Learn › Economic history › The Collapse of Silicon Valley Bank

The Collapse of Silicon Valley Bank

Why Silicon Valley Bank Failed

Explain why Silicon Valley Bank was exposed to a run, what the official reviews blamed, and what followed its failure.

Before you start

What you'll be able to answer

  1. Why was Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) weak when depositors rushed to withdraw?
  2. Why did depositors withdraw so fast, and what did the official reviews say caused the failure?
  3. What happened after SVB failed?

Where this sits

The Collapse of Silicon Valley Bank ยท this module is lit

  1. 16 Mar 2022The Federal Reserve, the US central bank, announces a rise of a quarter of a percentage point in its target range, the band it sets for the rate banks charge each other for overnight loans
  2. 8 Mar 2023Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) announces that it has sold some of its bonds and plans to raise money by selling new shares
  3. 10 Mar 2023California's banking regulator closes SVB and appoints the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), the US deposit insurer, to run what is left
  4. 12 Mar 2023The US Treasury, the Federal Reserve and the FDIC announce emergency measures; Signature Bank in New York is closed
  5. 13 Mar 2023SVB's British bank is sold to HSBC
  6. 26 Mar 2023First Citizens Bank agrees to take over SVB's deposits and loans from the FDIC
  7. 28 Apr 2023The Federal Reserve publishes its review of its supervision of SVB
  8. 1 May 2023First Republic Bank in San Francisco is closed and sold to JPMorgan Chase
  9. 11 Mar 2024The Federal Reserve's emergency lending programme for banks, opened in March 2023, stops making new loans

SVB put much of its deposits into long-term bonds

At the end of 2022, 55 per cent of SVB's assets were securities, meaning bonds and similar investments, and 35 per cent were loans. At other US banks with over $100 billion of assets, leaving out the very largest, securities were 25 per cent and loans 58 per cent, the Federal Reserve (the Fed), the US central bank, found.

Most of SVB's bonds were held to maturity: kept until repaid. Most of these were long-dated: home-loan bonds backed by US government agencies, due in 10 years or more.

Most of SVB's deposits were above the $250,000 insurance limit

Deposit insurance from the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) covers up to $250,000 per depositor at each bank. If a bank fails, the FDIC repays each depositor up to that limit. At the end of 2022, about 94 per cent of SVB's deposits were above the limit, against 41 per cent at similar large banks, the Fed found.

Many deposits came from start-ups with no sales income yet, Michael Barr, the Fed's Vice Chair for Supervision, told the Senate. They kept large cash balances to pay staff and bills. Many of these start-ups were linked through the same venture capital firms, investors who buy shares in new businesses.

In 2022, as interest rates rose and technology firms did less business, customers began taking deposits out of SVB. From July 2022 the bank repeatedly failed its own liquidity stress tests, checks of whether it could raise enough cash under strain.

Take a guess

SVB's long-dated bonds paid a fixed rate of interest. When interest rates rose in 2022, new bonds paid more than SVB's older ones, so buyers would pay less for SVB's bonds and their market price fell. A bank's capital is the money its shareholders have put in, and losses use it up first. How much of the fall in price of the bonds SVB held to maturity did it have to record as a loss that reduced its capital?

US interest rates rose fast from March 2022

Central banks raised interest rates in 2022 to curb high inflation, notes the Basel Committee, the international committee of bank supervisors. The Fed raises interest rates by raising its target range for the rate banks charge each other on overnight loans. The chart shows the top of that range. The top was 0.25 per cent until 16 March 2022 and 4.75 per cent from 2 February 2023.

SVB's accounts showed its held-to-maturity bonds at the price it had paid. A fall in their market price showed only as an unrealised loss: a loss on paper, which becomes real if the bonds are sold. At the end of 2022 these losses were over $15 billion, 89 per cent of the bank's core capital, found a preliminary review by the Government Accountability Office (GAO), Congress's audit office.

The top of the US central bank's target range for interest rates, 2021 to March 2023Per cent, daily
012345202120222023SVB closed

Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Federal Funds Target Range, Upper Limit (FRED DFEDTARU). Public domain, citation requested.