Before you start
What you'll be able to answer
- What is deflation, and how far did prices in Japan fall from 1999 to 2005?
- Why did prices keep falling, and had anyone expected it?
- Why did falling prices matter for firms carrying heavy debts?
Where this sits
Japan's Lost Decade — 1989 to 2006 · this module is lit
- Dec 1989Share prices in Japan peak
- Aug 1990The Bank of Japan's last rise in its discount rate, the interest rate at which it lent to banks
- Aug 1992The government announces the first of six spending packages up to 1995
- 1995-96The first direct use of taxpayers' money against financial instability covers losses at failed housing-loan companies, the jusen
- 1 Apr 1997The consumption tax rate, a tax on what people buy, is raised
- Nov 1997Sanyo Securities, Hokkaido Takushoku Bank and Yamaichi Securities fail
- Oct-Dec 1998Japan's parliament, the Diet, makes more public money available to deal with banks' bad loans, and the state takes over the Long-Term Credit Bank and Nippon Credit Bank
- Feb 1999The Bank of Japan begins its zero interest rate policy, pushing its overnight rate as low as possible
- Mar 1999Public capital, new capital paid for by the state, is put into the major banks
- Mar 2001The Bank of Japan begins quantitative easing, a target for the money banks keep in their accounts with it
- Oct 2002The Financial Services Agency, the banking regulator, launches its programme to cut bad loans
- Mar 2006The Bank of Japan ends quantitative easing
In 1999 prices in Japan began a run of yearly falls
By 1999 Japan's economy had been weak for most of a decade. The Bank of Japan, Japan's central bank, had cut its interest rate in several steps. The government had also put public money into the banks. Then prices started to fall. In 1999 the prices households paid for the things they bought were lower, on average, than a year before. They went on falling, or at best holding flat, until 2005.
From 1999 to 2005, by how much do you think the prices households paid in Japan fell in a typical year?
By less than 1 per cent a year. Even the biggest yearly fall in the period was under 1 per cent, and in 2004 prices barely moved, so the larger options overstate it. Each fall was small. The falls mattered because they kept coming year after year.
From the late 1990s Japan had deflation
From the late 1990s Japan had deflation. Deflation is a fall in the general level of prices across the whole economy. When it happens, the same amount of yen buys a little more than it did a year before.
Two measures track it. The consumer price index follows the prices of a typical set of goods and services that households buy. That set includes goods made abroad. GDP is the value of everything produced in Japan in a year. The GDP deflator follows the prices of all those goods and services. The GDP deflator covers what households buy. It also covers the machines and buildings that firms buy, and the goods Japan sells abroad. The GDP deflator leaves out imports, because they are made elsewhere.
Consumer prices fell or held flat every year from 1999 to 2005
The chart shows how much consumer prices changed each year, on figures from the World Bank, an international development lender. Above zero, prices rose on the year before; below zero, they fell. In the early 1990s they were still rising.
From 1999 to 2005 consumer prices fell or held flat every year. They fell most in 2002, by 0.9 per cent, and in 2004 they barely moved. Each yearly fall was small. Added together, the falls left consumer prices in 2005 about 3 per cent lower than in 1998. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) advises and lends to its member countries. It reported that most of its measures showed the forces pushing prices down growing stronger through 2000 and early 2001.
Source: World Bank, World Development Indicators (FP.CPI.TOTL.ZG, from IMF International Financial Statistics), data last updated 13 July 2026. CC BY 4.0.
Check yourself
Look at the chart before 1999. In which earlier year did consumer prices also fall slightly?
Prices across the whole economy fell by more
On the same World Bank figures, the GDP deflator, which measures prices across the whole economy, fell in every year from 1999 to 2005. In each of those years it fell by more than consumer prices. It had also fallen in 1995, 1996 and 1998, before consumer prices began their run of falls.
In December 2001 the Cabinet Office, part of Japan's government, said Japan was in what it called a mild deflation. By its count, consumer prices had been falling for about two years, and the GDP deflator since the mid-1990s.
Check yourself
Which of these price falls would show up in Japan's GDP deflator but not in its consumer price index?
The Cabinet Office gave three kinds of reason for the falling prices
Why did prices keep falling? In its December 2001 report the Cabinet Office gave three kinds of reason. First, more cheap imports, new information technology and changes in the way goods reached shops made goods cheaper to supply. Second, the economy was weak, so households and firms bought too little, and sellers cut prices. Third, banks were lending less of the money savers had put in them, so firms had less to spend.
