- Positive statement
- A positive statement describes the world as it is, and can be tested against evidence, at least in principle.
- Normative statement
- A normative statement describes how the world should be, and rests on values that no evidence can prove true or false.
A positive statement can be tested, and it can turn out false
Positive statements are factual. They may be true or false, and we can test them, at least in principle, by looking at what actually happens. An economist who works out whether the expected benefits of a new rail line exceed its costs is doing positive analysis. A positive claim that the evidence shows to be wrong is still positive: it has been tested and has failed.
A normative statement is a value judgement
A normative statement says what ought to be. It is a value judgement: it is subjective, because it depends on what the speaker believes is good, fair or right, and no evidence can prove it true or false. Arguing that the rich should pay a larger share of their income in tax is a normative case.
Examiners do not accept "it is an opinion" on its own as the explanation, since a forecast can be someone's opinion and still be positive. Name the value judgement instead. The line between the two is not always sharp, which is why a careful reader looks for the value judgement inside the sentence.
Check yourself
Three of these are positive statements. Which one is normative?
Can you think of one positive and one normative statement about the same policy?
"A 20p tax on sugary drinks will cut the number sold" is positive: sales can be counted before and after. "The government ought to tax sugary drinks" is normative: it depends on how much weight you give health against freedom of choice, and no sales figure could settle it. The two statements are about the same policy and belong in different boxes. Deciding whether to bring in the tax needs both: the positive prediction that sales and sugar intake will fall, and the moral or political judgement that better health is worth some loss of freedom of choice, and worth a tax that falls hardest on poorer households.
If a statement is wrong or untested, doesn't that make it normative?
No. "Cutting income tax always raises the government's tax revenue" is positive, because evidence can test it, and the evidence says it is false. A claim nobody has tested yet is positive too, as long as evidence could test it: "a four-day week would raise output per hour in the UK" has not been tried nationally, but it could be. Disagreement does not make a statement normative either: economists argue over many positive claims because the evidence is hard to read. What makes a statement normative is a value judgement, usually carried by words such as should, ought, fair, too high or better.
Check yourself
"Raising the minimum wage will reduce employment among young workers." What kind of statement is this?
Name the test, not just the label. Write "positive, because it could be checked against evidence" or "normative, because 'unfair' is a value judgement", and quote the judgement itself. Use the words "value judgement", not "opinion": "normative because it is an opinion" is not accepted as the explanation.
Check yourself
"Bus fares in the North rose faster than wages last year, and that is unfair to young workers." Which part makes the sentence normative?
Exam question
Explain the difference between a positive and a normative statement, using an example of each. [4]
A positive statement describes what is, or what will happen, and can be tested against evidence, such as "a sugar tax will reduce sales of fizzy drinks". A normative statement says what ought to be and rests on a value judgement that evidence cannot settle, such as "the government should tax sugary drinks".
One mark for each explanation and one for each matching example. An example only earns its mark if it fits the explanation: a normative example has to carry a value judgement, usually through a word such as should, fair or better.
A positive statement describes the world as it is and can be tested against evidence, at least in principle, so it may turn out true or false. A claim not yet tested is still positive if evidence could test it. A normative statement says how the world should be: it is a value judgement, subjective and beyond proof, not merely an opinion. Being wrong does not make a statement normative, and nor does disagreement. Look for the value judgement, often carried by words such as should, ought or fair.