Learn › Economic history › Hyperinflation
Hyperinflation
Money you have not raised
Seven steps, about ten minutes, a question at each. You need no economics and no preparation, only a willingness to guess before you are told.
Step 1 of 7
This part assumes one idea from the last part. When a government spends money it has not raised, the bank that issues the currency creates it. That new money reaches the shops as soon as it is spent.
The question
The last part left one question open: why did these governments need to spend so much more than they raised?
What you'll be able to answer
Hyperinflation · this module is lit
In Germany the answer starts in 1914. Germany paid for the war mostly by borrowing. The government issued IOUs, and the Reichsbank, the German central bank, paid for them with newly printed money. After the war, reparations to the countries Germany had fought became its biggest single cost. Then in January 1923 France and Belgium occupied the Ruhr, the centre of German industry. The German government told the workers there to stop work in protest, and kept paying them.
Zimbabwe ended up spending money it had not raised too, by a shorter route. There the central bank, which made the money, did the spending itself. It paid for farm equipment, grain, the response to a cholera outbreak, the 2008 general election and the school examinations. The bank listed all of these in its own annual report. None of that spending appeared in the government's own accounts for 2008.
Take a guess
Germany paid for four years of war. Where did the bulk of the money come from?
Germany's began in August 1914. From then on the Reichsbank, the German , could issue paper money backed by the government's own IOUs as well as by gold.
Before that, anyone could hand Reichsbank notes in and get gold for them. About a third of the money in use was backed by gold the bank held. From 4 August 1914 the bank could count the state's IOUs as backing too. So the government could now borrow from the bank that made the money.
The bank had already stopped paying out gold for its notes on 31 July 1914, four days earlier. After that, loans from the public and short-term government IOUs paid for almost the whole cost of the war.
Direct taxes paid for only 14 per cent of the extra wartime spending, on figures the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco reports. The rest was borrowed.
A dollar cost 4.2 marks in 1914. By November 1923 the was set at 4.2 trillion marks. In German that is written „4,2 Billionen Papiermark“, paper marks, because the German word Billion means a trillion.
The mark kept losing value for the same reason all the way through. The government kept spending more than it raised and kept borrowing to cover the gap. The Reichsbank kept buying the government's short-term IOUs with new money.
By the start of November 1922, eight years in, a dollar cost about 9,000 marks. The rest of the fall, to 4.2 trillion marks, took one more year.
Suppose a saver lent the government 4.2 marks in 1914 by buying a war loan. By November 1922 those marks had lost more than 99 per cent of their value against the dollar. The worst months of the inflation were still to come.
The mark went from 4.2 to the dollar in 1914 to 4.2 trillion in November 1923. How did it get there?
German became the single biggest item in the after the war, bigger than armaments, meaning weapons and the military. They stayed the biggest item from April 1920 to March 1923.
The Treaty of Versailles, the peace treaty, did not fix how much Germany had to pay. A commission of the Allied powers set the amount in 1921. Each year's payment then came out of the same budget as everything else.
Until reparations took over, armaments had been the largest item in the German budget. Within two years of the peace, reparations were larger. France kept military spending at a much higher share of its own budget into the early 1920s, to enforce its reparations claim.
The German Historical Museum puts the Reich's debt payments at 126 per cent of state revenue. So the state owed more each year on its debts than it took in. It had to borrow again just to pay for everyday government.
Reparations were the biggest single item in the German budget between 1920 and 1923. Roughly how much of the budget did they take?
Take a guess
Germany's answer to the occupation was to call on the Ruhr to stop work. What did that decision do to the government's finances?
In January 1923 France and Belgium sent troops into the Ruhr, the centre of German heavy industry. The German government told the workers there to stop work, and paid them while they did. It called this passive resistance: refusing to work for the occupiers.
