Learn › Economic theory › When markets fail

When markets fail

Buffer stock schemes

Draw a buffer stock scheme and say why such schemes fail

Specification: Edexcel 4.3.3

Key terms
Buffer stock scheme
A buffer stock scheme keeps a commodity's price between a floor and a ceiling by buying stock when harvests are good and selling it when they are bad.
Price floor
A price floor is the lowest price that one can legally pay for some good or service.
Take a guess

A bumper wheat harvest is about to push the market price below the scheme's floor. What do you think the agency does?

A good harvest
A good harvest inside a price bandVertical axis: Price of wheat. Horizontal axis: Quantity of wheat. D: a downward-sloping line. S1: a vertical line. S2: a vertical line. D meets S1, at price P1 and quantity Q1. D meets S2, at price P2 and quantity Q2. A point at price Pf and quantity Qd. Horizontal line: Floor. Horizontal line: Ceiling.FloorCeilingQ1P1Q2P2QdPfDS1S2bought
1 of 3

Normal harvestWith a normal harvest S1 the market clears at P1, inside the band between the floor and the ceiling. The agency does nothing.

Check yourself

The floor price for wheat is £160 a tonne. Farmers harvest 9 million tonnes, and at £160 buyers want 7 million tonnes. How many million tonnes must the agency buy to hold the price at the floor?

million tonnes
A bad harvest
A bad harvest inside a price bandVertical axis: Price of wheat. Horizontal axis: Quantity of wheat. D: a downward-sloping line. S1: a vertical line. S3: a vertical line. D meets S1, at price P1 and quantity Q1. D meets S3, at price P3. A point at quantity Q3. A point at price Pc and quantity Qd. Horizontal line: Floor. Horizontal line: Ceiling.FloorCeilingQ1P1P3Q3QdPcDS1S3sold
1 of 3

Normal harvestWith a normal harvest S1 the market clears at P1, inside the band. The agency does nothing.

Check yourself

The two dashed lines are the scheme's floor and ceiling. Each point is where the price would settle after a different harvest if there were no scheme. What does the agency do at each?

Three harvests and a price bandVertical axis: Price of wheat. Horizontal axis: Quantity of wheat. D: a downward-sloping line. Horizontal line: Floor. Horizontal line: Ceiling.FloorCeilingDABC
Common mistake

If the agency buys cheap and sells dear, doesn't the scheme pay for itself?

Only if the band sits around the price the market would average across good and bad years, and nobody knows that price in advance. Set the floor too high and the agency buys in more years than it sells, so stock piles up, storage bills grow and taxpayers cover the loss. Stored food also goes off, and some crops cannot be stored at all. A guaranteed floor also gives farmers a reason to plant more, which adds to the surplus the agency has to buy.

Exam tip

Draw one demand curve, the floor and the ceiling as dashed horizontal lines, and a vertical supply curve for each harvest. Label the quantity bought, Q2 minus Qd, at the floor and the quantity sold at the ceiling. For evaluation, name why schemes fail: a band set in the wrong place, storage costs, stock that perishes and a store that runs empty.

Check yourself

Three of these are reasons buffer stock schemes run into trouble. Which one is not?

Exam question

Using a diagram, explain how a buffer stock scheme stops the price of a crop falling after a good harvest. [4]

What to take away

A buffer stock scheme holds a crop's price inside a band. When a good harvest would push the price below the floor, the agency buys the surplus into store, adding to demand; when a bad harvest would push it above the ceiling, it sells from store, adding to supply. Inside the band it does nothing. Schemes fail when the band is set too high, so stock piles up and taxpayers pay, when stock perishes, and when a run of bad harvests empties the store.