Before you start
What you'll be able to answer
- What was the zero interest rate policy, and why did the Bank of Japan say it ended it in August 2000?
- What was quantitative easing, and how long did the Bank of Japan promise to keep it?
- How did the zero interest rate policy and quantitative easing differ?
Where this sits
Japan's Lost Decade — 1989 to 2006 · this module is lit
- Dec 1989Share prices in Japan peak
- Aug 1990The Bank of Japan's last rise in its discount rate, the interest rate at which it lent to banks
- Aug 1992The government announces the first of six spending packages up to 1995
- 1995-96The first direct use of taxpayers' money against financial instability covers losses at failed housing-loan companies, the jusen
- 1 Apr 1997The consumption tax rate, a tax on what people buy, is raised
- Nov 1997Sanyo Securities, Hokkaido Takushoku Bank and Yamaichi Securities fail
- Oct-Dec 1998Japan's parliament, the Diet, makes more public money available to deal with banks' bad loans, and the state takes over the Long-Term Credit Bank and Nippon Credit Bank
- Feb 1999The Bank of Japan begins its zero interest rate policy, pushing its overnight rate as low as possible
- Mar 1999Public capital, new capital paid for by the state, is put into the major banks
- Mar 2001The Bank of Japan begins quantitative easing, a target for the money banks keep in their accounts with it
- Oct 2002The Financial Services Agency, the banking regulator, launches its programme to cut bad loans
- Mar 2006The Bank of Japan ends quantitative easing
By 1999 the Bank of Japan had little room left to cut its rate
Early in 1999 Japan's economy was still weak and its prices were falling. The Bank of Japan is Japan's central bank. It steered the overnight rate, which is the rate banks charge each other for one-day loans. Since September 1998 that rate had been about a quarter of one per cent, so there was little room left to cut. Interest rates on long-term loans had also risen, which made borrowing for several years more expensive. Share prices were weak too.
Banks borrow from each other overnight when they run short of money. Suppose the central bank gives banks more money than they need. What do you expect to happen to the overnight rate?
It falls. Banks with spare money have little need to borrow and are keen to lend what they do not need, so the price of an overnight loan drops. That is how the Bank of Japan pushed the rate down in 1999.
In February 1999 the Bank pushed its overnight rate as low as possible
On 12 February 1999 the Bank of Japan began pushing its overnight rate as low as possible. It did this by supplying banks with more money than they needed. Banks with spare money will lend it to other banks for less, so the rate falls. At first the Bank aimed for around 0.15 per cent, then lower. It moved in steps so that short-term market rates would not jump about. The rate was virtually zero by March.
The Bank of Japan calls this push to near zero the world's first zero interest rate policy. Its aim, the Bank said, was to support the economy as much as it could and to stop the pressure for falling prices from growing. When prices fall, firms get less for what they sell. Their debts, fixed in yen, then become harder to repay.
In April 1999 the Bank promised to keep the rate at zero
Two months later, in April 1999, the Bank of Japan promised to keep the rate there until the fear of falling prices had passed. At the time, the Bank called this promise the policy duration effect. A promise like it is now called forward guidance.
The promise was meant to lower interest rates on loans for longer periods. A lender making a loan for several years looks ahead. It asks where the overnight rate is likely to be during those years. If it expects the rate to stay at zero for longer, it can charge less. Such a promise gave more support than a zero rate on its own, Bank of Japan economists wrote in 2005. The promise lowered the rates lenders expected in future.
Check yourself
Suppose that in mid-1999 lenders had stopped believing the promise, and expected the overnight rate to rise within a year. What would you expect to happen to interest rates on loans for several years?
In August 2000 the Bank ended the zero rate, saying the fear of falling prices had passed
The economy grew again from late 1999. In August 2000 the Bank of Japan ended the zero interest rate policy. It said it judged that the fear of falling prices had passed. A serious downturn followed because the world bought fewer high-technology goods. Early in 2001 the Bank cut its interest rates again.
