- Buffer stock scheme
- A buffer stock scheme keeps a commodity's price between a floor and a ceiling by buying stock when harvests are good and selling it when they are bad.
- Price floor
- A price floor is the lowest price that one can legally pay for some good or service.
A bumper wheat harvest is about to push the market price below the scheme's floor. What do you think the agency does?
A floor in a buffer stock scheme is held up by buying, not by law. Buying the extra wheat adds to demand, so the price stays at the floor instead of falling below it.
Normal harvestWith a normal harvest S1 the market clears at P1, inside the band between the floor and the ceiling. The agency does nothing.
A good harvest shifts supply right from S1 to S2, and from Q1 to Q2. To stop the price falling from P1 below the floor Pf, the agency buys.
- Farm prices swing because harvests swing with the weather while demand stays much the same. Once the crop is in, the quantity is fixed, so each harvest is a vertical supply curve.
- Left alone, the good harvest Q2 would drive the price down to P2. At the floor Pf buyers want only Qd, so the agency buys the gap, Q2 minus Qd, adding to demand to keep the price at Pf.
- The purchases cost the agency Pf times the quantity bought, and the wheat then sits in store until a bad year. In the UK the Rural Payments Agency can open intervention buying in a crisis, taking wheat, butter or skimmed milk powder off the market to sell at a later date.
Check yourself
The floor price for wheat is £160 a tonne. Farmers harvest 9 million tonnes, and at £160 buyers want 7 million tonnes. How many million tonnes must the agency buy to hold the price at the floor?
2 million tonnes
Buyers take 7 million tonnes at £160, so the agency buys the other 9 − 7 = 2 million tonnes. Any less, and the unsold wheat would push the price below the floor.
Normal harvestWith a normal harvest S1 the market clears at P1, inside the band. The agency does nothing.
A bad harvest shifts supply left from S1 to S3, and from Q1 to Q3. To stop the price rising from P1 above the ceiling Pc, the agency sells.
- Left alone, the small harvest Q3 would push the price up to P3. At the ceiling Pc buyers want Qd, more than was harvested, so the agency sells Qd minus Q3 from its store, adding to supply to keep the price at Pc.
- It can only sell what it holds. After a run of bad harvests the store is empty, and the price rises above the ceiling as if there were no scheme.
Check yourself
The two dashed lines are the scheme's floor and ceiling. Each point is where the price would settle after a different harvest if there were no scheme. What does the agency do at each?
Point A: Sells from store. A lies above the ceiling, so the harvest was small. Selling from store adds to supply and brings the price down to the ceiling.
Point B: Does nothing. B lies inside the band, so the market price is already acceptable and the agency leaves the market alone.
Point C: Buys into store. C lies below the floor, so the harvest was large. Buying the surplus adds to demand and holds the price up at the floor.
If the agency buys cheap and sells dear, doesn't the scheme pay for itself?
Only if the band sits around the price the market would average across good and bad years, and nobody knows that price in advance. Set the floor too high and the agency buys in more years than it sells, so stock piles up, storage bills grow and taxpayers cover the loss. Stored food also goes off, and some crops cannot be stored at all. A guaranteed floor also gives farmers a reason to plant more, which adds to the surplus the agency has to buy.
Draw one demand curve, the floor and the ceiling as dashed horizontal lines, and a vertical supply curve for each harvest. Label the quantity bought, Q2 minus Qd, at the floor and the quantity sold at the ceiling. For evaluation, name why schemes fail: a band set in the wrong place, storage costs, stock that perishes and a store that runs empty.
Check yourself
Three of these are reasons buffer stock schemes run into trouble. Which one is not?
Exam question
Using a diagram, explain how a buffer stock scheme stops the price of a crop falling after a good harvest. [4]
The scheme sets a floor Pf below the ceiling. A good harvest shifts supply right from S1 to S2, so the market price would fall to P2, below the floor. At Pf buyers want only Qd, so the agency buys the surplus, Q2 minus Qd, into store. This adds to demand and holds the price at Pf; the stock is sold in a later bad year.
One mark each for: a vertical supply curve for each harvest, with P2 shown below the floor; supply shifting right with the market price falling below the floor; the agency buying Q2 minus Qd; the purchase holding the price at the floor. Saying the price is held up by law loses the last mark.
A buffer stock scheme holds a crop's price inside a band. When a good harvest would push the price below the floor, the agency buys the surplus into store, adding to demand; when a bad harvest would push it above the ceiling, it sells from store, adding to supply. Inside the band it does nothing. Schemes fail when the band is set too high, so stock piles up and taxpayers pay, when stock perishes, and when a run of bad harvests empties the store.