Learn › Economic theory › Advanced theory

Advanced theory

Indifference curves

Draw indifference curves and a budget line and find the consumer's optimum

Key terms
Indifference curve
An indifference curve shows combinations of two goods that provide an equal level of utility or satisfaction to one person.
Budget constraint
A budget constraint shows every combination of two goods a person can afford, given their prices and the income there is to spend.

How a person trades one good for another

Can you name the three ideas that give an indifference curve its shape?

At A-level, utility is counted in utils. An indifference curve drops the numbers: it needs only that a person can say which of two bundles they prefer, or that they do not mind. These three ideas follow from that.

Check yourself

Three of these describe a normal indifference curve. Which one does not?

Moving along one indifference curve
Two moves along the same indifference curveVertical axis: Doughnuts. Horizontal axis: Books. IC: a downward-sloping curve. J: at D1 on the vertical axis and B1 on the horizontal axis. K: at D2 on the vertical axis and B2 on the horizontal axis.B1D1B2D2ICJKLM
1 of 2

Few booksFrom J to K, one more book is worth two doughnuts: B1 to B2 costs D1 minus D2.

Check yourself

On the same indifference curve, why is a sixth book worth far fewer doughnuts than a third book?

Take a guess

Lilly has a budget line and a map of indifference curves. Where is her best affordable choice?

Moving along the budget line to the highest curve
The budget line touches the highest indifference curve at EVertical axis: Doughnuts. Horizontal axis: Books. BL: a downward-sloping line. IC1: a downward-sloping curve. IC2: a downward-sloping curve. IC3: a downward-sloping curve. G: IC1 meets BL, at D1 on the vertical axis and B1 on the horizontal axis. E: at D2 on the vertical axis and B2 on the horizontal axis.B1D1B2D2BLIC1IC2IC3GE
1 of 3

An affordable choiceG is on the budget line BL, but only on the low curve IC1.

Check yourself

Which point is this consumer's best affordable choice?

A budget line and three indifference curvesVertical axis: Good Y. Horizontal axis: Good X. BL: a downward-sloping line. U1: a downward-sloping curve. U2: a downward-sloping curve. U3: a downward-sloping curve. Q: U1 meets BL.BLU1U2U3PQRS
Common mistake

Can two of a person's indifference curves cross?

No. Suppose they did. The bundle at the crossing would be as good as every point on one curve and as good as every point on the other. Transitivity would then make a point on the first curve exactly as good as a point on the second, yet away from the crossing one of those points can have more of both goods, and more of both is always preferred. So the curves nest inside each other, one for every level of utility.

Exam tip

Draw the budget line first and the tangent curve second. Then mark one lower curve that the line cuts and one higher curve it cannot reach, and say why neither is the choice. State the condition in words and symbols: the rate she will swap equals the rate the shop swaps, MRS = Px ÷ Py.

Exam question

Nobody can measure happiness in units. Doesn't that sink the whole theory of consumer choice? [4]

Exam question

Draw your indifference curves between £1 coins and 50p coins. Why are they straight lines, and what does that tell you about why most curves bend? [4]

Exam question

At your best choice between tea and coffee, why must the rate you would swap them equal the rate the café charges? [4]

What to take away

An indifference curve joins bundles that give one person equal utility, and needs no numbers, only rankings. The curves slope down, bow towards the origin because the marginal rate of substitution diminishes, never cross, and higher curves are preferred. The best affordable choice is where the budget line just touches the highest curve it can reach, so the marginal rate of substitution equals the price ratio.