- Equity
- Equity is fairness in how income, wealth and opportunity are shared out, judged against a view of what people ought to have.
- Equality
- Equality is a situation in which people or groups end up with the same, or nearly the same, amount of something, such as income.
Economists use two ideas of fair treatment
Can you name the two kinds of equity economists use to judge whether people are treated fairly?
Both are most often applied to taxes and benefits.
Horizontal equity is treating people in the same economic position in the same way, so that people with equal incomes pay equal tax.
Can you think of an example?
Two nurses in England each earn £38,000 a year, one in Leeds and one in Bristol. They pay the same income tax, whatever their postcode, hobbies or family name.
Vertical equity is treating people in different economic positions differently, in a way judged fair, such as asking those with higher incomes to pay more.
Can you think of an example?
UK income tax rates rise in bands as income rises, so someone earning £100,000 pays a larger share of their income in tax than someone earning £20,000.
Equal incomes are not always fair incomes
Complete equality of income at any one time is unlikely even in a society most people would call fair. Most workers earn little in their first jobs, more by middle age and less after retirement, so a country with people of different ages shows some inequality even if everyone's lifetime earnings were the same. Preferences differ too: some people choose long hours and a bigger house, others more free time.
So a fair result need not be an equal one. One view of equity asks for more equal outcomes; another asks for an equal chance, a ladder of opportunity that people from any background can climb, and accepts that where they end up will differ.
Check yourself
A council heating grant pays the same amount to any two pensioners with the same income and savings, wherever they live in the borough. Which idea of fairness does this rule follow?
Measuring inequality is positive, but judging what is fair is normative
How unequal incomes are is a positive question: it can be measured and checked, for example by the share of income each fifth of households receives. How much inequality is too much, and whether a pattern is fair, rests on values, so no data can settle it. Vertical equity carries such a judgement: many accept that higher earners should pay more, but they differ on how much more.
Economists cannot say how much inequality is too much, but they can set out the policy options and their costs. They also disagree about whether markets or governments should do more to make an economy fairer.
Check yourself
Which of these statements is a claim about equity rather than equality?
If everyone gets exactly the same, isn't that always the fair outcome?
Not always. A £300 payment to every household towards energy bills gives the same sum to a retired couple on a small pension and to a millionaire, and leaves the gap between their incomes where it was. Equal payments are horizontally equitable only between people in the same position. Paying two workers the same weekly wage when one works twice the hours is equal, but many would call it unfair. Ask what is being shared equally, and between whom.
Define both terms before you use them, and keep them apart: equality is a measurable outcome, equity a judgement of fairness. Name the kind of equity a policy serves, such as "a progressive income tax applies vertical equity", and point to the value judgement inside it.
Check yourself
Three of these apply vertical equity. Which one applies horizontal equity?
Exam question
Distinguish between equity and equality, using an example of a government policy. [4]
Equality means people end up with the same, or similar, amounts of something such as income; it can be measured. Equity means fairness, which depends on a value judgement about what people ought to have. A progressive income tax is not equal treatment, since higher earners pay a larger share of their income, but it applies vertical equity: many judge it fair that those able to pay more do so.
One mark for each definition and two for the example: one for the policy, one for linking it to equity or equality correctly. Saying that equity is normative and equality measurable shows the distinction clearly.
Equality is people ending up with the same amount of something; equity is fairness, a judgement of what people ought to have. Horizontal equity treats people in the same position alike; vertical equity treats people in different positions differently, as a progressive tax does. Incomes vary with age and choices, so unequal incomes at one time can still be fair. Measuring inequality is positive; judging how much is fair is normative.