Learn › Economic theory › When markets fail

When markets fail

Occupational and geographical immobility

Tell occupational from geographical immobility, and explain how each causes structural unemployment

Specification: AQA 4.1.8.6, 4.2.3.2 Edexcel 2.1.3, 3.5.2

Key terms
Immobility of labour
Immobility of labour is the difficulty workers have in moving to a different occupation or a different area, so labour does not flow to where it is wanted.
Structural unemployment
Structural unemployment is unemployment that lasts because the skills or the location of the people out of work do not match the vacancies on offer.

Kinds of labour immobility

Can you name the two kinds of labour immobility?

One kind stops a worker changing job; the other stops a worker changing place.

Check yourself

An unemployed printer in Hull has the skills for print jobs advertised in Leeds, but cannot sell his house for enough to buy one there. Which kind of immobility keeps him out of work?

Skills, housing and family ties keep workers where they are

Moving into a new occupation takes time and money: a worker whose skills are no longer in demand may need years of training. People with degrees can more easily be retrained; for people with few skills and little education, that option is more limited.

Moving to a new area has costs too: finding out about jobs elsewhere, selling one house and buying another near the new job, and leaving family and friends. How willing people are to move to new areas for work may also depend on history and culture. Where the vacancies are in places with high house prices and rents, the cost of moving is higher still.

Check yourself

Three of these cause geographical immobility. Which one causes occupational immobility?

Immobility leaves jobs empty in one place while workers sit idle in another

When labour cannot move, the market fails to shift it from shrinking industries and areas to growing ones. Vacancies stay unfilled while people who could fill them after retraining or a move stay out of work, so the economy produces less than its resources allow. Unemployment of this kind lasts after spending recovers, and it is structural unemployment.

Policy aims at each barrier. Retraining helps workers whose skills are no longer in demand. Better information about jobs and help with the mobility of workers bring workers and employers together more quickly. More housing where jobs are growing lowers the cost of moving there.

Common mistake

Aren't immobility and structural unemployment the same thing?

No. Immobility is the barrier; structural unemployment is what it produces once demand shifts. A miner whose pit closes stays unemployed because he cannot easily retrain or move to where the vacancies are. If he could do either, his time out of work would be short, closer to frictional unemployment. A policy that lowers the barrier, such as retraining, is a policy against structural unemployment.

Exam tip

Name the kind of immobility and the barrier behind it, then say what it does to the market: "geographical: rents in Cambridge are too high for a care worker from Hartlepool, so vacancies there stay empty while she is unemployed". For a policy, match it to the barrier: retraining for occupational, help with housing or moving for geographical.

Check yourself

Which policy is aimed at occupational immobility?

Exam question

Explain how geographical immobility of labour can lead to market failure. [4]

What to take away

Labour is immobile when workers cannot easily change occupation or area. Occupational immobility comes from lacking the skills or qualifications new work needs. Geographical immobility comes from the cost of moving, housing, family ties and not knowing about jobs elsewhere. Either way, vacancies go unfilled while people stay out of work, which is a market failure and a cause of structural unemployment. Retraining, better job information, help with moving and more housing where jobs are growing each target one barrier.