Some argued that falling prices caused by cheap imports and new technology were a good kind of deflation. The Cabinet Office called this debatable. It said the whole level of prices was falling, not only the prices of some goods. Firms carried too much debt, and banks held large bad loans that were not being repaid. With debts like these, it said, deflation harmed the economy even when prices fell only a little.
Check yourself
Three of these would tend to push prices across a whole economy down. Which one would not?
Federal Reserve staff said the slump had not been foreseen
Staff at the Federal Reserve, the US central bank, wrote in 2002 that Japan's long slump with falling prices in the 1990s "was not anticipated". Japanese policymakers did not expect it. Private and foreign observers did not expect it. Nor did the Federal Reserve's own economists. Inflation is the rate at which prices rise. Forecasts made two years ahead kept predicting more growth and more inflation for Japan than actually happened. They did so right up to the second half of the 1990s.
The staff wrote that deflation can be very hard to predict. So once interest rates and inflation are close to zero, a central bank should perhaps act against the risk of deflation. It should do so even when its main forecast does not show deflation coming.
Back to firms and their debts. A firm borrowed ¥100 million in 1995 and still owes it. From 1999 the prices it charges for what it sells fall a little each year. Compared with the firm's income, does the debt get easier or harder to carry?
It gets heavier. The firm still owes ¥100 million, but each sale brings in fewer yen than before, so repaying takes a bigger share of its income. Some of its costs may fall, but the debt itself does not shrink.
Falling prices made heavy debts heavier, the Cabinet Office said
A debt is fixed in yen. When prices fall, a firm's sales bring in fewer yen, so the same debt takes a larger share of its income. The real interest rate rises too. That is the cost of borrowing after taking account of how prices change. While prices fall, the real interest rate is roughly the interest rate plus the rate at which prices fall.
Deflation cut firms' profits in two ways, the Cabinet Office said in December 2001. It made heavily indebted firms' debts heavier, and it raised real interest rates and real wages, which are what pay is worth after taking account of prices. Both held back investment. Bank of Japan economists disagreed in 2005. They found no sign that falling prices had sharply raised real interest rates or the real weight of debts. They blamed falling share and land prices for the serious damage.
Check yourself
Work from this section: a firm pays 0.5 per cent interest a year on a loan, while prices across the economy fall by 1.5 per cent a year. Roughly what is its real cost of borrowing, in per cent a year?
2 per cent a year
About 2 per cent a year: 0.5 plus 1.5. With prices falling, each yen repaid is worth more than the yen borrowed, so the real cost is higher than the interest rate the firm pays.
Cutting the interest rate had not stopped prices falling
Central banks usually respond to falling prices by cutting their interest rate, which makes borrowing cheaper. The Bank of Japan had cut its call rate to under 0.5 per cent by the summer of 1995. The call rate is the rate banks charge each other for one-day loans. From 1999 the Bank cut the rate lower still. These cuts were not enough to stop the forces pushing prices down, Bank of Japan economists later wrote. Price stability means prices neither rising fast nor falling. Price stability had been hard to achieve for 25 years, since the economy fell into deflation in the late 1990s, the Bank said in 2024.
What did the Bank of Japan try when cutting its interest rate was no longer enough? The next module follows the Bank's next steps.
Check yourself
The key questions
What is deflation, and how far did prices in Japan fall from 1999 to 2005?
Deflation is a fall in prices across the whole economy. Consumer prices fell or held flat each year from 1999 to 2005. Each fall was small, but together they came to a few per cent. The GDP deflator fell every year, and by more.
Why did prices keep falling, and had anyone expected it?
In its 2001 account the Cabinet Office gave three reasons: cheap imports and new technology, weak spending, and banks lending less. Federal Reserve staff wrote in 2002 that the 1990s slump with falling prices had not been anticipated, in Japan or abroad.
Why did falling prices matter for firms carrying heavy debts?
A debt stays fixed in yen while a firm's prices and income fall, so it weighs more and the real cost of borrowing rises. The Cabinet Office said in 2001 that deflation made heavily indebted firms' debts heavier and held back their investment. Bank of Japan economists later took a different view. They found no sharp rise in the real weight of debts.
The numbers
Check yourself
Which of these would count as deflation?
Check yourself
Part of Japan's price fall came from cheap imports and new technology. Why did the Cabinet Office still call deflation harmful?
Check yourself
Why did the Cabinet Office say deflation hurt firms that already carried heavy debts?