A question from the Federal Reserve in December 1996
On 5 December 1996 Alan Greenspan, chairman of the Federal Reserve, the US central bank, asked in a speech: "how do we know when irrational exuberance has unduly escalated asset values"? He meant: when has excitement pushed prices too high? Over the next few years American share prices, led by technology firms, rose far above what companies earned, then fell: the dot-com bubble. In November 2025 US share prices were again high compared with their history, and the chance of large falls had risen.
Before you start
What you'll be able to answer
- How much did share prices rise in the late 1990s, and how did companies raise money while they rose?
- When did share prices fall, and how far?
- What did the Federal Reserve (the US central bank) do, and what happened to the US economy?
The S&P 500 is an index, a single number that tracks the share prices of 500 large US companies. Over the five years to March 2000, roughly how much did it rise?
It tripled. The next section sets that against what the companies were earning.
Where this sits
The Dot-com Bubble ยท this module is lit
- 5 Dec 1996Alan Greenspan, chairman of the Federal Reserve, the US central bank, asks how anyone could know when "irrational exuberance" has pushed asset prices, the prices of things such as shares, too high
- 30 Jun 1999The Federal Reserve starts raising its target for the federal funds rate, the interest rate banks charge each other for overnight loans
- 22 Jul 1999Greenspan tells a committee of Congress that share prices could be driven to levels that cannot be supported
- Mar 2000Technology shares reach their monthly peak
- 16 May 2000The Federal Reserve makes the last of its six rate rises
- 3 Jan 2001The Federal Reserve changes its target rate for the first time since May 2000
- Mar 2001A recession, a broad fall in economic activity, begins, as the National Bureau of Economic Research, which dates US recessions, later finds
- Nov 2001The recession ends, on the same body's dating
- 28 Apr 2003Ten investment firms settle charges that their banking business, helping companies sell shares, swayed their analysts' research, the advice they publish on which shares to buy
American share prices tripled in the five years to March 2000
The Bank for International Settlements (BIS), a body whose members are central banks, counted a threefold rise in the S&P 500 in the five years to March 2000.
The chart shows the total value of all shares in US non-financial companies, from the Federal Reserve's records. Non-financial companies are all firms other than banks, insurers and other financial firms. The total was about $6.4 trillion at the end of 1995 and about $16.3 trillion at the end of March 2000.
A price/earnings ratio is a share's price divided by the company's profit per share over the past year. Profit is also called earnings. At the March 2000 peak, the BIS found, US shares cost on average 33 times their past year's earnings. The BIS called this unprecedented.
Share markets abroad rose too. The BIS found that the Stockholm share market rose nearly fivefold over the same five years.
Source: Federal Reserve Board, Financial Accounts of the United States (Z.1), via FRED (NCBCEL). Public domain.
Check yourself
At the March 2000 peak, on the BIS's figures, US shares cost on average 33 times a year's earnings per share. Suppose earnings then stay the same while share prices halve. What happens to that price/earnings ratio?
An initial public offering (IPO) is when a company first sells its shares to the public, at a price set beforehand. In 1999, how far above that price did IPO shares close on their first day of trading, on average?
About 70 per cent. The next section gives the exact figure and who counted it.
First-time share sales raised $319 billion from 1993 to late 2000
Companies sold shares in IPOs to raise money. The Council of Economic Advisers (CEA), the President's economists, counted $319 billion raised this way between 1993 and the end of November 2000. That was over twice the IPO total for the 20 years before, even after allowing for inflation. Some of the largest IPOs were by established firms. IPOs also raised important money for new firms, especially in information technology and biotechnology.
The first-day return is how far a share closed above the offer price on its first day. In 1999 the average was 69 per cent. The CEA said this was three times higher than in any other year from 1975 to 1999.
The CEA gave two possible reasons. Investors may have been carried away (irrational exuberance). Or underwriters, the banks that set the offer price and sold the shares, may have set it too low. Or both.
Check yourself
Work from the 1999 average first-day return above. A company sold its shares in a 1999 IPO at $20 each. If its first day matched the average, at roughly what price did they close?
$34
About $34. 69 per cent of $20 is $13.80. Adding that to $20 gives a closing price near $33.80.
The Federal Reserve raised its interest rate six times
The Federal Reserve has a committee that sets interest rates, the Federal Open Market Committee. It sets a target for the federal funds rate. That is the interest rate banks charge each other on loans that last one night. On 30 June 1999 the committee raised the target from 4.75 to 5 per cent. Five more rises followed. The last, on 16 May 2000, took it to 6.5 per cent.
