Before you start
What you'll be able to answer
- Why was Greece in crisis again in 2015?
- Why did Greece shut its banks, and how close did it come to leaving the euro?
- How did Greece settle its dispute with the countries and institutions that lent it money in 2015, and on what terms?
Where this sits
The Eurozone Crisis — 2009 to 2015 · this module is lit
- 21 Oct 2009Greece revises its 2009 deficit figure sharply upward
- May 2010Euro area governments and the IMF agree Greece's first rescue loan, EU governments agree to create rescue funds, and the ECB starts buying government bonds
- 28 Nov 2010Ireland agrees a rescue programme
- May 2011Portugal agrees a rescue programme
- Dec 2011 and Feb 2012The ECB makes two rounds of three-year loans to banks
- Mar to Apr 2012Private holders of Greek bonds take a cut of more than half in face value
- 20 Jul 2012Euro area ministers approve a loan to rebuild the capital of Spain's banks
- 26 Jul and 6 Sep 2012The ECB's president promises "whatever it takes"; the ECB announces a plan to buy struggling governments' bonds
- Mar to Apr 2013Cyprus takes rescue loans, while uninsured depositors, shareholders and bondholders meet the capital needs of Cyprus Popular Bank and the Bank of Cyprus
- Jun to Jul 2015Greece shuts its banks as savers rush to withdraw money, voters reject the lenders' terms, and euro area leaders agree to move towards a third programme
27 June 2015
Late on Friday 26 June 2015, Greece's negotiators walked out of talks with Greece's lenders. The lenders were the other governments of the euro area (the countries that share the euro) and the International Monetary Fund (IMF), which lends to countries in trouble. Early the next morning the prime minister, Alexis Tsipras, announced a referendum, a public vote on one question. Voters would decide whether to accept the lenders' conditions for more money. Greece's second rescue programme, a loan with conditions, was due to end in four days.
Many Greeks kept their savings in Greek banks. What do you think many of them did as talk grew that Greece might leave the euro?
Many took their money out. The US Congressional Research Service (CRS) says fear that Greece could leave the euro sped up a bank run. In a bank run, many savers rush to take their money out at once.
Syriza won the January 2015 election
Greece had relied on rescue loans since 2010. In return, its governments had cut spending, wages and pensions. The CRS says anger at these cuts put a party called Syriza in power in January 2015. The CRS calls its government far-left and anti-austerity, meaning against the cuts. Its leader, Tsipras, promised to undo the cuts. He also promised debt relief, a cut in what Greece owed, and to keep Greece in the euro.
Tsipras became prime minister in late January, when Greece's second programme had about a month left. Three lenders, called the troika, oversaw it. They were the European Commission (the EU's executive), the European Central Bank (ECB) and the IMF. The European Stability Mechanism (ESM), the euro area's rescue fund, says Syriza had campaigned to get rid of the troika. In February euro area finance ministers extended the programme by four months, to the end of June.
The ECB tightened the rules for Greek banks
Banks borrow from the ECB, the central bank for the euro area. To borrow, a bank pledges collateral. Collateral is assets the lender can keep if a loan is not repaid. Greek government bonds are IOUs the government sells. Their credit grade was below the minimum the ECB normally accepts. An exception, called a waiver, let banks pledge them anyway. On 4 February 2015 the ECB ended the waiver. It said it could not assume the programme's review, the lenders' regular check on Greece's progress, would succeed.
When savers take money out, a bank must pay them and make up the loss, often by borrowing. From 11 February, Greek banks with no other collateral had to use emergency liquidity assistance. These were loans from the Bank of Greece, Greece's central bank. The ECB set a limit on how much banks could borrow this way.
Check yourself
In the spring of 2015 Greek savers took money out of their banks. Why did these withdrawals give the ECB more and more power over the banks?
Talks with the lenders stalled
Greece's new finance minister was Yanis Varoufakis. The ESM's history says that at his first meeting with the other euro area finance ministers, he spoke against budget cuts. He backed a higher minimum wage. He was also wary of selling things the state owned. The CRS says the main disagreements were over taxes, pensions, debt relief and the budget targets Greece had to meet.
Each side blamed the other. Jeroen Dijsselbloem, who chaired the euro area finance ministers, said Greece's government had decided to stop keeping its agreements after the election. Euclid Tsakalotos, one of Tsipras's negotiators, said the government could not ignore voters who had chosen a change of direction. Greece's government was running short of cash. In May it repaid the IMF 750 million euros from reserves it kept in an IMF account. In June it said it would delay another repayment.
