Explain what drove the recovery from 1999 on the IMF's account, why South Korea recovered sooner than Indonesia, and what was still unfinished by 2000.
12 min
7 questions
Before you start
What you'll be able to answer
What drove the recovery from 1999?
Why did South Korea recover sooner than Indonesia?
What was still unfinished by 2000?
Where this sits
The Asian Financial Crisis — 1997 to 2000 · this module is lit
2 Jul 1997Thailand stops holding the baht at a fixed rate to the dollar and lets it float
14 Aug 1997Indonesia lets the rupiah float
20 Aug 1997The IMF approves a loan of about $3.9 billion for Thailand
Nov 1997The IMF approves a loan of about $10.1 billion for Indonesia
Nov 1997Indonesia closes 16 banks
4 Dec 1997The IMF approves a loan of about $21 billion for Korea
24 Dec 1997Korea's programme is speeded up
21 May 1998President Suharto of Indonesia resigns
Aug 1998A crisis in Russia spreads panic beyond Asia
1-2 Sep 1998Malaysia brings in rules on money leaving the country
1999Growth returns in most of the region
In December 1998 South Korea paid back part of its emergency loans
In 1997 South Korea nearly ran out of dollars to pay its foreign bills. A year later it paid back part of its emergency loans. In December 1998 it repaid 2.8 billion dollars to the International Monetary Fund (IMF), which lends to countries that cannot pay their foreign bills. The IMF had set up a special fund for countries whose lenders suddenly stop trusting them. South Korea's loan came from that fund. The IMF took the repayment as a sign that South Korea was getting out of its crisis.
Take a guess
Early forecasts mostly expected South Korea's economy to grow by one or two per cent in 1999. What do you expect happened?
It grew by more than 10 per cent, far faster than the early forecasts. The next section gives the figures and a chart.
In 1999 growth returned, strongly in South Korea and barely in Indonesia
Output, or gross domestic product (GDP), is the value of everything an economy produces. According to the World Bank's current figures, South Korea's output fell by 4.9 per cent in 1998. It then grew by about 11.6 per cent in 1999. Malaysia grew by 6.1 per cent in 1999, Thailand by 4.6 per cent and the Philippines by 3.3 per cent. Indonesia's output barely grew.
At first most forecasts had expected South Korea to grow by one or two per cent in 1999, the US Congressional Research Service notes. It is a US body that writes reports for Congress. Recovery came faster than many observers had expected, the IMF wrote in June 2000. The chart shows South Korea's growth each year from 1995 to 2001.
South Korea's growth each year, 1995 to 2001Yearly growth in output, after allowing for price changes, per cent; below zero means output fell
Source: World Bank, World Development Indicators, GDP growth (annual %), Korea, Rep. CC BY 4.0.
Check yourself
Look at the chart. What happened to South Korea's growth in 2000 and 2001?
The IMF said the recovery came from households and firms spending again
The 1998 recessions (years when output falls) came mainly from a collapse in spending at home by households and firms, the IMF says. Firms cut investment in buildings and machines most. The recoveries came when that spending picked up again.
Financial markets in South Korea and Thailand calmed early in 1998, and in Indonesia much later. Currencies recovered part of their fall, though they stayed well below their pre-crisis levels. In South Korea and Thailand interest rates began to fall early in 1998; in Indonesia they fell only from mid-1999. Lower interest rates make borrowing cheaper, and rates were kept low to support growth. South Korea's output began to rise in the second half of 1998, the IMF says, though 1998 as a whole still fell. By June 2000 the IMF put growth down to households' spending, to exports (goods sold abroad), and to some new investment by firms.
Imports fell, exports grew and current accounts swung into surplus
A country's current account compares what it pays the rest of the world, such as imports and interest, with what it earns from the rest of the world. If it pays more than it earns, it has a deficit. If it earns more, it has a surplus. Imports fell sharply during the recessions. The current accounts of South Korea, Thailand and Indonesia had swung quickly from deficit to surplus by January 1999, the IMF reported.
A cheaper currency makes a country's goods cheaper for foreign buyers and foreign goods dearer at home. Currencies still well below their pre-crisis levels helped exporters compete, the IMF said in June 2000. Strong world demand for electronics helped keep the surpluses going. South Korea went from a deficit of 1.7 per cent of its GDP in 1997 to a surplus of 12.7 per cent in 1998, the IMF's table shows.
Check yourself
Work from this module: in 1997 South Korea's current account was a deficit of 1.7 per cent of GDP. In 1998 it was a surplus of 12.7 per cent of GDP. By how many percentage points did it change? (A percentage point is the gap between two percentages.)
percentage points
14.4 percentage points
About 14.4 points. Going from a deficit of 1.7 to zero is 1.7 points, and from zero to a surplus of 12.7 is 12.7 more: 1.7 plus 12.7 is 14.4. In one year South Korea went from paying the world more than it earned to earning far more than it paid.
Check yourself
A South Korean firm sells a car priced at 20 million won, South Korea's currency. When a dollar buys more won than before, what happens to the car's price in dollars for an American buyer?