In May 2000 the committee explained why it was raising the rate. Demand, meaning what households and firms wanted to buy, was growing. The economy's ability to produce goods and services was growing fast too. Demand was still growing faster. The committee said that if demand kept outgrowing what the economy could produce, prices could rise. A general rise in prices is inflation. Its statement did not mention share prices.
The Nasdaq Composite is an index of more than 4,000 shares. The CEA used it to measure technology share prices. From its monthly peak in March 2000 to October 2001, how much of its value did it lose?
About two-thirds. The next section compares that with another index of US shares.
Technology shares peaked in March 2000
Internet companies had risen fastest of all. The CEA tracked them with a Wilshire index of internet businesses. Their total market value rose from $145 billion in December 1997 to $1.6 trillion in December 1999. Over those two years the whole stock market rose in value. Internet companies accounted for about 23 per cent of that increase.
Technology share prices reached their monthly peak in March 2000 and then fell. By the CEA's figures, the Nasdaq Composite fell 67 per cent from that peak to its lowest month, October 2001. That took it back to where it had been in early 1998. Over the same months the Wilshire 5000, another index of US shares, fell 32 per cent.
Share markets in other countries also rose and fell. The BIS found that the markets that had risen most tended to fall furthest. Technology shares rose and fell most sharply.
Check yourself
Work from the Nasdaq figure above. Someone held $10,000 of shares that moved exactly with the Nasdaq Composite from its March 2000 monthly peak. Roughly what were they worth in October 2001?
$3300
About $3,300: a 67 per cent fall leaves 33 per cent of the starting value, and 33 per cent of $10,000 is $3,300.
A recession began in March 2001
A recession is a broad fall in economic activity, across many industries, that lasts more than a few months. In the United States its dates are set by the Business Cycle Dating Committee of the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER), a research organisation. In November 2001 the committee found that a recession had begun in March 2001. The recession ended an expansion, a period of growth, that had started in March 1991. The expansion had lasted exactly ten years. The NBER called this expansion "the longest in the NBER's chronology", meaning its record of past periods of growth and recession.
Industrial production, a measure of the output of factories and other industry, had peaked late in 2000. Employment across the whole economy kept growing until March 2001. In July 2003 the committee dated the end of the recession to November 2001, eight months after it began.
Check yourself
Industrial production peaked late in 2000, but employment across the whole economy went on growing until March 2001. What does the gap between the two suggest?
The CEA counted what all shareholders lost
Share prices went on falling well after the recession ended. On the chart, the value of non-financial companies' shares reached its low, about $8.7 trillion, at the end of September 2002. That was a little over half its March 2000 peak.
The CEA also counted the total loss to everyone holding US shares. It found that from the first quarter of 2000 to the fourth quarter of 2002, shareholders lost nearly $7 trillion. The CEA used a different measure from the chart, so the two sets of figures do not match.
Why had prices risen so far, and what followed when they fell? The next module takes it up.
Check yourself
The key questions
How much did share prices rise in the late 1990s, and how did companies raise money while they rose?
The S&P 500 tripled in the five years to March 2000. At the peak, US share prices were higher compared with earnings than ever before, the BIS found. Many companies, including new firms, raised money by selling shares to the public in IPOs. On their first day of trading, those shares often closed far above the offer price.
When did share prices fall, and how far?
Technology shares peaked in March 2000; by October 2001 the Nasdaq Composite had lost two-thirds of its value, against about a third for the Wilshire 5000. The fall spread across the market and ran on until late 2002.
What did the Federal Reserve (the US central bank) do, and what happened to the US economy?
It raised its target interest rate six times, to 6.5 per cent in May 2000, citing the risk of inflation. A recession began in March 2001 and ended a ten-year expansion. By the NBER's dating, the recession lasted until November 2001.
The numbers
Check yourself
Two figures from the boom. At the March 2000 peak, US shares cost on average 33 times a year's earnings, on the BIS's figures. In 1999, new shares closed their first day 69 per cent above the offer price on average, on the CEA's figures. What do the two figures suggest about the prices buyers were paying?
Check yourself
From March 2000, one investor held only technology shares. Another held shares that moved with the Wilshire 5000, another index of US shares. Which describes what happened to them?
Check yourself
Someone says the Federal Reserve raised its rate in 1999 and 2000 because the economy was already shrinking. Which answer fits this module?