France and Belgium said Germany had missed deliveries of timber, telegraph poles and coal. The German Historical Museum calls that claim an excuse. Germany's federal agency for civic education says France wanted to do lasting harm to Germany's economy. The occupiers shut plants and banned strikes. The workers still needed money to live on.
Around 60,000 French and Belgian soldiers went in, on the German Historical Museum's count. Germany's federal agency for civic education dates their arrival to 11 January 1923. The San Francisco Fed puts the force at more than 60,000.
The government now had to pay the Ruhr workers' wages. Reparations had already been taking nearly half its budget for three years. At the same time, the Ruhr's taxes and coal stopped arriving. The German Historical Museum says the resistance cost far more than the Reich's finances could bear.
By 1923 the German state was spending far more than it raised. The gap had three causes: a war it had borrowed to fight, a reparations bill, and the wages of a region it was paying to stop work.
A deficit is the gap between what a government spends and what it raises. Germany's three costs arrived one after another, and none of them went away. The war loans had been owed since 1914. Reparations took nearly half the budget from 1920. The Ruhr occupation began in January 1923.
Each cost had to be paid in a different way. The war loans were owed to lenders at home, in marks. Reparations were owed abroad, in foreign currency. The Ruhr wages had to be paid out in cash, every week, for as long as the resistance lasted.
The occupation began on 11 January 1923 and the resistance was called off on 26 September. Over those months the price of a dollar rose from about 21,000 marks in the spring to 160 million by the end of September.
By 1923 Germany had to cover this gap somehow. Which way of raising the money was still possible?
In 2008 Zimbabwe's central bank, the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe, did the spending itself. A section of the law that set up the bank allowed it to carry out transactions on behalf of the State.
In Germany two separate bodies had to act. The government issued IOUs, and the Reichsbank bought them with new money. In Zimbabwe only one body was involved. The Reserve Bank paid for the government's programmes directly, so spending the money and creating it happened in one step.
The Bank names the law that allowed this in the Foreword to its 2008 annual report. A section of the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe Act gives it the power "to carry out transactions on behalf of the State if so requested".
The puts the Reserve Bank's 2008 subsidies at US$1,135m. Subsidies are payments that cover part of someone else's costs. These went to the public sector, to producers and to firms selling abroad. Everything the government itself collected that year came to US$133m.
A government that wants to spend money it has not raised usually needs its central bank to agree. In Zimbabwe in 2008, what happened at that point?
The Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe listed this spending in its own 2008 annual report. The list sits under its own heading, Extra Ordinary Interventions. The next heading in the report is Operations, meaning government-style spending done by the central bank.
The Foreword names seven interventions. The first three are farm machinery; grain, fuel, electricity and farm chemicals; and the fight against a cholera outbreak. The other four are the 2008 school examinations, the infrastructure for the 2008 general elections, a food programme called BACOSSI, and a first step towards using foreign currencies.
BACOSSI, the food programme, reached 1,578,365 households. The Bank counted 2,049,410 households in the provinces it covered, which leave out Harare and Bulawayo. It puts the share reached at 77 per cent. Bank staff handed the food out.
The report shows the government's 2008 budget, without the central bank's spending, taking in more than it spent. The Bank says it has cleared the whole cost of that spending from its books ("fully amortized"). Nothing is left, it says, "to be transferred as burden on the fiscus". So the government pays none of it.
Three of the four below were paid for by the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe and listed in its annual report. Which one was not?
Hyperinflation
Can you answer each one now? Tap to check.
Why was the German state spending money it had not raised?
Why did the Ruhr occupation make the gap so much worse?
How did Zimbabwe's central bank pay for the state's programmes?
Can you remember each figure? Tap to check.
When Germany's began
Share of Germany's extra war spending met by direct taxation
What a dollar cost in marks in 1914, and the set in November 1923
Share of the German taken by , 1920 to 1923
French and Belgian troops in the Ruhr from January 1923
Zimbabwe's subsidies in 2008, against all the state's revenue
What the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe called its own spending
You met seven terms in this module
, , , , , ,
Germany and Zimbabwe took different routes to the same result: spending money nobody had raised.
