Before you start
What you'll be able to answer
- How high did unemployment go, and how much did output fall, in the countries hit hardest by the euro crisis?
- Why did the countries hit by the crisis cut spending and raise taxes when their economies were already shrinking?
- What harm did the budget cuts do, and what arguments were made for them?
Where this sits
The Eurozone Crisis — 2009 to 2015 · this module is lit
- 21 Oct 2009Greece revises its 2009 deficit figure sharply upward
- May 2010Euro area governments and the IMF agree Greece's first rescue loan, EU governments agree to create rescue funds, and the ECB starts buying government bonds
- 28 Nov 2010Ireland agrees a rescue programme
- May 2011Portugal agrees a rescue programme
- Dec 2011 and Feb 2012The ECB makes two rounds of three-year loans to banks
- Mar to Apr 2012Private holders of Greek bonds take a cut of more than half in face value
- 20 Jul 2012Euro area ministers approve a loan to rebuild the capital of Spain's banks
- 26 Jul and 6 Sep 2012The ECB's president promises "whatever it takes"; the ECB announces a plan to buy struggling governments' bonds
- Mar to Apr 2013Cyprus takes rescue loans, while uninsured depositors, shareholders and bondholders meet the capital needs of Cyprus Popular Bank and the Bank of Cyprus
- Jun to Jul 2015Greece shuts its banks as savers rush to withdraw money, voters reject the lenders' terms, and euro area leaders agree to move towards a third programme
30 March 2012
On 30 March 2012 Spain's government proposed a budget with 27 billion euros of cuts, the euro area's rescue fund records. In 2011 over a fifth of those wanting work had none. Luis de Guindos, economy minister, spoke about the deficit, the gap between what a government spends and collects: "Europe did not trust Spain after the deficit mushroomed, and wanted to tighten the screws on us to ensure that we reduced it at a faster pace than we could manage." He meant Europe pushed Spain to cut too fast.
In 2011 about one in five people in Spain who wanted a job had none. Where do you expect Spain's unemployment rate was in 2013?
More than one in four. Spain's rate rose in every year from 2007 to 2013.
A shrinking economy makes a government's deficit bigger
Spain's slump, a long period when the economy shrinks, began in 2008, when a long boom in house prices and borrowing ended. Spain had made no budget cuts at that point. Unemployment, the share of people who want a job and cannot find one, was 8.2 per cent in 2007 and began to climb in 2008.
When an economy shrinks, people and firms earn less, so they pay less tax. More people also claim unemployment benefits. So the government's deficit gets bigger even if it changes no policy. These automatic changes are called automatic stabilisers.
Automatic stabilisers also make a slump less severe. When incomes fall, people pay less tax and get more benefits, so they can keep spending more.
In 2009 Spain's deficit was 11.2 per cent of its GDP, Eurostat records. GDP is the value of everything a country produces in a year. Economists also call it output.
Check yourself
A government promises to cut its deficit to a set share of GDP. Then its economy shrinks more than forecast. What must the government now do to meet the target?
Rescue loans and European Union rules set limits on deficits
The US Congressional Research Service (CRS), writing about Greece, explained how lenders can force a government to cut. Lenders who doubted Greece could repay might stop lending, or charge interest it could not afford. Greece would then have to cut quickly or risk failing to repay. Spending cuts and tax rises like these are called austerity.
Greece, Ireland and Portugal borrowed from European rescue funds and governments and from the International Monetary Fund (IMF), which lends to countries in trouble. These loans, called programmes, came with conditions. Greece had to make reforms (changes to how its economy worked) and meet agreed yearly deficit targets, the CRS reported.
The euro area's rescue fund lent Spain money for its banks only. The IMF only gave Spain advice. But European Union (EU) rules required deficits below 3 per cent of GDP. In July 2012 EU governments gave Spain until 2014 to get there.
Jobs and output (GDP) in Spain and Greece
Spain's unemployment rate rose each year to 26.1 per cent in 2013. Of people aged 15 to 24 in Spain who wanted work, 55.5 per cent had none. In 2013 Greece's rate reached 27.8 per cent; Germany's was 4.9 per cent. By 2013 Spain's output was about 8 per cent lower than in 2008. Greece's was more than a quarter lower.
Spain shared the euro with Germany. The European Central Bank (ECB), the euro area's central bank, set one interest rate for both, so Spain could not set its own. Spain also could not lower the value of its currency. A cheaper currency makes exports cheaper for foreign buyers.
Only the budget was left for Spain to steer its economy. In July 2012 Spain raised the main rate of VAT, a tax on sales, to cut its deficit. Unemployment fell from 2014, to 19.6 per cent in 2016.
Source: Eurostat, unemployment rates (lfsa_urgan), Spain. CC BY 4.0.
Check yourself
In 2013 Spain had far more unemployment than Germany, but both had the same interest rate. Why did one rate for the whole euro area suit Spain badly?
Two IMF economists later looked back at the start of the crisis. They judged that forecasters then assumed each euro of budget cuts would reduce output by about 50 cents. Some governments planned bigger cuts for 2010 and 2011. How did their growth turn out compared with the forecasts?