The chart shows the discount rate from 1995 to 2007. The discount rate is the rate at which the Bank lent to banks. From 1995 the Bank also steered the overnight rate, as well as setting the discount rate. The discount rate stayed at 0.5 per cent throughout the zero rate policy. Early in 2001 the Bank cut it in two steps to 0.25 per cent. The Bank then offered to lend to any bank at that rate whenever the bank asked. So no bank would pay another bank more than that to borrow overnight.
Source: IMF, Monetary and Financial Statistics (MFS_IR), discount rate, Japan. IMF data, used with credit.
Check yourself
Look at the chart. What was the lowest level the discount rate reached on the chart?
In March 2001 the Bank of Japan began quantitative easing
Banks keep accounts at the Bank of Japan, called current accounts, and must hold a minimum amount in them. On 19 March 2001 the Bank stopped setting a target for the overnight rate. Instead it set a target for the total held in those accounts. The first target was about ¥5 trillion. That target was a trillion yen more than banks had held on average in February. In February they held little more than the minimum. The Bank added the extra money through its trading in financial markets. With more than they needed, banks had little reason to pay to borrow, and the overnight rate fell back to effectively zero.
Quantitative easing meant a target for a quantity of money in place of a target for an interest rate.
The Bank of Japan also promised to keep quantitative easing going for a while. What do you think it tied the end of the policy to?
Consumer prices no longer falling. The April 1999 promise was also tied to what happened to prices. Neither promise named a date or an amount of money.
The Bank raised the target and promised to keep going until prices had stopped falling for good
The Bank raised the target several times, to ¥30-35 trillion by January 2004. That was far above the minimum banks were required to hold, which was by then roughly ¥6 trillion.
From the start the Bank also made a promise. Quantitative easing would stay in place until consumer prices were steadily at least as high as a year before. The price measure for this test left out fresh food. Because of the promise, lenders could expect the overnight rate to stay near zero until prices had stopped falling for good.
Check yourself
Three of these were true of both the zero interest rate policy and quantitative easing. Which was true of quantitative easing only?
Check yourself
Suppose that in 2003 consumer prices, leaving out fresh food, rose above a year before for a single month, then fell back. Under its quantitative easing promise, what should the Bank of Japan do?
The Cabinet Office said the money was not reaching borrowers
In 2002 the Cabinet Office, part of Japan's government, wrote that the monetary base had risen sharply. The monetary base is the cash and bank balances the central bank supplies. A wider measure of money also counts the public's bank deposits. It had grown slowly, and the economy stayed weak.
In 2003 the Cabinet Office added that banks were buying government bonds instead of lending. Banks held back because they worried about their capital, the cushion that absorbs a bank's losses. Banks should clear their bad loans, the office said. These were loans unlikely to be paid back.
Quantitative easing was thought to have worked mainly in two ways, the Bank of Japan said in 2024. The promise held down longer-term interest rates. The plentiful money kept the banks stable.
How were the banks' bad loans finally cut, and how did the period end? The next module follows both.
Check yourself
The key questions
What was the zero interest rate policy, and why did the Bank of Japan say it ended it in August 2000?
From February 1999 the Bank pushed its overnight rate as low as possible, and in April promised to keep it there until the fear of falling prices had passed. In August 2000 it ended the policy, saying it judged that the fear of falling prices had passed.
What was quantitative easing, and how long did the Bank of Japan promise to keep it?
From March 2001 the Bank set a target for the money banks kept in their accounts with it. The target was above the minimum they had to hold, and the Bank raised it several times. It promised to keep the policy until consumer prices, leaving out fresh food, were steadily at least as high as a year before.
How did the zero interest rate policy and quantitative easing differ?
The zero interest rate policy targeted an interest rate, the overnight rate. Quantitative easing targeted a quantity, the money banks held at the central bank. Both kept the overnight rate near zero and came with a promise tied to prices.
The numbers
Check yourself
Why did the Bank of Japan say it ended the zero interest rate policy in August 2000?
Check yourself
What did the Bank of Japan do with its quantitative easing target between 2001 and 2004?
Check yourself
What did quantitative easing set a target for?