Before you start
What you'll be able to answer
- How did the second oil price rise compare with the first?
- What did governments do about the second rise?
- Did the second shock bring worse inflation than the first?
Where this sits
The Great Inflation — 1971 to 1982 · this module is lit
- 15 Aug 1971The United States stops turning dollars into gold, freezes wages and prices, and puts a tax on imports
- Dec 1971–Mar 1973New fixed rates are agreed in December 1971, with the dollar devalued against gold; they break down, and by March 1973 the main currencies float
- 1972Food and commodity prices start to climb, while consumer prices across the rich world are already rising
- Oct 1973Arab oil producers embargo shipments to the United States and the Netherlands
- 1974Imported crude costs US refiners far more than in 1973; in America inflation and unemployment rise together
- Jan 1976At a meeting in Jamaica, IMF members agree that each country may choose its exchange-rate arrangement; gold is to lose its official price
- 1979Iran's revolution cuts its oil production, and the oil price rises a second time
- Oct 1979The Federal Reserve raises its discount rate, the rate at which it lends to banks, and most of the other countries the series follows raise an official rate within two months
- 1982Net bank lending to the developing countries that did not export oil halves, and a debt crisis begins
- 1983Inflation is below its peak in all eleven countries the series follows
Trouble in Iran cut the world's oil supply again
From late 1978 into 1979, Iran supplied much less oil to the world. Iran's ruler, the Shah, was removed in what became the Iranian revolution. On 5 April 1979 President Jimmy Carter said events in Iran had cut world oil supplies a second time. He said oil exporters had raised prices sharply again. The first oil shock, a sharp jump in the oil price, came five years earlier. This series follows eleven countries, among them the United States, Britain and Japan. All now faced a rising oil price again.
The second rise added more dollars to the price of a barrel than the first one did. Now measure each rise as a share of the price it started from. How do you think the second rise compared with the first?
A smaller rise as a share. The next section gives the figures.
Comparing the two rises on one oil price
West Texas Intermediate is a type of crude oil whose price is widely quoted. From August 1977 to January 1979 it cost $14.85 a barrel every month. All prices here are the dollar prices of the time, not adjusted for inflation. The price started to climb in February 1979. It rose in twelve of the fifteen months up to April 1980. From April to July 1980 it stayed at $39.50. That was $24.65 above its starting price. The first oil shock had also raised this price. It was $3.56 a barrel until July 1973 and $11.16 from October 1974, a rise of $7.60. In dollars, the second rise was much bigger. As a share of the starting price, it was smaller. The second time, the price ended at 2.66 times its starting level. The first time, it ended at 3.13 times.
Iran's oil output collapsed while world output rose in 1979
Iran produced 5.24 million barrels of crude oil a day in 1978. Its output fell in each of the next three years, to 1.38 million barrels a day in 1981, about a quarter of the 1978 level. Other producers pumped more. Saudi Arabia's output rose from 8.30 million barrels a day in 1978 to 9.53 million in 1979. World output rose from 54.26 million to 56.62 million barrels a day. Taken over the whole of 1979, the world produced more oil than the year before, and the price still kept climbing.
Check yourself
World oil output was higher in 1979 than in 1978, yet the price kept rising. Which of these could push the price up even with more oil being produced?
One official account of why the price kept rising
The US President's Council of Economic Advisers wrote in January 1981 that two things had shrunk before Iran's supplies were cut. One was spare production capacity, oil that producers could pump at short notice. The other was oil held in stock. World oil use had risen steadily from 1975 to 1978, and stocks fell during 1978. When Iran's supplies were cut, buyers feared more cuts and built up their stocks. That extra buying pushed the price up. Buyers then expected stored oil to be worth more later, so they stored still more. The Council judged that a smaller price rise would have been enough to make the oil produced equal the oil used. Exporters also raised their official prices. Saudi Arabia's official price went up in April, July and December 1979. Japan's Economic Planning Agency noted that the first rise came all at once and the second in stages.
In April 1979 Carter had to decide on the legal limits on American oil prices
Crude oil produced in the United States was sold under federal price controls. These legal limits held its price below the world price. About half the oil Americans used came from abroad. The world price was rising again after the cuts in Iran's supplies. By law the controls were due to end in September 1981. From June 1979 the President could decide what happened to them before then. President Jimmy Carter had to choose.
Your decision
You are Jimmy Carter. What do you choose?
Controls keep the price of oil produced at home below the world price, so Americans pay less for fuel while the world price climbs.
Where it was triedThe President's Council of Economic Advisers judged that controls on oil produced at home had made the first oil shock milder. They kept American prices from taking the full effect of the world price rise.
What it costsCarter said the controls held down oil production at home and encouraged waste and reliance on foreign oil.
A higher price gives producers a reason to pump more oil and users a reason to burn less. Removing the controls in steps spreads the price rise over time, so each step is smaller.
Where it was triedA 1978 law had already begun a gradual end to the controls on natural gas prices.
What it costsOil that companies had already found would sell for more. Carter said this extra money was an undeserved windfall: profit the companies had done nothing to earn. He also expected the change to add a little to inflation at first.
Removing the controls in one go gives producers and users the full world price straight away.
Where it was triedIn 1971 the United States had put limits on wages and prices across the whole economy. When those limits ended in 1973 and 1974, the Council of Economic Advisers recorded a burst of price and wage rises.
What it costsPrices of petrol and heating oil would jump in one step. Carter said he wanted to avoid this kind of sudden shock to the economy.
