Explain why output fell so far in East and South-East Asia in 1998, who bore the cost, and how the rescue programmes were changed during the year.
12 min
8 questions
Before you start
What you'll be able to answer
Why did output, the value of what each economy produced, fall so far across the crisis countries in 1998?
Who paid the price when the economies shrank?
How did the IMF change its loan programmes for the crisis countries as their recessions got worse?
Where this sits
The Asian Financial Crisis — 1997 to 2000 · this module is lit
2 Jul 1997Thailand stops holding the baht at a fixed rate to the dollar and lets it float
14 Aug 1997Indonesia lets the rupiah float
20 Aug 1997The IMF approves a loan of about $3.9 billion for Thailand
Nov 1997The IMF approves a loan of about $10.1 billion for Indonesia
Nov 1997Indonesia closes 16 banks
4 Dec 1997The IMF approves a loan of about $21 billion for Korea
24 Dec 1997Korea's programme is speeded up
21 May 1998President Suharto of Indonesia resigns
Aug 1998A crisis in Russia spreads panic beyond Asia
1-2 Sep 1998Malaysia brings in rules on money leaving the country
1999Growth returns in most of the region
In late 1997 the IMF programmes for Indonesia and South Korea still expected growth in 1998
In November 1997 Indonesia agreed a programme of loans and conditions with the International Monetary Fund (IMF), which lends to countries that cannot pay their foreign bills. The programme assumed that Indonesia's economy would still grow by 3 per cent in 1998/99, the budget year that started in April 1998. The IMF's Independent Evaluation Office, the IMF's own watchdog, records that in January 1998 the forecast was cut to zero. South Korea's programme of December 1997 assumed growth of 2.5 per cent in 1998.
Take a guess
What do you expect happened to Indonesia's output, the value of what its economy produces, in 1998?
It fell by more than a tenth, far below what the programmes forecast. The next section gives the figures and a chart.
In 1998 output fell across the region
Output, or gross domestic product (GDP), is the value of everything an economy produces. In 1998 it fell by 13.1 per cent in Indonesia, World Bank figures show, by 7.6 per cent in Thailand, 7.4 per cent in Malaysia and 4.9 per cent in South Korea, and slightly in the Philippines. A fall in output over a period is a recession, and Indonesia's was a deep one.
The chart shows Indonesia's growth each year from 1990 to 1998.
Indonesia's growth each year, 1990 to 1998Growth in real GDP (output after allowing for price rises), per cent; below zero means output fell
Source: World Bank, World Development Indicators, GDP growth (annual %), Indonesia. CC BY 4.0.
Falling currencies made dollar debts heavier
Banks and firms across the region had borrowed heavily abroad in dollars. When a currency such as the rupiah, Indonesia's, falls against the dollar, one dollar buys more rupiah. So each dollar they owed cost more in their own money, while what they owned at home and the income they earned were worth no more than before. Many firms now owed more than they could pay, and banks that had lent to them faced losses. A firm's or bank's balance sheet sets what it owes against what it owns. The evaluation office finds that the currency collapse badly damaged the balance sheets of firms and banks.
A firm with debts it can barely pay tends to keep its cash to pay them and put off new buildings and machines. A bank facing losses on its loans tends to lend less, so fewer firms can borrow to invest.
Check yourself
Look at the chart. What happened to Indonesia's growth in 1997, the year the crisis began?
Check yourself
Across Indonesia, many firms put off new buildings and machines at the same time. What does this do to the country's output?
Investment fell much further than the programmes had projected
Investment is spending on new buildings, machines and equipment. In Indonesia the November programme had expected it to fall hardly at all in the year from April 1998; it fell by about a third, the evaluation office records. In Korea it fell by 21.2 per cent in 1998, against a projected fall of 14.2 per cent. Banks that were being closed or rebuilt also lent less.
Investment is part of output, so large falls in investment pulled output down. In Indonesia, in the evaluation office's view, the fall in investment explains much of the gap between the forecast and what happened. In both countries the damage to balance sheets was clearly underestimated. The office notes that at the time most economists, inside and outside the IMF, did not yet study balance sheets in this way.
Take a guess
A poverty line is the income below which a household counts as poor. Before the crisis about one Indonesian in nine lived below Indonesia's national poverty line. What do you expect happened to that share by the end of the crisis?
It nearly doubled, by World Bank estimates. The next section gives the figures.
Poverty rose sharply in Indonesia and in South Korea's cities
Each country sets its own poverty line. The share of Indonesians below the national poverty line rose from 11.0 per cent before the crisis to 19.9 per cent after it, by World Bank estimates reported by the US Congressional Research Service. Their overall standard of living fell by 24.4 per cent. A severe drought in parts of Indonesia added to the hardship and caused widespread hunger, the report says. Incomes in the countries hit appeared by 2000 to have fallen less than first estimated, the report notes. But living standards were seriously harmed in every one of them.
