California closed Silicon Valley Bank on 10 March 2023
On Friday 10 March 2023 California's banking regulator closed Silicon Valley Bank (SVB), based in Santa Clara. The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) insures US bank deposits. It said SVB held about $209 billion of assets at the end of 2022. Assets are the loans and investments a bank owns. Most of SVB's customers were technology and life-sciences companies, or the venture capital firms that invest in them. Two days before it closed, the bank had announced a plan to raise new money from investors.
Before you start
What you'll be able to answer
- What kind of bank was Silicon Valley Bank, and why did its deposits make it fragile?
- How did the run on SVB happen?
- How did the authorities respond, and what happened to the bank?
On Thursday 9 March depositors took money out of SVB, and its managers expected more to go on Friday. What share of the bank's deposits do you think was set to leave over those two days?
Roughly 85 per cent, counting the money withdrawn on 9 March and the outflows expected on 10 March, according to the Federal Reserve (the Fed), the US central bank. The sections below show how it came to that.
Where this sits
The Collapse of Silicon Valley Bank · this module is lit
- 16 Mar 2022The Federal Reserve, the US central bank, announces a rise of a quarter of a percentage point in its target range, the band it sets for the rate banks charge each other for overnight loans
- 8 Mar 2023Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) announces that it has sold some of its bonds and plans to raise money by selling new shares
- 10 Mar 2023California's banking regulator closes SVB and appoints the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), the US deposit insurer, to run what is left
- 12 Mar 2023The US Treasury, the Federal Reserve and the FDIC announce emergency measures; Signature Bank in New York is closed
- 13 Mar 2023SVB's British bank is sold to HSBC
- 26 Mar 2023First Citizens Bank agrees to take over SVB's deposits and loans from the FDIC
- 28 Apr 2023The Federal Reserve publishes its review of its supervision of SVB
- 1 May 2023First Republic Bank in San Francisco is closed and sold to JPMorgan Chase
- 11 Mar 2024The Federal Reserve's emergency lending programme for banks, opened in March 2023, stops making new loans
SVB grew fast as a bank for technology firms
SVB lent to, and held deposits for, young technology and life-sciences firms. Many of these firms had money from venture capital: investors who buy stakes in new businesses. From 2019 to 2021 venture capital investment grew fast and interest rates were very low. Over those years SVB's assets grew from $71 billion to over $211 billion, according to the Fed. The Fed was also the main US government body that oversaw SVB.
In the US, deposit insurance from the FDIC guarantees deposits up to $250,000 per depositor at each bank. Money above that limit is uninsured. If the bank fails, a depositor may lose some of the uninsured money. Most of SVB's deposits, the Fed found, were uninsured.
Check yourself
Work from the two figures above: SVB's assets were $71 billion in 2019 and over $211 billion in 2021. Roughly how many times bigger was the bank in 2021?
3 times
About three times: 211 divided by 71 is about 2.97. The Fed's review says the bank tripled in size.
On 8 March SVB announced a loss and a plan to raise new money
SVB had put much of its depositors' money into securities. These were bonds that pay a fixed return. When interest rates rise, newly issued bonds pay more. Older bonds then sell for less, because buyers can get a better return from the new ones.
On Wednesday 8 March 2023 SVB said it had sold $21 billion of its securities. It sold them for less than they had cost, and the loss came to $1.8 billion after tax. SVB also planned to raise $2.25 billion of new capital. Capital is money from shareholders that a bank can use to cover its losses.
SVB told investors to expect slower growth, because business among its technology customers was still slowing. Credit rating agencies are firms that grade how safe it is to lend to a company. SVB said two of them were considering cutting its rating.
Large depositors heard that the bank had made a loss and needed new capital. What do you think many of them did next?
Many moved their money out, and fast. Most of their balances were above the insurance limit, so a failure could cost them money. The next section says how much.
Depositors pulled their money out on 9 March
On 9 March depositors withdrew over $40 billion. Over $100 billion more was expected on Friday. Together that was roughly 85 per cent of deposits. This was a bank run: depositors rushing out at once.
The Fed's review names three causes. Depositors doubted the technology sector. SVB's rating might be cut. And venture capital investors and technology firms, a close network, withdrew together, spurred by social media.
Michael Barr, the Fed's Vice Chair for Supervision, told the Senate that SVB lacked the cash, or assets to borrow against, to pay that fast.