On 5 April 1979 Carter announced that the controls would be removed in stages. The first step would come on 1 June, and the process would run for 28 months. He also asked Congress, the US law-making body, for a tax on the oil companies' windfall profits: profit they had done nothing to earn. The money would go into an energy security fund. He told Americans that each of them would "have to use less oil and pay more for it".
What followedThe Council of Economic Advisers judged that removing the controls raised the average price of American crude oil only a little in the second half of 1979. The controls coming off and the exporters' price rises together pushed up the prices of oil products such as petrol and heating oil. In the first three months of 1980 those prices rose so fast that, had that pace lasted a full year, they would almost have doubled. President Reagan sped up the end of the controls as one of his first acts in office in 1981.
The industrial countries' response to the second rise
Germany's council of economic experts reports to its government each year. In November 1979 it wrote that the governments of the industrial countries aimed to stop their oil imports growing. They would hold imports at the level already reached, until 1985. The aim was an amount of oil, not a price. To meet the aim without harming growth and jobs, the council said, countries would need to save more oil and switch more to other fuels. Higher taxes on burning oil could help. The council added that the aim was not meant to be met through a long recession, a period when the economy shrinks. A separate promise had been made by April 1979. Carter said then that 20 oil-using countries, his own among them, had promised to use 5 per cent less oil than they had expected to use. This promise was about oil used, not oil imported.
Check yourself
The German council said the import aim was not meant to be met through a long recession. How would a recession have met it?
Each of the eleven countries had a year of highest inflation in the years around the first oil shock. After the second shock, do you think most countries' highest inflation was higher or lower than their earlier highest?
Lower in most of them. The next section gives the count.
Inflation peaks after the first shock and after the second
For each country, take its highest yearly inflation in 1972 to 1977. Then take its highest in 1978 to 1983. Call each of these a peak. Each yearly figure is the average of that year's monthly readings. Each reading shows how much consumer prices had risen since the same month a year before. For Australia the readings come every three months. In seven of the eleven the later peak was lower: Britain, Japan, West Germany, France, the Netherlands, Switzerland and Australia. France's two peaks were only 0.05 of a percentage point apart. In the United States, Italy, Canada and Sweden the later peak was higher. The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) is a club of rich countries. It also gives one inflation figure for all its members, more countries than these eleven. The OECD peak rose, from 14.10 per cent in 1974 to 14.85 per cent in 1980.
Japanese inflation and pay across the two shocks
Japan's consumer prices rose 23.18 per cent in 1974, the highest of the eleven. Its 1980 peak was far lower, and no other country's peak fell as far. By 1978, before the second shock, Japanese inflation was already down to 4.21 per cent. Japanese manufacturing pay grew 26.20 per cent in 1974, 6.00 in 1978 and 7.43 in 1980. In August 1980 Japan's Economic Planning Agency explained why prices rose less than in 1974. Pay rises had stayed steady and each worker produced more, so the pay cost of making each item fell. Firms also used less oil and other materials per item, and sold more. So their prices rose by less than their costs. So far, higher prices had not led to higher pay that pushed prices up again. In 1974, big pay rises and falling output per worker had raised the pay cost of each item.
Source: International Monetary Fund, Consumer Price Index (IMF.STA:CPI), Japan, change on a year before, monthly. IMF data, used with credit.
Check yourself
Look at the chart. The oil price began its second climb in February 1979. When did Japanese inflation start rising again?
Check yourself
Read the chart: at its highest point in 1980, about what was Japanese inflation, in per cent?
8.7 %
About 8.7 per cent, in September 1980. This is a monthly reading, so it sits a little above the yearly averages in the text. The chart's 1974 high was 24.8 per cent, so the 1980 high was about a third of it.
American pay and inflation across the two shocks
Of the nine countries with pay figures, the United States had the lowest growth in manufacturing pay in 1974, at 8.55 per cent. In 1980 it was almost the same, 8.78 per cent. Yet American inflation was higher at its second peak: 11.03 per cent in 1974 and 13.58 per cent in 1980. Elsewhere, falling pay growth did not always mean a lower peak. West German pay growth fell from 10.67 to 6.53 per cent, and its peak fell too. Swedish pay growth also fell, from 10.99 to 8.85 per cent, but its peak rose. In 1981 the US Council of Economic Advisers wrote that firms raise pay as the cost of living rises, partly to keep workers. When unemployment is low, an oil price rise is more likely to bring bigger pay rises. The 1980 recession, it added, did not cut spending enough to stop American inflation rising again.
Check yourself
The key questions
How did the second oil price rise compare with the first?
It added more dollars to a barrel but raised the price by a smaller share. It also came in stages over more than a year. The loss of Iranian oil started the rise. In the US Council of Economic Advisers' account, buyers storing extra oil and the exporters' own price rises kept it going.
What did governments do about the second rise?
Germany's council of economic experts reported that the industrial countries' governments aimed to hold down the amount of oil they imported. The United States also began taking the price controls off its own crude oil in June 1979.
Did the second shock bring worse inflation than the first?
Not in most of the eleven. Seven had a lower inflation peak the second time, and Japan's fell the most. Japan's government said in August 1980 that steady pay and more output per worker had so far stopped higher prices and higher pay from pushing each other up in turn. Four peaked higher, among them the United States. American pay growth had barely changed, so pay alone does not explain why the US peak was higher.
The numbers
Check yourself
Measured on the same crude oil price, how did the second oil price rise differ from the first?
Check yourself
Which of these describes inflation after the second oil shock?
Check yourself
What did the industrial countries' governments set out to hold down until 1985?