Greece's ten-year borrowing cost is the yearly interest investors earned on its ten-year bonds. It was 5.89 per cent in September 2014. Where do you expect it was in April 2015?
About 12 per cent. It was 12.00 per cent in April 2015, more than double its level of September 2014.
Lenders grew more worried
The chart shows Greece's ten-year borrowing cost each month, from Eurostat, the EU's statistics office. It was 5.89 per cent in September 2014 and 12.00 per cent in April 2015. A higher rate means investors want more reward for the risk of not being repaid in full. Rating agencies are firms that grade how likely borrowers are to repay. The ESM's history says that from the end of March 2015, three agencies (Fitch, Standard & Poor's and Moody's) all gave Greece a lower grade.
Source: Eurostat, ten-year government bond yields (EMU convergence criterion series, irt_lt_mcby_m), Greece. CC BY 4.0.
Check yourself
Look at the chart. When did Greece's borrowing cost start to rise?
The banks shut
Talk that Greece might abandon the euro led savers and investors to move their money elsewhere, the ESM's history says. The CRS says this fear sped up a bank run, a rush by savers to withdraw. Yannis Stournaras, the Bank of Greece's governor, said about 45 billion euros of savings left during Varoufakis's six months as finance minister.
On 28 June, citing the referendum and the end of the programme, the ECB did not raise its limit on emergency loans to Greek banks. The limit stayed where it had been two days before. The banks could not borrow more as savers withdrew. That day the government said the banks would shut from the next morning and cash withdrawals would be limited. These limits on moving money are called capital controls. On 30 June the programme ended, and Greece missed a 1.5 billion euro payment due to the IMF.
Check yourself
Most voters rejected the lenders' terms on 5 July. Why might Greece's government still have needed a deal with the lenders soon afterwards?
After the referendum
On 5 July more than 60 per cent of voters rejected the lenders' terms, the CRS says. Five days later Germany proposed that Greece leave the euro, at least for a time, if it did not accept tougher reforms, the ESM's history says. Euro area leaders considered this proposal, the CRS says. On 12 July they chose to keep Greece in the euro and work towards a third programme, another loan on tough terms. They said a quick decision was a condition for reopening the banks.
Before that programme could start, Greece had to pass laws on taxes, pensions and its statistics office. It also had to put valuable state assets into a fund that would sell them. The leaders said Greece's debt could not be cut in face value, the amount to be repaid. Tsipras said accepting the terms was less bad than leaving the euro, the CRS says.
The third programme
Greece got a bridge loan, a short-term loan until the main loans arrived, of 7 billion euros. It came from the EFSM, an EU fund separate from the ESM. With it, Greece paid the ECB and paid its arrears, meaning overdue payments, to the IMF. The banks reopened on 20 July after three weeks, but capital controls stayed and were eased only slowly.
On 14 August euro area finance ministers agreed the programme: ESM loans of up to 86 billion euros, including up to 25 billion euros for the banks. Greece agreed to reform pensions, collect more tax and sell state assets. It also agreed to take in more than it spent, before counting interest payments. The IMF had lent to Greece in 2010 and 2012. The CRS says it did not join, citing doubts about Greece's debts and reforms. Tsipras won another election in September.
Check yourself
Three of these were part of the third programme agreed in 2015. Which one was not?
Check yourself
The key questions
Why was Greece in crisis again in 2015?
Voters tired of years of cuts elected Syriza in January, with the second programme nearly over. Talks with the lenders stalled over taxes, pensions, budget targets and debt relief. The ECB stopped accepting Greek bonds as normal collateral. Savers took money out of the banks, and the government ran short of cash.
Why did Greece shut its banks, and how close did it come to leaving the euro?
Fear that Greece would leave the euro drove savers to withdraw, and the banks had to replace their deposits with emergency loans. After the referendum was called, the ECB did not raise the limit on those loans. The CRS says fears of an exit sped up a run on the banks, and the government then closed them. Leaders weighed letting Greece leave, and a proposal from Germany circulated, but they chose to keep it in.
How did Greece settle its dispute with the countries and institutions that lent it money in 2015, and on what terms?
Euro area leaders agreed in July to move towards a third programme, and in August finance ministers agreed loans from the ESM. Greece had to pass laws first, reform pensions, collect more tax and sell state assets. Its debt was not cut in face value, and the IMF did not join.
The numbers
Check yourself
Which of these helped bring Greece's crisis back in 2015?
Check yourself
How close did Greece come to leaving the euro in July 2015?
Check yourself
Who lent Greece the main loans in its third programme?