Learn › Economic history › Japan's Lost Decade — 1989 to 2006

Japan's Lost Decade — 1989 to 2006

The 1997 Tax Rise and Japan's Bank Failures

Explain what happened to Japan's economy and banks around the April 1997 tax rise and the failures of November 1997, and what the IMF said caused the downturn.

Before you start

What you'll be able to answer

  1. Why did Japan's economy turn down again in 1997?
  2. What happened to Japan's banks and securities houses (firms that trade shares and bonds for clients) in November 1997? What did the Bank of Japan, Japan's central bank, do?
  3. Why did Japanese banks have to pay more to borrow abroad?

Where this sits

Japan's Lost Decade — 1989 to 2006 · this module is lit

  1. Dec 1989Share prices in Japan peak
  2. Aug 1990The Bank of Japan's last rise in its discount rate, the interest rate at which it lent to banks
  3. Aug 1992The government announces the first of six spending packages up to 1995
  4. 1995-96The first direct use of taxpayers' money against financial instability covers losses at failed housing-loan companies, the jusen
  5. 1 Apr 1997The consumption tax rate, a tax on what people buy, is raised
  6. Nov 1997Sanyo Securities, Hokkaido Takushoku Bank and Yamaichi Securities fail
  7. Oct-Dec 1998Japan's parliament, the Diet, makes more public money available to deal with banks' bad loans, and the state takes over the Long-Term Credit Bank and Nippon Credit Bank
  8. Feb 1999The Bank of Japan begins its zero interest rate policy, pushing its overnight rate as low as possible
  9. Mar 1999Public capital, new capital paid for by the state, is put into the major banks
  10. Mar 2001The Bank of Japan begins quantitative easing, a target for the money banks keep in their accounts with it
  11. Oct 2002The Financial Services Agency, the banking regulator, launches its programme to cut bad loans
  12. Mar 2006The Bank of Japan ends quantitative easing

Japan in the spring of 1997

Japan's economy grew again in 1996 after years of slow growth. The recovery did not last. In the spring of 1997 the government raised the consumption tax, a tax on what people buy. It also cut its own spending. By the end of November two securities houses, firms that trade shares and bonds for clients, and a large bank had failed. A 2001 paper for the Bank for International Settlements (BIS), the central banks' own bank, calls this the financial crisis of autumn 1997.

Take a guess

The higher consumption tax rate applied from 1 April 1997. What do you expect happened to household spending in the months just before and just after that date?

The government raised taxes and cut its own spending in 1997

On 1 April 1997 the government raised the consumption tax from 3 per cent to 5 per cent. In June it ended an income tax cut given in earlier years. It also sharply cut public investment, its spending on roads, buildings and other works.

The budget deficit is the gap between what the government spends and what it collects in a year. Part of it shrinks when the economy grows, because people then pay more tax. The structural deficit is the part that stays even when the economy is doing well.

Japan's structural deficit fell by about 1.5 per cent of GDP, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) estimated. The IMF advises and lends to its member countries. GDP is the value of everything the economy produces in a year. The aim was to get the government's finances under control before an ageing population pushed its costs up, the IMF said.

Household spending fell back after April, and output fell

Households had rushed to buy ahead of the tax rise, the IMF reported. After April the extra buying stopped. GDP fell sharply from April to June 1997. It rose a little from July to September, then fell again from October 1997 to March 1998. The economy was back in recession, a fall in output that lasts for some time.

The fall in household spending after the tax rise was larger than expected, the IMF said in 1999. A 2019 brief from the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond, part of the US central bank, says household spending fell after the rise, then stayed flat for about two years. The brief said few published statistical studies had tested whether the tax rise caused the recession. Spending changed sharply when the tax rose, according to research the brief reported, but that research did not blame the tax for the recession.

Check yourself

Work from this: the consumption tax rate rose by 2 percentage points, that is, 2 more yen of tax on every 100 yen spent. A household spends ¥200,000 a month on things the tax applies to, and buys the same things after the rise. Roughly how much more tax does it pay each month, in yen?

yen
Take a guess

On 3 November 1997 Sanyo Securities, a medium-sized securities house, failed. It had borrowed ¥8.3 billion in the interbank market, where banks lend each other spare cash. It had put up no collateral, something the lender can take if a loan is not repaid. Sanyo could not repay the money. The sum was small compared with the amounts that market handled. What do you expect other lenders did next?