The IMF's account of why South Korea recovered sooner than Indonesia
In the IMF's account South Korea's markets calmed sooner than Indonesia's, and its recovery came sooner. South Korea raised interest rates for a short time to steady the won. Higher rates pay more to people who hold won, so fewer sell. By early 1998 its markets were stable again. Then South Korea quickly switched to helping the economy grow again. The government let its budget deficit grow, meaning it spent more than it took in, to soften the recession. South Korea stopped drawing on its IMF loan, rebuilt its reserves of dollars and other foreign money, and by 2000 was borrowing on world markets again.
Indonesia's recovery was held back by political turmoil and by policies poorly carried out, the IMF wrote; its economy began to grow again only late in 1999. Strife and political instability were still weighing on Indonesia's currency in April 2000, the Congressional Research Service noted.
Take a guess
The IMF lent to the crisis countries on condition that they changed their policies. Under these rescue programmes, banks and finance companies that could not survive were closed. What do you expect happened to the money their owners had put in?
The owners lost some or all of what they had put in. The next section explains this, and what happened to lenders that could survive.
The programmes closed failed lenders and rebuilt weak banks
Reform of the banks was at the centre of the programmes. In every case, lenders that could not survive were to be closed, the IMF's factsheet of January 1999 says. The money their owners (shareholders) had put in was to be written down, meaning counted as lost. A bank's capital is the money its owners put in. If the bank loses money, its capital is used up first. Banks short of capital were to be recapitalised, meaning given new capital. Weak banks were to be closely supervised.
By June 2000 weak banks and other lenders had been closed, merged or recapitalised, and supervision strengthened, the IMF reported. South Korea, Thailand, Indonesia and Malaysia had rebuilt their banks with government money, the Congressional Research Service notes. The service says this in effect turned short-term debts owed by private firms into longer-term debts owed by governments. The governments had to repay them.
Check yourself
Suppose a South Korean bank has just been given new capital in 1999, but most firms asking it for loans are close to bankruptcy. What would you expect the bank to do?
By 2000 bad loans and unfinished reform still weighed on the region
Reform of banks and companies was much slower than the recovery of the economies, the Congressional Research Service reported in April 2000. The service said South Korea, Thailand, Indonesia and Malaysia were still in a credit crunch, meaning banks had sharply cut lending. So many firms were bankrupt that few borrowers could meet the banks' stricter standards. In most of the crisis countries, bad loans (loans unlikely to be repaid) seemed to be falling slowly as a share of all debt. Even so, the total amount of bad loans might still be rising.
The IMF lent to Thailand, Indonesia and South Korea. In all three, it thought, firms' debts were being reorganised too slowly. The slow progress held back the recovery. The Congressional Research Service added that analysts warned the recovery was uneven, and that incomes in several countries were still well short of their pre-crisis levels.
By 2000 the IMF called the crises over, and a US report called the recovery incomplete
The crises were behind the region by June 2000, the IMF wrote. In its view the rebound had two sources: the countries carrying out their policies, and the money lent to them. Most of that money came under the IMF's own programmes. Apart from Indonesia, the East Asian economies hit hardest by the crisis had made "a remarkable, though still incomplete, recovery", in the words of the Congressional Research Service. Why the crisis happened, and whether the rescues helped or hurt, is argued over. What caused the Asian financial crisis, and were the rescues the right response?
Check yourself
The key questions
What drove the recovery from 1999?
In the IMF's account the recessions came from a collapse in private spending, and the recoveries from its revival. Markets calmed, currencies recovered part of their fall, and interest rates fell. Imports fell sharply. Exports also helped, because currencies were still cheap and world demand for electronics was strong. Current accounts swung from deficit to surplus. The IMF also credited the countries' own policies and its own programmes.
Why did South Korea recover sooner than Indonesia?
In the IMF's account South Korea's markets were stable by early 1998, after a short rise in interest rates. South Korea then quickly switched to helping the economy grow again. Its output turned up in the second half of 1998. In December 1998 it paid back part of its emergency IMF loans, and in 1999 it grew by more than 10 per cent. Indonesia's recovery was held back by political turmoil and policies poorly carried out, the IMF said. Its interest rates fell only from mid-1999, and its output barely grew that year.
What was still unfinished by 2000?
The rescue programmes closed lenders that could not survive and wrote down their owners' money. They gave weak banks new capital, often government money. But reform of banks and companies went much more slowly than the economies recovered, the Congressional Research Service reported. Bad loans remained, banks lent little to firms, and analysts warned the recovery was uneven and incomplete.
The numbers
South Korea's output, 1998 and 1999 (World Bank)Fell by 4.9 per cent, then grew by about 11.6 per cent
Growth in 1999 elsewhere (World Bank)Malaysia 6.1, Thailand 4.6 and the Philippines 3.3 per cent; Indonesia barely grew
South Korea's current account, 1997 and 1998 (IMF, June 2000)A deficit of 1.7 per cent of GDP, then a surplus of 12.7 per cent
Emergency IMF loans South Korea repaid, December 19982.8 billion dollars
Check yourself
What drove the recovery from 1999, according to the IMF?
Check yourself
Why did South Korea recover sooner than Indonesia, in the IMF's account?