[1] How Germany paid for the war, in its own national museum's figures: Deutsches Historisches Museum, LeMO: Die Inflation (Stand 14 September 2014) and Die Ruhrbesetzung (Stand 10 May 2022). Both pages fetched, cached and read as rendered HTML. Every German figure below is quoted with its own original beside it, because an extraction slip between Milliarde and Billion is three orders of magnitude. War costs: „die stetig ansteigenden Kriegskosten, die sich schließlich auf 164 Milliarden Mark beliefen. Deren Finanzierung erfolgte vor allem durch Anleihen (97 Mrd. Mark), Schatzwechsel, Schatzanweisungen und ähnliche Schuldverschreibungen (57 Mrd. Mark), aber nur zu einem kleinen Teil durch Kriegsabgaben und Steuererhöhungen (10 Mrd. Mark).“ The 1914 mechanism: „Am 31. Juli 1914 stellte die Reichsbank die Einlösung von Banknoten und Scheidemünzen in Gold ein“ and „Zur Banknotendeckung wurden jetzt Schuldverschreibungen des Reiches zugelassen“. Debt service: „Der Schuldendienst des Reiches lag bei 126 Prozent der Staatseinnahmen.“ The Ruhr: „Mit dem Einmarsch von rund 60.000 Soldaten“ and „Die Kosten des passiven Widerstands überstiegen die Reichsfinanzen bei weitem.“ The fixed dollar rate: „Der Kurs für einen Dollar wurde auf 4,2 Billionen Papiermark ... festgesetzt“ -- festgesetzt, set rather than reached. LeMO also gives a reparations total, „Mehr als 132 Milliarden Goldmark“, and it is not printed. LeMO also records what the bill had to be paid in, which is what beat 5 rests on: „Mehr als 132 Milliarden Goldmark wurden vom Deutschen Reich als Kriegsentschädigung in Dollar ($), Pfund (£) und Franc (FF) gefordert“. On the totals, the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco gives 123 billion gold marks and the Bundesarchiv „269 Milliarden Goldmark“ for what is nominally the same obligation, none of the three acknowledges the others, and the budget share is uncontested where the total is not. Four things read off these pages on 5 September. The gold cover: „Etwa ein Drittel des Geldumlaufes war durch Gold gedeckt, der Rest durch andere Sicherheitsmechanismen“, and the Reich's debt certificates were „zugelassen“ as note cover alongside it rather than in place of it. The Ruhr: „Die alliierte Reparationskommission stellte Ende Dezember 1922 einen geringfügigen Lieferrückstand deutscher Reparationen an Frankreich fest; dies bot im Januar 1923 den Vorwand für den Einmarsch“ -- slight, and a pretext. The Reichsbank's part after the war: „Die Reichsbank diskontierte die Schatzanweisungen des Staates“. And „Oft erfolgten die Lohnzahlungen täglich“, which is about wages generally and names no payer, so no step attributes it to the state. TWO FIGURES IN THE READER'S PATH ARE THIS BUILD'S OWN DIVISION AND NEITHER INSTITUTION'S: 'about one mark in every seven' restates the Fed's 14 per cent, and 'more than 99 per cent' at beat 2 is 4.2 against 9,000, both of which print in that same step so the arithmetic can be checked.