Once SVB closed, the FDIC became its receiver, the body that sells a failed bank's assets. Insured deposits moved to a new FDIC bank by Monday. Depositors were promised part of their uninsured money within a week. For the part still unpaid they would get a certificate promising further payments as SVB's assets were sold.
Check yourself
Under the FDIC's plan of 10 March, which of these SVB customers would have been cut off from most of their money for a time?
The US authorities acted on Sunday 12 March
Barr told the Senate that the failure could spread to other banks, some already showing signs of trouble. New York state regulators closed Signature Bank, which had also suffered a run, on Sunday 12 March. That day the Treasury Secretary, Janet Yellen, approved an emergency power, the systemic risk exception. It let the FDIC guarantee every deposit at both banks. Customers could reach all their money the next day.
Shareholders were not protected from losses. Nor were certain unsecured debtholders: lenders to SVB who held none of its assets as security. Senior managers were removed. The company that owned SVB filed for bankruptcy on 17 March.
The FDIC pays insured depositors from its Deposit Insurance Fund. Guaranteeing uninsured deposits could cost that fund money. Banks would pay a special charge to cover any such loss, said the Treasury, the Fed and the FDIC. Taxpayers would bear none of it.
The Fed opened a lending programme, and banks borrowed heavily
That weekend the Fed opened the Bank Term Funding Program (BTFP). Banks could borrow from it for up to one year, pledging US government bonds and similar securities as security. Each bond was valued at par, the amount due when it is repaid. Its market price that day was ignored. The Treasury set aside $25 billion from its Exchange Stabilization Fund to cover any BTFP losses.
Banks could also borrow from the Fed's regular lending service, the discount window, against collateral: assets pledged as security. From that Sunday the discount window used the BTFP's rules for how much a bank could borrow against each bond, so banks could borrow more there.
The chart shows primary credit, the discount window's standard loan, each Wednesday in early 2023. BTFP loans are not included. Primary credit stood at about $4.6 billion on 8 March and about $152.9 billion a week later.
Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, H.4.1, Loans: Primary Credit, Wednesday level (FRED WLCFLPCL). Public domain, citation requested.
Check yourself
A bank's bonds had fallen in price, so their market price was below par. The BTFP counted them at par, the amount due when they are repaid. How did that help the bank?
Check yourself
Look at the chart. After mid-March, how long did primary credit stay above $50 billion?
SVB's British bank and its US business were sold
SVB also owned a British bank, Silicon Valley Bank UK, with deposits of about £6.7 billion. On Monday 13 March the Bank of England sold it to HSBC, using its powers under the Banking Act 2009. The Financial Stability Board, an international body of financial regulators, says HSBC paid £1. The UK government said no taxpayer money was involved.
In the US the FDIC ran SVB as a bridge bank, a temporary bank it controls until a buyer is found. On 26 March First Citizens Bank agreed to take on all its deposits and loans. That day the FDIC estimated that the failure would cost its Deposit Insurance Fund about $20 billion.
SVB had tripled in size from 2019 to 2021 and failed two days after its announcement. Why was it so exposed to a run, and what changed after it failed? The next module answers these questions.
Check yourself
The key questions
What kind of bank was Silicon Valley Bank, and why did its deposits make it fragile?
A bank for technology firms and their venture capital investors that tripled in size from 2019 to 2021. Most of its deposits were above the limit that deposit insurance covers, so its depositors stood to lose money if it failed and had reason to leave at the first doubt.
How did the run on SVB happen?
On 8 March 2023 SVB announced a loss on selling securities and a plan to raise capital. The next day depositors took out tens of billions of dollars, and more was set to follow. The Fed's review names three causes that seem to have set off the run. Depositors worried about the technology sector. SVB's rating might be cut. And a close network of depositors pulled out together. The bank did not have the cash to pay, and California's regulator closed it on 10 March.
How did the authorities respond, and what happened to the bank?
On 12 March the US authorities used an emergency power to guarantee every deposit at SVB and Signature Bank. Any loss to the fund from protecting uninsured depositors was to be recovered from banks. The Fed also opened an emergency lending programme. SVB's British bank was sold to HSBC on 13 March, and First Citizens took on SVB's deposits and loans on 26 March.
The numbers
Check yourself
Most of SVB's deposits came from technology firms and their investors, in balances above the insurance limit. Why did that leave the bank fragile?
Check yourself
Which account of 8 to 10 March fits what happened?
Check yourself
Which of these sums up what the US authorities decided on 12 March?