If GDP per head is rising, isn't the country developing?
Not necessarily. GDP per head is an average, so it can rise while most people see no gain, if the extra income goes to a few. It also counts output, not how people live: rebuilding after a flood, or a polluting factory, adds to GDP without making lives better.
Rising GDP per head makes development possible, and in most countries the two go together over time. To know whether a country is developing, look at health, schooling, poverty and the environment as well.
Define both terms before comparing them: growth as a rise in real GDP, development as a wider improvement in living standards. Then give one reason they can diverge and tie it to the country in the question, for example oil revenue that reaches few households. Compare living standards with GDP per head, not total GDP.
Check yourself
A government keeps its total spending the same but moves money from road building into clean water supplies and free primary schooling in rural areas. What is this most likely to bring?
Exam question
Using an example, explain why economic growth may not lead to economic development. [4]
Economic growth is a rise in real GDP, while economic development is a broader improvement in living standards such as health, education and freedom from poverty. Growth may not bring development if the extra income goes to a few. For example, revenue from a new oil field may go to the firm's owners and a small group of workers, so GDP rises while most households see no better healthcare or schooling.
One mark for each definition, one for a reason growth and development can diverge, and one for an example applied to it. Pollution, spending on repairs or population growing as fast as output also earn the reason mark.
Economic growth is a rise in real GDP. Economic development is a broader improvement in living standards: health, education, freedom from poverty and choice. Growth can happen without development when gains go to a few, when output harms health or the environment, when it only replaces losses, or when population grows as fast. Development can come with little growth. Over time the two usually move together.