[2] A dated German series of what a dollar cost, month by month: Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung: Volker Ullrich, 1923 als Schlüsseljahr für 1933?, Aus Politik und Zeitgeschichte. Fetched, cached and read as rendered HTML; an independent German dating, with its own series, and one of the three institutions behind the exchange rate under signed decision F1. In order: 9.000 Mark for a dollar at the start of November 1922; „rund 21.000 Mark“ held between February and April 1923; „Ende Juli notierte der Dollar bereits mit über einer Million Mark“; „Am 14. November überstieg der Dollarkurs erstmals die Billionengrenze, am 15. stand er bei 2,52 Billionen“; „Am 20. November konnte der Kurs des Dollars bei 4,2 Billionen stabilisiert werden“; and the parity, „Das bedeutete faktisch eine Rückkehr zum Vorkriegs-Dollarkurs von 4,20 Mark.“ The 15 November figure is why no step here writes 4,2 Billionen against that day: bpb puts the market at 2,52 Billionen on it, and 4,2 Billionen is a rate authorities set five days later. Three further sentences from this article carry beats, all read on 5 September. On the occupation: „Doch das war ein Vorwand. In Wirklichkeit ging es Frankreich darum, Deutschland in seiner Wirtschaftskraft nachhaltig zu schwächen“, with the stated grounds „Schnittholz, Telegrafenstangen und Kohle“. On its date: „Am 11. Januar waren französische und belgische Truppen ins Ruhrgebiet einmarschiert“ -- this article gives the day and the other two sources do not, so beat 4 attributes it here. And on the size of the fall: „Als Stresemann sein Amt antrat, stand der Dollarkurs bei 3,7 Millionen Mark, bis Ende September stieg er auf 160 Millionen“, which is the figure beat 5 closes on. On 20 November this article's verb is „stabilisiert werden“ and LeMO's, at the 15 November reform, is „festgesetzt“; beat 2 attributes each verb to the body that used it.
[3] The share of the German budget that reparations took, and the size of the force sent into the Ruhr: Federal Reserve: Bank of San Francisco Working Paper 2018-06, and the Bank of New York's Liberty Street Economics, Inflating Away the Debt, 13 July 2023. The working paper was rendered page by page and read, rather than grepped: printed p.1 footnote 1, the share of increased war spending paid for through direct taxes was fairly low across Europe, for example 14% for Germany; printed p.7, reparations took over from armaments as the largest single budget item, taking 48% of the budget from April 1920 to March 1923 (Young, 1925), and Sargent (1982, p.73) argues that Germany's budget deficit, reparations payments aside, did not become unsustainable until 1923; printed p.18, "Belgium and France invaded the Ruhr Valley with more than 60,000 troops"; and, a paragraph earlier on the same printed p.18, Germany had tried to raise a private loan from international banks to fund its spending, and was refused, which the sentence before it dates to December 1921. The Liberty Street post gives the pair at each end: the mark fell from 4.2 per dollar just before World War I until, by November 1923, it stood at 4.2 trillion per dollar. One paper stands behind the Liberty Street post and it is counted once: Brunnermeier, Correia, Luck, Verner and Zimmermann appear at the New York Fed, at CEPR and as NBER Working Paper 31298, and signed decision F1 counts all three as one source. The post carries no day, only the month, which is the second reason no step here dates the figure to a day. THIS PAPER CREDITS THREE OF THE FOUR FIGURES TAKEN FROM IT TO NAMED THIRD PARTIES, so the prose says 'reports' and 'cites' rather than presenting them as the Bank's own findings: 48 per cent is "(Young, 1925)" in the same sentence, 14 per cent is "(Balderston, 1989)" in the same footnote, and the sustainability claim is "Sargent (1982, p.73) argues", an argument in a contested literature rather than a finding relayed. The paper gives NO DAY for the Ruhr invasion -- only January 1923, and "Jan-23" in its chronology -- so no step takes a date from it. Also read off the rendered page on 5 September, and now carried at beat 3: to enforce its reparations claim and secure its borders with Germany, France kept a much larger share of its budget on military spending into the early 1920s. One internal contradiction, recorded per the 5 September rule and NOT carried as a disagreement between bodies: the paper gives the May 1921 settlement as 123 billion gold marks on printed p.6 and 132 billion on printed p.18. Neither total prints.
