Prices that rise faster than pay cut what a household can buy
If every price and every wage rose by the same amount on the same day, nobody's buying power would change. In practice prices rise first and pay catches up later, often only once a year, so workers lose buying power in between and may have to fight for rises that keep pace. People on incomes fixed in pounds lose most. A retiree whose pension stays the same in pounds loses buying power every year, and over a decade or two the losses compound.
You borrowed at a fixed interest rate of 9 per cent, expecting inflation of 3 per cent. Inflation turns out to be 9 per cent. Are you better or worse off than you planned?
You repay the same pounds, but each pound now buys less. The real interest rate you pay falls from the 6 per cent you expected to zero, and the lender bears the loss.
Unexpected inflation moves buying power from lenders to borrowers
Anyone holding cash, or savings earning less than inflation, loses. If a bank account pays 4 per cent interest and inflation is 5 per cent, the real return is minus 1 per cent, and any tax due is charged on the full 4 per cent. A borrower at a fixed interest rate gains: the loan is repaid in pounds worth less than expected, and the borrower's gain is the lender's loss. The government, a large borrower, gains on its fixed-rate debt in the same way. Nobody earned these gains or deserved these losses, which is one reason people see inflation as unfair.
Check yourself
A savings account pays 3 per cent interest a year and inflation is 7 per cent. What is the real rate of return, in per cent?
-4
The real rate is the interest rate minus inflation: 3 minus 7 is minus 4 per cent. The saver has more pounds at the end of the year, but they buy about 4 per cent less.
High and variable inflation blurs prices and makes planning harder
Prices carry messages about demand and supply. When inflation is high and bouncing about, a firm cannot tell whether a higher price for its product means more demand or just general inflation, so markets adjust more slowly and erratically. Long-term decisions, such as building a factory or saving for retirement, get harder when nobody knows what money will buy in ten years. Firms spend time protecting themselves from inflation instead of improving their products. If UK prices rise faster than prices abroad, UK exports also become dearer and sell less.
Check yourself
Inflation jumps between 5 and 25 per cent from year to year. Why might a furniture maker hesitate to build a new factory?
Deflation makes debts heavier and spending weaker
Unexpected deflation raises the real burden of debt. With a nominal interest rate of 7 per cent and prices falling 2 per cent, a borrower pays a real rate of 9 per cent. More borrowers fail to repay, banks lose money and lend less, and aggregate demand falls, which can deepen a recession. If people expect prices to keep falling, households and firms may also put off buying, waiting for lower prices, which cuts demand further. A central bank cannot easily cut interest rates below zero, so with prices falling it may be unable to bring the real interest rate down far enough to revive spending.
- Deflation
- Deflation occurs when the rate of inflation is negative, so money has more purchasing power over time rather than less.
- Disinflation
- Disinflation is a decline in the rate of inflation, while prices are still rising.
Doesn't inflation make everyone poorer?
Not on its own. Over long periods wages have risen roughly as fast as prices, so on average people's buying power is not much changed by inflation. The costs come from things not moving together: pay lagging behind prices, pensions and savings fixed in pounds, interest rates set before inflation turned out higher. That is why inflation that is expected, and built into pay and interest rates, does much less harm than inflation that takes people by surprise.
Name the group and say whether the inflation was expected. The UK target is 2 per cent CPI inflation, symmetric and applying at all times, because low and stable inflation reduces uncertainty and lets firms and households plan and invest. So judge a cost by the size, speed and predictability of the inflation, not the sign alone.
Check yourself
Prices fall by 2 per cent a year for several years. Who is most likely to be made worse off?
Exam question
Explain how an unexpected rise in inflation affects savers and borrowers. [4]
Savers lose: if the interest they earn is below the new inflation rate, the real return on their savings is negative, so their money buys less than before. Borrowers at fixed interest rates gain: they repay the loan in pounds that are worth less than they expected, so the real interest rate they pay falls. Buying power moves from lenders to borrowers.
Two marks for savers (the loss, and the real return falling below zero or below what they expected) and two for borrowers (the gain, and repaying in pounds worth less). "Unexpected" matters: expected inflation is built into interest rates and redistributes little.
Inflation does harm when prices, wages and interest rates do not move together. Workers lose when pay lags behind prices, and people on fixed incomes and savers lose buying power. Unexpected inflation moves buying power from lenders to borrowers. High and variable inflation blurs price signals and makes long-term planning harder. Deflation raises the real burden of debt, can deepen a recession, and is hard for a central bank to fight.