Worse. Output fell further below the forecasts where bigger cuts had been planned, the two economists found.
Output came in lower than forecast where bigger cuts were planned, IMF economists found
A fiscal multiplier measures how much output changes for each euro of budget cuts. Olivier Blanchard and Daniel Leigh, IMF economists, judged that forecasters at the start of the crisis assumed multipliers of about 0.5. So each euro of cuts would reduce output by half a euro.
In October 2012 a section the two wrote for the IMF's World Economic Outlook report concluded that "actual fiscal multipliers were larger than forecasters assumed". In January 2013 they answered critics of that finding.
Where European governments planned bigger cuts for 2010 and 2011, output ended up further below forecast. Each percentage point of GDP of planned cuts went with output about one per cent lower than forecast. So each euro of cuts cost about one euro more output than expected. Real multipliers were about 1 higher than assumed, and well above 1 early in the crisis. Unemployment also rose more than forecast.
Check yourself
Work from the definition above. A government cuts spending by 10 billion euros. If the multiplier is 1.5, by how many billion euros does output fall?
15 billion euros
15 billion euros. A multiplier of 1.5 means each euro of cuts removes 1.5 euros of output, and 1.5 times 10 is 15. A forecaster who assumed 0.5 would have expected a fall of 5 billion.
IMF economists gave reasons why the cuts hurt output so much
Blanchard and Leigh gave reasons why multipliers could be larger in this slump. Central banks usually cut interest rates to boost spending. Rates were near zero, so central banks could not cut further to make up for the budget cuts. With banks in trouble, households and firms may have had to spend only what they earned. So they cut spending as soon as income fell.
The IMF's evaluators, its Independent Evaluation Office, added that euro countries could not cut their interest rates or lower their currency's value.
The evaluators found the growth forecasts too hopeful for Greece and Portugal, though not for Ireland. When Greece's and Portugal's output shrank more than expected, the deficit targets were kept, so governments cut further. In the evaluators' view, keeping the targets stopped the automatic stabilisers working and made the slump worse. Ireland's programme was flexible from the start and let the stabilisers work.
The case for cutting
In May 2010 the ECB's Governing Council, its main decision-making body, said that the longer governments put off fixing their budgets, the bigger the fix needed. The risk of losing confidence would also grow. Quick cuts, mainly to spending and combined with reforms, would make people trust that governments could put their finances right, the ECB said.
Lenders would then charge governments less extra interest. Lower interest costs would support growth over the medium term. The ECB's president, Jean-Claude Trichet, added that recovery and growth needed households and firms to feel confident.
The German government agreed. The CRS described its view in 2013 using two technical terms. Fiscal consolidation means cutting the budget deficit. Convergence means euro economies becoming more alike. In the German view, the CRS wrote, "economic growth and economic convergence will not come without significant fiscal consolidation and economic reform".
Two questions: what the cuts cost, and whether they were needed
One question is whether the cuts made the slumps worse in the short run. Blanchard and Leigh measured this. The other question is whether cuts were needed to win back lenders' trust and to give lasting growth. The ECB and the German government argued that they were.
Blanchard and Leigh wrote that the multiplier is not the same in every country or every period. They added that confidence may sometimes cancel out part of the harm from cuts. Lenders who trust a government lend to it more cheaply. They said their results did not prove that cutting deficits was a mistake. Almost all advanced economies had high debts to bring down.
The CRS reported that critics said the focus on cuts had hurt growth. The leaders of Spain, Italy and France called for more European action on growth. In January 2015 Greeks elected a government opposed to the budget cuts.
Check yourself
In May 2010 the ECB argued that quick budget cuts would support growth over the medium term. How, according to the ECB, would they do that?
Check yourself
Three of these are reasons the IMF's economists or evaluators gave for why budget cuts cost more output in this slump. Which one is not a reason they gave?
Check yourself
The key questions
How high did unemployment go, and how much did output fall, in the countries hit hardest by the euro crisis?
In 2013 more than one in four people who wanted work had none, in both Spain and Greece. In Spain, more than half of young people who wanted work had none. Greece's output was more than a quarter below its 2008 level. Spain's output was about 8 per cent below its 2008 level.
Why did the countries hit by the crisis cut spending and raise taxes when their economies were already shrinking?
The slumps made the countries' deficits bigger. Lenders who doubted a country could repay either stopped lending or charged more. Greece had to meet budget targets to receive its rescue loans, and Spain had to meet EU deficit rules by 2014.
What harm did the budget cuts do, and what arguments were made for them?
Two IMF economists, Blanchard and Leigh, found that output fell further below forecasts where bigger cuts were planned. They first reported this in an IMF report in October 2012. The IMF's evaluators judged that keeping Greece's and Portugal's deficit targets deepened their slumps. The ECB argued that cuts were needed to win back confidence. The German government argued that growth would not come without cuts and reform. Blanchard and Leigh said their results did not prove that cutting deficits was a mistake.
The numbers
Check yourself
By 2013 unemployment was above a quarter in both Spain and Greece. How did the fall in output since 2008 compare?
Check yourself
What pressed Spain's government to cut its budget in 2012?
Check yourself
What did the two IMF economists find about the budget cuts planned for 2010 and 2011?