A lost job cuts a household's income, and often more than that
For the person who loses a job and their family, there is the daily worry of not knowing where the next pay packet is coming from. Savings run down; some sell the car or move somewhere cheaper. Even when they find a new job, it may pay less than the old one. For many people a job is part of their self-worth, so being out of work can strain family life and harm mental and physical health.
Households spend less, so firms sell less
Unemployed workers and their families cut back on what they buy, so consumption falls and firms selling to them lose sales. Firms that expect weaker demand hire fewer workers, which can push unemployment higher still. For some firms there is an upside: with more people looking for work, employers find recruits more easily and can hold down pay rises, which keeps their costs lower.
Check yourself
Unemployment rises sharply in a town. Which firm is most likely to gain rather than lose?
Unemployment rises by 200,000 and the government changes no tax rates and no benefit rules. What do you think happens to government borrowing?
With no change in the rules, fewer people in work pay less income tax and spend less, so tax revenue falls, while more people claim benefits. Revenue falls and spending rises at once, so borrowing goes up.
The government collects less tax and pays out more in benefits
When unemployment rises, incomes and profits fall, so less income tax and corporation tax is paid, and less VAT on what people no longer buy. At the same time more people claim unemployment benefits and other support. Both happen automatically, without any new law, so the budget deficit widens in a recession. Money spent on benefits is money the government cannot spend on schools or hospitals, or must borrow.
Check yourself
100,000 more people become unemployed. Each would have paid £6,000 a year in taxes, and each now receives £4,000 a year in benefits. By how many million pounds a year does the government's budget worsen?
1000
Each person costs the budget £6,000 of lost tax plus £4,000 of new benefits, £10,000 in all. Times 100,000 people that is £1,000 million a year, or £1 billion.
Society loses the output the unemployed could have made
When willing workers cannot find jobs, the economy is like a company with a working factory standing idle. What is lost for good is the goods and services those workers could have produced. The cost is not shared evenly: it falls hardest on the young, the less qualified and regions where a big employer has closed. Frictional unemployment, the short spell between jobs, costs far less, because it is part of matching people to the right work.
- Opportunity cost of unemployment
- The opportunity cost of unemployment is the output that the unemployed workers could have produced.
- Automatic stabilisers
- Automatic stabilisers are tax and spending programmes already in law that stimulate aggregate demand in a recession and hold it down in a boom.
Isn't the real cost of unemployment the money paid out in benefits?
No. Benefits move money from taxpayers to the unemployed: they are a transfer, and nothing is used up when they are paid. They matter for the government's budget, but they are not the cost to the economy. That cost is the output nobody produces while willing workers sit idle, and it would be lost even if no benefit were paid at all. Answer a question about society's costs with lost output first, and the budget second.
Name the group, then the chain for that group. "The government loses income tax and pays more in benefits, so borrowing rises" earns more than "the government loses money". To evaluate, ask how long the unemployment lasts and what type it is: long spells and structural job losses cost far more than a few weeks between jobs.
Check yourself
Three of these are costs of rising unemployment. Which one can be a gain for some firms?
Exam question
Explain two consequences of a rise in unemployment for the government. [4]
Tax revenue falls: people out of work pay less income tax and spend less, so VAT receipts fall too. Spending on benefits rises, because more people claim unemployment and other support. With revenue down and spending up, the budget deficit widens and the government must borrow more or cut spending elsewhere.
Two marks for each consequence: one for naming it and one for the reason it follows from unemployment. "The government loses money" earns at most one mark, because it names neither the tax nor the spending link.
Unemployment cuts the income of the unemployed and can harm their health and future pay. They spend less, so firms sell less, though firms that are hiring face less pressure on wages. The government collects less tax and pays more in benefits, so borrowing rises. The cost to society is the output the unemployed could have produced, and it is highest for long spells and falls hardest on the young, the less qualified and the regions hit by closures.