- Circular economy
- A circular economy is an economic system that keeps materials, resources and energy in use at their highest value for as long as possible.
- Linear economy
- A linear economy relies on extracting new raw materials to make products that are thrown away once they are used.
Four loops bring a used product back into the economy
Can you name the four loops by which a circular economy brings a used product back into use?
Each loop returns the product to a different point in the chain that made it. The shorter the loop, the more of the product survives.
Repair fixes a broken or worn product so that it goes back into use with the same user.
Can you think of an example?
A washing machine's drum bearing fails. A repairer fits a new bearing, and the household keeps the machine instead of buying another.
Reuse returns a used product, whole, to be used again, as it is or after cleaning, often through a seller or service provider.
Can you think of an example?
An eye department at a Northampton hospital switched from single-use to reusable surgical scissors, cleaned between operations. It saved 1,000 pairs of scissors and £12,000.
Remanufacture returns a used product to a manufacturer, which takes it apart, replaces worn parts and rebuilds it to an as-new condition.
Can you think of an example?
In 2021 Leeds Teaching Hospitals bought 604 remanufactured heart catheters, saving £76,610, and earned £22,923 more by selling its used catheters to the same firm.
Recycling breaks a used product down into materials, which are turned into new parts or products.
Can you think of an example?
Aluminium drinks cans collected from homes are shredded and melted, and the metal is rolled into sheet for new cans.
A linear chain ends in landfill, while a circular one loops back
In a linear economy a product passes once along a chain: raw materials are extracted, made into parts, assembled into a product, sold and used, and then burned or sent to landfill. Each new product needs new raw materials.
A circular economy adds loops. Repair keeps the product with its user. Reuse sends it back to a seller or provider, remanufacture back to its maker, and recycling back to the parts maker as material.
Check yourself
A hospital's used heart catheters are remanufactured: taken apart, fitted with new parts and sold again. Which flow is this?
A runs from the user back to the seller. That is reuse: the product goes round again whole, with no rebuilding by its maker.
Yes. B returns the used product to the product maker, which takes it apart and rebuilds it. That is remanufacture.
C runs back to the parts maker. That is recycling: the product is broken down into materials, not rebuilt as the same product.
The waste hierarchy ranks preventing waste first and landfill last
Defra's waste hierarchy ranks what to do with materials by what is best for the environment. Preventing waste comes first: using less material, and keeping products for longer. Next comes preparing for re-use, such as checking, cleaning and repairing; then recycling; then other recovery, such as burning waste to make energy; and last, disposal in landfill.
The UK is a long way from circular. A report cited in the government's Design for Life roadmap puts the UK's circularity at 7.5 per cent, and finds that over 90 per cent of the materials the economy uses are newly extracted, 80 per cent of them imported.
Check yourself
A brewery has an empty glass bottle. Which of these ranks highest in the waste hierarchy?
Isn't a circular economy just recycling more?
No. Recycling keeps the least of a product: it breaks the product into materials and loses the work that shaped them, and some material each time. Repair, reuse and remanufacture keep the product whole, and the waste hierarchy puts preventing waste, by using less and keeping products longer, above all of them. A country could recycle more while its use of new raw materials kept rising.
Define the circular economy against the linear one: take, make, dispose once, against keeping products and materials in use. Then name a specific loop and what it returns, such as "remanufacture returns the product to its maker to be rebuilt", rather than writing "recycling" for every loop.
Check yourself
Three of these keep a product or its materials in use. Which one belongs to a linear economy?
Exam question
Explain two ways in which a circular economy differs from a linear economy. [4]
First, a linear economy disposes of a product once it has been used, while a circular economy keeps it in use through repair, reuse and remanufacture, so its value is kept for longer. Second, a linear economy needs new raw materials for each new product, while a circular economy recycles used products into materials for new ones, so less has to be extracted.
Two marks for each difference: one for stating it and one for explaining what happens to the product or its materials. Design for long life, or ranking prevention above recycling, would also earn marks with an explanation.
A linear economy takes raw materials, makes products and throws them away. A circular economy keeps materials, resources and energy in use at their highest value for as long as possible. Repair keeps a product with its user; reuse, remanufacture and recycling return it to the seller, the maker and the parts maker. The waste hierarchy puts preventing waste first and landfill last.