- Constraint on growth
- A constraint on growth is a limit on how large a firm can become, set by its market, its finance, its owners' aims or the law.
- Diseconomies of scale
- Diseconomies of scale are the rise in average cost that comes when a firm grows so large that it becomes hard to manage.
Four constraints on growth
Can you name the four things that can stop a firm growing, however much it wants to?
Two limit what the firm can do, one what its owners want, one what the law allows.
The size of the market limits growth when there are too few buyers to take a larger firm's extra output at a profitable price.
Can you think of an example?
A workshop making hand-made violin bows has few possible buyers nationwide. A bigger workshop would double its output, not the number of violinists.
Access to finance limits growth because expansion is paid for from profits, borrowing or selling shares, and a young firm has few profits and no record to borrow against.
Can you think of an example?
A new café made £10,000 profit last year and wants an £80,000 second site. With no record of steady profits, its bank lends only part.
Owner objectives limit growth when a firm's owners choose to keep it small, to hold on to control, a manageable workload or a way of working they value.
Can you think of an example?
A family bakery turns down investors who would pay for five new shops, because they would take a share of ownership and a say in running it.
Regulation limits growth because competition law gives the government power to block certain mergers, or to allow them only if the firm sells off some parts.
Can you think of an example?
Two large supermarket chains propose to merge. If shoppers would lose choice, the Competition and Markets Authority can block the deal or demand some shops are sold.
Check yourself
A web design firm run by two partners turns away work rather than hire staff, because the partners want to keep doing all the design themselves. Which constraint on growth is this?
Organic growth is safe but slow, while horizontal growth buys scale at a price
Organic growth keeps control with the owners, costs no takeover price and fits the way the firm already works. But it is slow, paced by profits, and in a market that is not growing each sale is won from a rival. Horizontal integration buys a rival's customers at once, with economies of scale such as bulk buying and a larger market share. The risks are overpaying for the rival, a clash of corporate personalities that leaves both firms worse off, diseconomies of scale, and a competition authority blocking a deal that reduces competition.
Vertical growth secures a stage of the supply chain, and conglomerate growth spreads risk
Backward vertical integration secures the supply, cost and quality of an input; forward vertical integration controls how the product reaches buyers. Both keep the other stage's profit margin inside the firm. But the firm may run the new stage worse than a specialist did, it is tied to a supplier or outlet it cannot easily leave, and a fall in demand for the final product hits every stage at once. Conglomerate integration spreads risk, so a bad year in one market need not sink the firm. But the businesses share no inputs or customers, so cost savings are few, and managers may run a business they do not understand.
Check yourself
A sandwich chain buys the bakery that supplies its bread. Three of these are gains to the chain. Which one is a risk?
Doesn't a merger always lower costs, because the firm gets bigger?
No. A firm can grow so large that it becomes very difficult to manage, with many layers of management trying to communicate with workers and with each other, and average cost rises. A merger also joins two ways of working, and a clash of corporate personalities can leave both firms worse off. The route matters too: a conglomerate merger joins firms with no shared inputs or customers, so it may bring almost no cost saving.
Match each point to its route: bulk buying to horizontal, secure supply to backward vertical, control of selling to forward vertical, spreading risk to conglomerate. Give a gain and a risk, each with a because. Then evaluate with a constraint: the gain arrives only if the market is big enough, the finance is there and the regulator allows it.
Check yourself
A toy maker buys a chain of cinemas. Which is the most likely gain to the toy maker from this move?
Exam question
A coffee shop chain plans to grow by buying a rival chain rather than by opening new branches. Explain one advantage and one disadvantage of this choice. [4]
Advantage: buying the rival is horizontal integration, which brings its branches and customers at once, so the chain grows faster than by building, and it gains economies of scale such as buying coffee beans in bulk, which lowers average cost. Disadvantage: the chain may pay more than the rival is worth, and running two sets of staff and systems may make it harder to manage, so it grows into diseconomies of scale and average cost rises. The competition authority could also block the deal if it cuts choice for customers.
Two marks for an advantage of buying over building, identified and explained, such as speed or economies of scale. Two marks for a disadvantage, identified and explained, such as overpaying, a clash of ways of working, diseconomies of scale or a regulator blocking the deal.
Organic growth keeps control but is slow. Horizontal integration buys market share and economies of scale, at the risk of overpaying and a clash of ways of working. Vertical integration secures inputs or the route to buyers, but ties the firm to a stage it may run badly. Conglomerate integration spreads risk but saves little cost. On any route, growth is capped by the size of the market, access to finance, owner objectives and regulation.