- Monopsony
- A monopsony is a labour market in which there is only one employer, so workers who want that kind of job must accept its wage.
- Monopoly
- A monopoly is a market with only one seller, which can charge any price it wishes and must lower it to sell more.
The only employer can set the wage and must raise it to hire more
Because a monopsony is the sole employer in its labour market, it can offer any wage it wishes. It still faces the market supply curve of labour, though, so if it wants to hire more workers it must raise the wage it pays.
One more worker costs the firm more than that worker's wage
The marginal cost of labour is the cost to the firm of hiring one more worker. To hire one more, the monopsony must pay the higher wage not only to the new worker but to all the workers it already has. So for every worker after the first, the marginal cost of labour is above the wage, and its curve lies above the supply curve.
Check yourself
A monopsony can hire 10 workers at £10 an hour, or 11 workers at £11 an hour each. What is the marginal cost of the eleventh worker, per hour?
£21
Eleven workers at £11 cost £121 an hour and ten at £10 cost £100, so the eleventh adds £21: their own £11 plus £1 more for each of the other ten.
To hire one more worker, a monopsony must raise the wage it pays all its workers. Compared with a competitive market, will it hire more workers or fewer?
Fewer. Every worker it adds raises the wage bill for all the others too, so the extra cost of one more worker climbs fast and the firm stops hiring early. The low wage follows from hiring fewer.
A monopsony hires fewer workers and pays them less
A profit-maximising monopsony hires up to the point where the marginal revenue product of labour equals the marginal cost of labour. It then pays only the wage the supply curve says is needed to attract that many workers. A competitive market would hire where demand meets supply, so compared with it a monopsony employs fewer workers at a lower wage.
The curvesThe marginal cost of labour, MCL, lies above the supply curve S, because each extra worker raises everyone's wage.
Can you think of an example before you look?
A food-processing plant is the only large employer in a small town. It can hire 200 workers at £11 an hour, or 201 at £11.05. The extra worker gets £11.05, and the other 200 each get 5p more, adding £10: that worker costs £21.05 an hour. If their marginal revenue product is £16, the plant does not hire them, even though they would work for £11.05.
An employer need not be the only one to have monopsony power
Pure monopsony is rare: the classic case is the only mining company in a mining town, or the only hospital in a town employing surgical nurses. Many more employers have some market power over workers who have few other employers nearby, and the outcomes are similar in kind though less extreme.
Check yourself
Which of these employers is most likely to have monopsony power over its workers?
If a monopsony pays less, won't it hire more workers, because labour is cheap?
No. A low wage makes workers cheap to a firm that can hire as many as it likes at that wage, as a competitive employer can. A monopsony cannot: every extra worker raises the wage it pays everyone. So it stops hiring early, and the low wage follows from hiring fewer, since fewer workers can be attracted at lower pay.
On the diagram, draw the marginal cost of labour above the supply curve, find employment where it meets the marginal revenue product, and read the wage down from the supply curve, not from that crossing. For evaluation, add that a minimum wage set between the monopsony wage and the competitive wage can raise pay and employment together.
Check yourself
A town's only large employer is joined by several rival firms hiring the same kind of worker. What happens to the wage and employment?
Check yourself
On this diagram of a monopsony labour market, which point gives the wage the monopsony pays?
A is where the marginal cost of labour meets the marginal revenue product. It fixes how many are hired, but the firm does not pay that high a wage.
Yes. B is on the supply curve below the hiring point: the lowest wage that attracts that many workers, which is all the monopsony needs to pay.
C is where supply meets the marginal revenue product: the competitive outcome, with more workers at a higher wage than the monopsony chooses.
Exam question
Explain why a monopsony employer pays a lower wage and employs fewer workers than a competitive labour market would. [4]
To hire one more worker the monopsony must raise the wage for all its workers, so the marginal cost of labour is above the wage. It hires where marginal revenue product equals this marginal cost, which is fewer workers than where demand meets supply. It then pays only the wage on the supply curve needed to attract that number, which is below the competitive wage.
One mark for the higher wage going to all workers, one for marginal cost above the wage, one for hiring where MRP equals marginal cost, one for reading the lower wage off the supply curve.
A monopsony is a labour market with only one employer. Hiring one more worker means paying more to every worker, so the marginal cost of labour is above the wage. It hires where marginal revenue product equals that marginal cost and pays the wage the supply curve allows: fewer workers at a lower wage than a competitive market.