[4] The size of a central bank's own spending set beside its government's deficit: International Monetary Fund, Country Report 10/186, Zimbabwe: 2010 Article IV Consultation. Rendered and read as pages. Table 3, Zimbabwe: Central Government Operations, 2008-15 (Baseline), printed pp.22 and 23, gives the same 2008 rows on two bases. In millions of US dollars: overall balance -124, QFA by RBZ 1,135, overall balance including it -1,259. In per cent of GDP: -3.2, 28.9 and -32.1. Footnote 1/ on both pages defines the row as "Subsidies provided by the RBZ to the public sector and producers/exporters", and Figure 1's note lists what they were: spending related to elections, transfers to parastatals, subsidised directed lending, equipment and fertilisers supplied to farmers below cost, and foreign exchange allocated at subsidised exchange rates. The same table's top row gives total revenue and grants for 2008 as US$133m, which is the scale line at beat 6. The two bases agree with each other and with the arithmetic. One disagreement is carried here rather than in a step, per adjudication rule A4 and rule 49: the Reserve Bank's own paragraph 3.47 reports a 2008 central government budget SURPLUS on expenditures that exclude the quasi-fiscal spending, while the Fund's table, on that same exclusion basis but in US dollars, puts the government's overall balance at -124. Neither body mentions the other and neither reconciles the two, so no step asserts that the surplus was caused by the exclusion. The report's claim is attributed to the report and the Fund's figures to the Fund. imf.org/external/pubs refuses this repository's fetcher and is on its blocklist; the imported-full-text path above answers and is the same document. Read again on 5 September, and it narrows the claim: footnote 1/ defines the 1,135 row as "Subsidies provided by the RBZ to the public sector and producers/exporters", which is the Fund's own category and NOT the Reserve Bank's section 8(2) formula 'on behalf of the State' -- producers and exporters are not the State, and the Fund nowhere mentions the Bank's published seven-item list. Beat 6 and beat 7 say subsidies, and neither claims the Fund's row and the Bank's list are the same set.
[5] The list a central bank published of what it had been paying for, and the accounts it kept that spending out of: Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe, 2008 Annual Report. Rendered and read as pages, because the brief required the paragraph numbers to come off a page rather than an extraction. Both are correct as the allocation cited them. Printed p.4, Foreword by the Governor, carries the two tier-2 subheadings Extra Ordinary Interventions and Quasi-Fiscal Operations. Paragraph 1.10, under the first: the Bank, citing section 8(2) of the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe Act (Chapter 22:15), a provision that lets it carry out transactions for the State on request, undertook extra-ordinary interventions, followed by the seven-item list quoted in the prose. Paragraph 1.13, under the second: the outlays have been written off in full, so nothing at all will pass to the fiscus as a burden, and therefore none to the "tax paper" -- the last two words are the report's own. Printed p.20, Fiscal Developments, paragraph 3.47: excluding Quasi Fiscal expenditures, the central Government's 2008 fiscal outturn was an overall budget surplus of $14.9 sextillion, with the table beneath it repeating the exclusion in a footnote. Chapter 8 is the programme list, and its BACOSSI tables give 1,578,365 households served against 2,049,410 counted, which the report puts at 77 per cent. Two things re-read on 5 September. ¶8.4's "established number of households of 2,049,410" is the total of the eight provincial rows in the table beneath it -- Matabeleland North and South, Manicaland, Midlands, Mashonaland East, West and Central, and Masvingo -- and HARARE AND BULAWAYO ARE NOT AMONG THEM, so it is the Bank's own provincial count and not the country's households. And the seven-item list sits wholly under Extra Ordinary Interventions, ¶¶1.9 to 1.10, with Quasi-Fiscal Operations the subheading over ¶1.12 and ¶1.13. Item iv is "Logistical support in the administration of National Schools Examinations in 2008", which is what beat 7's option and reveal now say.
Country data from the World Bank (CC BY 4.0) and the UNDP Human Development Report (CC BY 3.0 IGO)
Games · Learn · Atlas · Read · Feedback · Privacy · Contact