One firm's unpaid debt made banks afraid to lend to each other

Sanyo's failure to repay made lenders afraid that other borrowers might fail next. Many placed their money with the Bank of Japan, Japan's central bank, instead of lending it to other banks. Foreign banks cut how much they would lend to Japanese banks in general. With less money on offer, the interest rates banks charged each other were pushed up. Hiroshi Nakaso wrote in the 2001 BIS paper that the Bank of Japan stepped in. In late November it lent large sums in the interbank market to keep it working.

Hokkaido Takushoku Bank and Yamaichi Securities failed within weeks

On 17 November 1997 Hokkaido Takushoku Bank told the Bank of Japan it could no longer keep running by itself. Its share price and its deposits had fallen. It was the first city bank, a large commercial bank, to close during the crisis, the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco noted. On 24 November Yamaichi Securities, a large securities house, said it would close. It had kept some debts out of its accounts, and these debts had just been found.

The Bank of Japan lent to Hokkaido Takushoku and Yamaichi so that customers could get their money and assets back. Hokkaido Takushoku's savers were taking their deposits out. Hokuyo Bank, a regional bank in Hokkaido, had agreed to take over its business there. The Bank of Japan lent to Hokkaido Takushoku without collateral. That lending peaked at ¥2.6 trillion in early February 1998.

Check yourself

Lenders were holding back from the interbank market in November 1997. What did the Bank of Japan do about this?

Share prices fell, and Japanese banks paid more to borrow abroad

The chart shows an IMF index of Japanese share prices for each month from 1996 to 1998. An index tracks prices against a base year. Here the base year is 2010, set at 100. Share prices fell sharply from mid-1997 as people worried that the banks were in trouble, the IMF said. Between mid-1997 and the end of the year the index lost about a fifth of its value.

The same worry made it harder for Japanese banks to borrow abroad. Foreign banks had already cut how much they would lend to them. Japanese banks also paid extra interest to borrow abroad, called the 'Japan premium'. The premium rose sharply as the failures came, the IMF reported. Nakaso notes that lenders charge more to a bank they fear might fail. Lenders abroad now feared that Japanese banks in general might fail.

Japanese share prices, 1996 to 1998IMF index of share prices: each point is a monthly average, with 2010 set at 100
100125150175200199619971998Tax rise, Apr 1997Failures, Nov 1997

Source: International Monetary Fund, Monetary and Financial Statistics: Financial Market Prices, Japan, equities, period-average index. IMF data, used with credit.

Check yourself

Look at the chart. What did share prices do in the two months after the tax rise of April 1997?

Check yourself

Tightening a budget means raising taxes or cutting spending so that the deficit shrinks. Three of these would tighten a government's budget, as Japan's was tightened in 1997. Which one would not?

The IMF named several causes of the downturn

In August 1998 the IMF gave its reasons for the downturn. It said household spending fell after the tax rise. It said problems in the banks were an important factor, because banks with weak finances lent less. It said the tighter budget slowed the economy further, and so did the Asian financial crisis. That crisis began in Thailand in July 1997.

Japan's net exports are what it sold abroad minus what it bought from abroad. They fell in early 1998, mainly because Japan sold less to the rest of Asia, the IMF said. In 1999 the IMF added that bank lending fell sharply, partly because of the failures of late 1997. It also said the amount of goods Japan exported fell through 1998.

Check yourself

The key questions

Why did Japan's economy turn down again in 1997?

What happened to Japan's banks and securities houses (firms that trade shares and bonds for clients) in November 1997? What did the Bank of Japan, Japan's central bank, do?

Why did Japanese banks have to pay more to borrow abroad?

The numbers

Consumption tax rate before and after 1 April 1997
Fall in the structural deficit in 1997 (IMF estimate)
Sanyo Securities' unpaid borrowing in the interbank market, November 1997
Bank of Japan's lending to Hokkaido Takushoku without collateral, at its peak in early February 1998
IMF share price index, mid-1997 to the end of 1997

Check yourself

A commentator in 1998 says the tax rise alone caused Japan's downturn. Which of these would the IMF add?

Check yourself

Why did the Bank of Japan lend Hokkaido Takushoku large sums, without collateral, after its failure was announced?

Check yourself

Why did lenders abroad charge Japanese banks extra interest after the failures of November 1997?