- Trade union
- A trade union is an organisation of workers that negotiates with employers over wages and working conditions.
- Collective bargaining
- Collective bargaining is the negotiation between a union and one or more firms over pay and conditions.
Critics argue a union raises pay by cutting the number of jobs
A union is the sole seller of its members' labour, so it can act like a monopoly: by threatening a strike, it can win a wage above the market equilibrium. At that wage firms hire fewer workers than they otherwise would, often by not replacing leavers rather than by sacking anyone, and more people want union jobs than there are posts. Critics say unions grab as much as they can in the short term, even when it injures workers in the long run.
No unionThe market clears at W0, with Q0 workers employed.
Check yourself
A union wins a wage above the equilibrium in a competitive industry, and productivity does not change. What does the model predict?
Supporters argue higher productivity can pay for the higher wage
Supporters see unions as workers' main defence against firms holding down pay. The higher wage need not cost many jobs if union workers are more productive. Members tend to stay longer in a job, which cuts hiring and training costs and builds experience, and many unions run training and apprenticeships. Where productivity rises with pay, the demand for union labour shifts right and fewer jobs are lost. Firms may also switch to machinery, which makes each worker more productive but means hiring fewer.
Check yourself
Training makes union members more productive, and nothing else changes. Which way does the demand curve for their labour move?
The measured UK pay gap is small, and not all of it is the union's doing
UK government figures put the average gross hourly pay of union members 5.3 per cent above that of non-members in 2025. The premium is positive in the public sector; in the private sector members earn marginally less than non-members. The figure does not allow for other differences between members and non-members, which the government says strongly influence it, and collective agreements are likely to cover non-members in the same bargaining unit too.
What the answer turns on is the power on the other side of the table
Where a union faces a single powerful employer, both sides push employment below the competitive level, and the wage lands somewhere between what the union wants and what the employer wants, closer to whichever has more bargaining power. So whether a union raises pay, and whether it costs jobs at all, depends on how productive its members become and how much power the employer holds.
Weigh the wage gain against the job cost, then name what decides the balance. Where the employer is a monopsony, a union wage set between the monopsony wage and the competitive wage raises pay and employment together, as a minimum wage can. A raw gap of about five per cent between members and non-members is not the effect of a union on pay.
Check yourself
In 2025, UK union members earned about 5 per cent more an hour than non-members. Which conclusion does that figure support?
Exam question
Assess the view that trade unions raise their members' wages at the cost of jobs. [8]
For: acting as a monopoly seller of labour, a union can win a wage above equilibrium, and firms then hire fewer workers, often by not replacing leavers. Against: if union workers are more productive through longer tenure and training, demand for them rises and fewer jobs go; and facing a monopsony, a union wage between the monopsony and competitive wages raises pay and employment together. The UK evidence is modest: members earn about five per cent more than non-members, a raw gap not adjusted for other differences. Judgement: unions can raise wages; whether jobs are lost depends on productivity and on the employer's power, so the claim holds in competitive markets but not where employers have monopsony power.
Levels reward analysis of both sides: the monopoly-union job cost, and the productivity and monopsony cases where jobs need not go. Top-level evaluation weighs evidence and reaches a judgement that follows from it, naming what the answer depends on.
A union acts like a monopoly seller of labour and can win a wage above equilibrium, at the cost of fewer jobs than a competitive market would give. Supporters reply that longer tenure and training can make union workers productive enough to justify the pay, and facing a monopsony a union can raise pay and employment together. The measured UK gap between members and non-members is small and unadjusted.