- X-inefficiency
- X-inefficiency is producing an output at a higher cost per unit than the lowest possible for that output, because a firm lets its costs drift upward.
- Productive efficiency
- Productive efficiency is producing goods at the lowest possible average cost, at the bottom of the average cost curve.
Sources of organisational slack
Can you name three ways a firm lets its costs rise above the lowest possible?
Overstaffing is employing more workers than the output needs, so the wage bill per unit is higher than it has to be.
Can you think of an example?
A depot keeps twelve drivers on the rota for work that ten could cover.
Overpaying for inputs is buying materials, energy or services at more than the lowest price available for the same quality.
Can you think of an example?
A firm renews its energy contract with the same supplier every year without asking any rival supplier for a price.
Weak management effort is managers failing to organise work, control spending or adopt known cheaper methods.
Can you think of an example?
Managers approve prestige offices and first-class travel that add nothing to output.
The average cost curve shows the lowest cost of each output
A firm's average cost curve shows the cost per unit of each level of output when the firm combines its inputs as cheaply as its technology allows. A firm that wastes inputs, or pays more for them than it needs to, produces the same output at a higher cost per unit. Its cost sits above the curve, not on it. The gap between the cost the firm bears and the lowest possible cost of that output is X-inefficiency.
The curveAC shows the lowest possible cost per unit of each output, with inputs combined as cheaply as the firm's technology allows.
Check yourself
A hospital kitchen makes 20,000 meals a week at a total cost of £90,000. With the same equipment and methods, the lowest possible cost of those meals is £70,000. How much X-inefficiency is there per meal, in pounds?
£1
The kitchen's cost per meal is £90,000 ÷ 20,000 = £4.50, and the lowest possible is £70,000 ÷ 20,000 = £3.50. The gap of £1 a meal is cost above the curve for that output.
A firm with no rivals can take a quiet life
A firm facing strong competition has to keep its costs down, or rivals charging less take its customers. Once a barrier to entry is in place, a monopoly that does not need to fear competition can produce the same old products in the same old way and still make a healthy profit. John Hicks wrote in 1935 that the best of all monopoly profits is a quiet life: a monopoly may bank its profits and slack off.
Check yourself
Which of these firms is most likely to have costs above the lowest possible for its output?
Regulation that covers a firm's costs weakens the reason to cut them
When a regulator sets prices by taking a firm's costs and adding a normal rate of profit, the firm has less reason to be concerned with high costs, because it can pass them on in higher prices. It may even gain from large premises or many staff, because what it can charge is linked to what it spends. A price cap set years ahead lets the firm keep any saving it makes, which gives it a reason to cut costs.
Can you think of an organisation with no rivals whose costs could drift above the minimum?
A council has run its own bin collections for twenty years with no rival bidding for the work. It employs sixty crew where fifty would cover the same rounds, and buys lorries without comparing prices. Each bin emptied costs it £1.30, against £1.00 for the cheapest way of doing the same work. The 30p gap is X-inefficiency.
Isn't X-inefficiency just producing away from the bottom of the average cost curve?
No. A firm producing away from the bottom of the curve, but at the lowest cost for that output, is on the curve: productively inefficient, with no X-inefficiency. X-inefficiency is being above the curve, at whatever output the firm chooses. A monopoly can suffer both at once, producing away from the lowest point while slack holds its costs above the curve.
Draw the average cost curve, mark the firm's output and plot its actual cost above the curve at that output; label the gap X-inefficiency. Then give the cause, such as a barrier to entry or cost-plus regulation, and the remedy that restores the pressure: new rivals, a contract put out to tender, or a price cap.
Check yourself
Each point shows one firm's output and its actual cost per unit. Which firm is X-inefficient?
A is on the curve, so the firm has the lowest possible cost for its small output. It is productively inefficient, away from the bottom, but has no slack.
B is at the bottom of the curve, the lowest possible cost of any output. That is productive efficiency, with no slack at all.
Yes. C is above the curve: the firm pays more per unit than the lowest possible cost of its output, which is X-inefficiency.
D is below the curve, a cost lower than the lowest possible for that output. With this technology and these input prices, no firm can produce there.
Exam question
Explain why a monopoly may be X-inefficient. Use an average cost diagram in your answer. [4]
X-inefficiency is producing at a cost per unit above the lowest possible for that output, shown as a point above the average cost curve at the firm's output. A monopoly protected by barriers to entry faces no rivals who could undercut it, so it can let costs drift up through overstaffing, overpaying for inputs or weak management and still make supernormal profit.
One mark for the definition, one for the diagram with actual cost above AC at the firm's output, one for the lack of competitive pressure behind barriers to entry, and one for a source of slack such as overstaffing.
The average cost curve shows the lowest possible cost of each output. X-inefficiency is producing at a cost above that curve, through overstaffing, overpaying for inputs or weak management. A monopoly behind barriers to entry faces no rivals to undercut it, so it can take a quiet life and let costs drift up. Competition and price caps restore the pressure to cut costs.