- Wage elasticity of labour demand
- The wage elasticity of labour demand is the percentage change in the quantity of labour demanded divided by the percentage change in the wage.
- Wage elasticity of labour supply
- The wage elasticity of labour supply is the percentage change in the quantity of labour supplied divided by the percentage change in the wage.
What makes labour demand elastic
Can you name four things that set the wage elasticity of labour demand?
Each makes employers cut hiring by more when the wage rises.
The easier it is to replace workers with machines or other inputs, the more elastic the demand for labour.
Can you think of an example?
Supermarkets can swap cashiers for self-service tills, so a rise in cashiers' pay cuts jobs sharply.
Labour demand is derived demand, so the more elastic the demand for the product, the more elastic the demand for the workers who make it.
Can you think of an example?
A pay rise at one of many takeaways raises its prices, customers go elsewhere, and it needs fewer staff.
The larger the share of costs that goes on wages, the more a pay rise raises costs and prices, and the more elastic labour demand.
Can you think of an example?
Wages are most of a cleaning firm's costs but a small share of an oil refinery's.
Labour demand is more elastic in the long run, because firms need time to buy machines and change how they work.
Can you think of an example?
After a pay rise a warehouse keeps its staff at first, then installs automated picking and hires fewer.
Elastic labour demand turns a pay rise into a large fall in jobs
A rise in the wage from W1 to W2 moves employment along each demand curve. On the elastic curve DE, employment falls by a larger percentage than the wage rose, from L1 to L3. On the inelastic curve DI it falls by a smaller percentage, from L1 to L2. So a minimum wage or a union pay deal costs fewer jobs where labour demand is inelastic.
Check yourself
All three curves are the demand for labour at a firm, drawn through the same wage W1 and employment L1. Which fits a firm that can easily replace its workers with machines?
Yes. A is the flattest through the shared point, so a small rise in the wage brings a large fall in the workers hired, as the firm switches to machines.
B is steep through the shared point, so employment barely responds to the wage. That fits a firm that has no easy substitute for its workers.
C is vertical: employment stays at L1 whatever the wage. That is perfectly inelastic demand, the opposite of a firm that can swap workers for machines.
Labour supply is more elastic where people can move into the job easily
The wage elasticity of labour supply for teenage workers is generally fairly elastic: a given percentage change in wages leads to a larger percentage change in hours worked. For adults in their thirties and forties it is fairly inelastic.
Supply to one occupation is also more elastic where the job needs little training, where workers can move easily between jobs and places, where many are unemployed or doing other work that uses the same skills, and over a longer period, as more people train. The supply of surgeons is inelastic in the short run: training one takes many years.
Check yourself
Pay rises by 10 per cent in each of these jobs. In which is the supply of labour most wage-inelastic over the next few months?
If demand for labour is inelastic, doesn't a pay rise cost no jobs at all?
No. Inelastic means employment falls by a smaller percentage than the wage rises, not that it stays put. Only a vertical, perfectly inelastic demand curve keeps employment fixed. With an elasticity of 0.2, a 10 per cent pay rise still cuts employment by about 2 per cent. With inelastic demand the total wage bill rises: the extra pay to those who keep their jobs outweighs the pay lost by those who lose theirs.
Name the determinant, then run the chain to the size: "wages are a small share of costs, so a pay rise barely moves the price, so few jobs go: inelastic". Say which side of the market you mean: demand comes from employers, supply from workers. A higher wage cuts the quantity demanded, so quote a demand elasticity as a size, without the minus sign.
Check yourself
The wage in an industry rises by 8 per cent and the number of workers employed falls by 2 per cent. What is the wage elasticity of labour demand? Give its size, without the minus sign.
0.25
2 ÷ 8 = 0.25, and the minus sign is left off when you give the size. Employment moved by a quarter as much as the wage in percentage terms, so demand is inelastic.
Exam question
Pilots' pay is a small share of an airline's total costs, and its aircraft cannot fly without qualified pilots. Explain why the wage elasticity of demand for its pilots is likely to be low. [4]
No machine can replace the pilots, so a pay rise cannot be avoided by switching to capital, and the airline still needs a pilot for every flight. Because pilots' pay is a small share of total costs, a pay rise raises costs and fares only a little, so passenger numbers and the number of flights barely fall. Both mean the number of pilots employed falls by a smaller percentage than their pay rises.
Two marks for each factor: one for naming it (no substitute for the pilots; a small share of costs) and one for the chain to a small fall in the number of pilots employed.
Both wage elasticities divide a percentage change in the quantity of labour by the percentage change in the wage. Labour demand is more elastic where workers are easy to replace with capital, product demand is elastic, wages are a large share of costs, and in the long run. Labour supply is more elastic where training is short, workers can move easily and more time has passed.