In South Korea the share of city dwellers below the poverty line rose from 8.6 per cent in 1997 to 19.2 per cent in 1998. The crash in Thailand appears to have fallen mainly on the urban middle classes, and poverty across the country rose only moderately, the report says.
Check yourself
Work from this module: the share of South Korea's city dwellers below the poverty line was 8.6 per cent in 1997 and 19.2 per cent in 1998. By how many percentage points did it rise? (A percentage point is one step on the per cent scale.)
percentage points
10.6 percentage points
About 10.6 points: 19.2 minus 8.6. In 1997 fewer than one city dweller in ten was below the line; in 1998 it was nearly one in five.
Check yourself
A farmer on Java, in Indonesia, sells a crop whose price is set on world markets in dollars. The rupiah falls against the dollar. What happens to the rupiah the farmer gets for each tonne?
City and countryside fared differently
In general the crisis hurt the urban poor and middle classes more than people in the countryside, the Congressional Research Service report finds. Many farmers grew cash crops, crops grown for sale, whose value is set by world prices. When local currencies fell, those crops brought in more local money. So farmers' incomes tended to rise compared with those of city workers. Many city workers in South-East Asia went back, at least for a time, to the villages they had come from.
Most South Korean workers did not have that option, the report says. But Korea, with far more wealth, could set up unemployment benefits and other relief fairly quickly. Thailand and Indonesia lacked the money and the government offices to give much support.
As the recessions deepened, the budget targets were relaxed
In Indonesia and Korea the first programmes called for tight money, meaning higher interest rates, to steady the currencies. They also called for tighter budgets. Thailand's aimed for a small surplus. A government with a surplus takes in more than it spends, which holds down spending. A deficit, spending more than it takes in, adds to spending. As the recessions deepened, the targets changed. From February 1998 Thailand's target was a deficit, rising in steps to 5 per cent of GDP by December. In May Thailand was allowed careful cuts in interest rates, after holding them high.
Korea's target moved from a small surplus to a deficit in February 1998, with larger deficits allowed in May and July as tax revenue fell. In June Indonesia's programme raised planned social spending to 7.5 per cent of GDP, on job programmes and subsidies that kept food, fuel and medical care cheap.
The evaluation office's later view of the first budgets
Looking back, the evaluation office judged that the first tightening of budgets in Indonesia and Korea was not needed, given how far output fell. It also found that the tightening was relaxed quickly once the collapse became clear. Some critics argued that the tight budgets had helped cause the collapse. The office disagreed. In its view the tightening had been mild. The collapse came from damage to firms' and banks' balance sheets and to confidence. The programmes had not allowed for that damage.
In Korea, the office records, IMF staff advised as early as late December 1997 that the government need not keep to its budget target and should let the deficit widen as revenue fell. The government was reluctant to depart from its habit of balanced budgets.
Check yourself
Three of these were changes made to the rescue programmes during 1998. Which one was not?
Check yourself
The key questions
Why did output, the value of what each economy produced, fall so far across the crisis countries in 1998?
Banks and firms had borrowed heavily in dollars, so when their currencies fell, what they owed grew in their own money while what they owned and earned did not. Firms cut back and banks lent less, and investment fell far more than the IMF's programmes had projected, by about a third in Indonesia. In the evaluation office's view this damage to balance sheets was clearly underestimated. Output fell in Indonesia, Thailand, Malaysia, South Korea and the Philippines, by more than a tenth in Indonesia.
Who paid the price when the economies shrank?
Poverty rose sharply, by World Bank estimates: the share of Indonesians below the national poverty line nearly doubled, and in South Korea's cities it more than doubled. In general, the Congressional Research Service report finds, city dwellers were hit harder than people in the countryside. In the countryside, cash crops sold at world prices brought in more local money as currencies fell. In Indonesia a drought added to the hardship; in Thailand poverty rose more moderately. Korea could pay unemployment benefits; Thailand and Indonesia could give little support.
How did the IMF change its loan programmes for the crisis countries as their recessions got worse?
During 1998 the budget targets were relaxed: Thailand's moved from a small surplus to a deficit, and Korea's moved to a deficit and then larger ones as tax revenue fell. Thailand was allowed to cut interest rates further, carefully, and Indonesia's programme raised planned spending on food, fuel, medical care and jobs. Looking back, the evaluation office judged that the first budget tightening in Indonesia and Korea was not needed. The office also judged that the tightening did not cause the collapse in output.
The numbers
Indonesia's output, 1998Fell by 13.1 per cent
Indonesians below the national poverty line, before and after the crisis11.0 and 19.9 per cent
City dwellers below the poverty line in South Korea, 1997 and 19988.6 and 19.2 per cent
Thailand's budget target, December 1998A deficit of 5 per cent of GDP
Indonesia's social spending target, June 19987.5 per cent of GDP
Check yourself
Why did investment fall so much further than the programmes had projected?
Check yourself
In general, which group did the recession hit harder, the Congressional Research Service report finds?
Check yourself
As the recessions deepened, which way did the programmes move the budget targets?