Learn › Economic theory › Firms and competition

Firms and competition

Invention, innovation, and process and product change

Tell invention from innovation, and process innovation from product innovation

Specification: AQA 4.1.4.8

Key terms
Invention
Invention is an advance in knowledge, such as a new idea, design or discovery, whether or not anyone has yet put it to use.
Innovation
Innovation is putting an advance in knowledge to use in a new product or service, or in a new way of producing.

Two kinds of innovation

Can you name the two kinds of innovation a firm can make?

Each one is a way to earn more profit: make the same thing more cheaply, or make something buyers want more.

A process innovation changes the method, so productivity rises and costs fall

Technology in economics covers more than new gadgets. It includes new ways of organising work, such as the assembly line, and new methods of making output to a higher quality. A process innovation changes the method of production: a machine takes over a task, steps are cut out, or the work is reorganised. The same workforce then makes more output in the same time, so labour productivity, output per worker, rises. Unless the new method is itself dear to run, average cost falls at every level of output: the cost curve shifts down, so the firm can cut its price or keep a bigger margin. Over time, this is the gain that dynamic efficiency measures.

Check yourself

A call centre's 20 staff handle 400 calls a day. New routing software lets the same 20 staff handle 500 calls a day. By what percentage has labour productivity risen?

%

A product innovation changes what the firm sells, so demand for it rises

A firm can earn higher profit by finding a way to produce more cheaply or by creating products with characteristics buyers want. Product innovation is the second route. A new or better product raises demand for what the firm sells, so it can sell more at the same price or charge more. Until rivals copy it, the firm has a temporary edge and above-normal profit. Its costs often rise at first, because research and design must be paid for. To classify a change, ask what differs. If buyers get something new or better, it is a product innovation. If they get the same thing made a new way, it is a process innovation. One change can be both, such as a lighter material that is cheaper to work and makes the product better.

A product innovation raises demand for the firm's productVertical axis: Price. Horizontal axis: Quantity. D1: a downward-sloping line. D2: a downward-sloping line. A point at price P1 and quantity Q1. A point at quantity Q2.Q1P1Q2D1D2
1 of 2

Old productBefore the innovation, the firm sells Q1 at price P1 on demand curve D1.

At price P1 the firm sold Q1 on D1; after the product innovation it sells Q2 on D2.

Check yourself

Three of these are process innovations. Which one is a product innovation?

Example

Can you put numbers on what a process innovation does to productivity and cost?

Common mistake

If a firm uses a new machine to make its product, isn't that a product innovation?

Not on its own. The test is what has changed for the buyer. A bakery that buys a faster oven and bakes the same loaf has made a process innovation: the method is new, the product is not. It becomes a product innovation only if buyers are offered something new or better, such as a loaf that stays fresh for a week. A new machine is often how a firm makes a process innovation, and sometimes it allows a product innovation too, but the machine is the means, not the test.

Exam tip

Name the kind of innovation first, then follow its own route. Process: new method, higher productivity, lower average cost, then a lower price or a bigger margin. Product: new or better product, higher demand, then more sales or a higher price. Do not claim a product innovation lowers costs unless the case says so, because it often raises them.

Check yourself

A brewery reorganises its bottling hall so each worker fills more bottles an hour. It buys no new equipment, and wages and its other input prices stay the same. What happens to its average cost?

Exam question

Distinguish between a process innovation and a product innovation, and explain how a process innovation can affect a firm's costs of production. [4]

What to take away

An invention is an advance in knowledge; an innovation puts it to use. A process innovation changes how an existing product is made: the method changes, labour productivity rises and the cost of each unit falls at every output, shifting its cost curve down. A product innovation changes what the firm sells: demand for it rises, and the firm earns above-normal profit until rivals copy it, even though its costs may rise. Ask what the buyer gets to tell them apart.