- Indifference curve
- An indifference curve shows combinations of two goods that provide an equal level of utility or satisfaction to one person.
- Budget constraint
- A budget constraint shows every combination of two goods a person can afford, given their prices and the income there is to spend.
How a person trades one good for another
Can you name the three ideas that give an indifference curve its shape?
At A-level, utility is counted in utils. An indifference curve drops the numbers: it needs only that a person can say which of two bundles they prefer, or that they do not mind. These three ideas follow from that.
The marginal rate of substitution is the rate at which a person is willing to trade one good for another so that utility remains the same.
Can you think of an example?
If you would give up two doughnuts for one more book and feel no better or worse off, your marginal rate of substitution is two doughnuts per book. It is the slope of your indifference curve, without the minus sign.
A diminishing marginal rate of substitution means that the more of one good a person has, the less of the other they will give up for one more unit of it.
Can you think of an example?
With a few books and plenty of doughnuts, one more book is worth a lot of doughnuts. With a shelf full of books and few doughnuts, it is worth hardly any. That is why the curve is steep on the left and flat on the right.
An indifference map is the whole field of a person's indifference curves, one for every level of utility, with higher curves giving more utility.
Can you think of an example?
Take any point on a lower curve and you can find a point on a higher one with more of both goods. So every point on the higher curve beats every point on the lower one, and two curves can never cross.
Check yourself
Three of these describe a normal indifference curve. Which one does not?
Few booksFrom J to K, one more book is worth two doughnuts: B1 to B2 costs D1 minus D2.
Moving along IC from J to K, books rise from B1 to B2 and doughnuts fall from D1 to D2, with satisfaction unchanged.
- Every point on IC gives the same utility. So one more book must be paid for with fewer doughnuts, which is why the curve slopes down.
- From J to K, the third book is worth two whole doughnuts: with few books, one more matters a lot. From L to M, the sixth book is worth less than half a doughnut.
- The slope, and so the marginal rate of substitution, falls as you move right. Diminishing marginal utility of both goods is the intuition for the convex shape; strictly, the model simply assumes a diminishing MRS.
Check yourself
On the same indifference curve, why is a sixth book worth far fewer doughnuts than a third book?
Lilly has a budget line and a map of indifference curves. Where is her best affordable choice?
A curve the budget line crosses has points above it that are also affordable, on a higher curve. Keep moving up and you reach the one curve the line only touches. Nothing higher is affordable.
An affordable choiceG is on the budget line BL, but only on the low curve IC1.
Moving along BL from G to E, books fall from B1 to B2 and doughnuts rise from D1 to D2, reaching the highest curve IC2 the budget allows.
- Books cost £3, doughnuts £2 and Lilly has £18, so BL runs from 9 doughnuts to 6 books with a slope of minus 1.5, the price ratio.
- G is affordable but sits on IC1, where the line cuts the curve. Moving along BL towards E reaches higher curves at no extra cost.
- At E the line just touches IC2. There the slope of the curve equals the slope of the line: MRS = Pbooks ÷ Pdoughnuts. IC3 would be better but no point on it is affordable.
Check yourself
Which point is this consumer's best affordable choice?
P is on the highest curve, so it would be best of all, but it lies outside the budget line and cannot be afforded.
Q is affordable, but the budget line cuts through U1 there. Moving along the line towards R reaches a higher curve for the same money.
R is where the budget line just touches U2. No affordable point is on a higher curve, and the MRS equals the price ratio.
S is inside the budget line, so some money is left unspent. Spending it would reach a higher curve, so S cannot be the best choice.
Can two of a person's indifference curves cross?
No. Suppose they did. The bundle at the crossing would be as good as every point on one curve and as good as every point on the other. Transitivity would then make a point on the first curve exactly as good as a point on the second, yet away from the crossing one of those points can have more of both goods, and more of both is always preferred. So the curves nest inside each other, one for every level of utility.
Draw the budget line first and the tangent curve second. Then mark one lower curve that the line cuts and one higher curve it cannot reach, and say why neither is the choice. State the condition in words and symbols: the rate she will swap equals the rate the shop swaps, MRS = Px ÷ Py.
Exam question
Nobody can measure happiness in units. Doesn't that sink the whole theory of consumer choice? [4]
No. Indifference curves need only that a person can rank bundles: this one is better, worse, or just as good. From rankings, plus the assumption that the MRS diminishes, the curves slope down, bow towards the origin and never cross, and the best choice is where the budget line touches the highest one. No utils are needed, and the predictions, such as how quantities respond to a price change, can be tested. What the approach does assume is that rankings are consistent: if you prefer A to B and B to C, you prefer A to C. People sometimes break that.
A strong answer states the ordinal model, shows it still gives the tangency result and testable predictions, and then names the assumption it rests on, consistent (transitive) preferences, with a hint that behaviour can break it.
Exam question
Draw your indifference curves between £1 coins and 50p coins. Why are they straight lines, and what does that tell you about why most curves bend? [4]
Two 50p coins are always worth exactly one £1 coin to me, however many of each I hold, so the marginal rate of substitution is fixed at two and each curve is a straight line; with £1 coins on the horizontal axis its slope is minus two. They are perfect substitutes. Most goods are not: the more books I have, the less one more is worth in doughnuts, so the MRS diminishes and the curve bows in. The bend measures how imperfect the substitutes are; at the other extreme, left and right shoes are perfect complements and the curves are L-shaped.
Start from the MRS, show it is constant for perfect substitutes, then use that to explain why diminishing MRS bends ordinary curves. Naming the other extreme, perfect complements, shows the interviewer you see the whole range.
Exam question
At your best choice between tea and coffee, why must the rate you would swap them equal the rate the café charges? [4]
Suppose I would give up two teas for one coffee but the café charges only one tea's worth for a coffee. Then swapping one tea for a coffee leaves me better off, so I am not at my best choice yet. I keep swapping until my MRS, which falls as I get more coffee, equals the price ratio. That is the tangency: MRS = Pcoffee ÷ Ptea. It assumes I can buy in small amounts and buy some of both; if I hate tea, the best choice is all coffee, a corner where the rule need not hold.
Explain the rule with a swap that makes you better off, show diminishing MRS closes the gap, then state the tangency. Pointing out the corner solution, where someone buys none of one good, is the assumption-breaker.
An indifference curve joins bundles that give one person equal utility, and needs no numbers, only rankings. The curves slope down, bow towards the origin because the marginal rate of substitution diminishes, never cross, and higher curves are preferred. The best affordable choice is where the budget line just touches the highest curve it can reach, so the marginal rate of substitution equals the price ratio.