- Distortion of price signals
- A distortion of price signals is when a government rule stops prices acting as messengers that tell buyers and sellers about demand and supply.
- Unintended consequences
- Unintended consequences are effects of a policy that its makers did not plan, as people respond in unexpected ways that undermine the policy's intent.
Government failure in four policies
Can you think of a real policy for each of the four causes of government failure?
Three are real policies from the source; the fourth is invented. Each example names the cause and its mechanism.
Farm price supports are price floors that keep farm prices above equilibrium, usually by the government buying up the product to add to demand.
Can you think of an example?
The European Union held the price of wheat above equilibrium, so farmers grew more than buyers wanted and taxpayers bought the surplus. Cause: distortion of price signals, since the price told farmers to grow more than consumers would buy.
A tariff is a tax added on imported goods, which raises their price to buyers and shields home producers from foreign rivals.
Can you think of an example?
In 2009 the United States raised its tariff on tyres from China to protect tyre-making jobs. Estimates in the source say it saved about 1,200 but cost about 3,700 in other industries, as buyers paying more for tyres spent less elsewhere. Cause: unintended consequences.
Command-and-control regulation is a set of laws stating how much pollution firms may emit, and often which equipment they must use to cut it.
Can you think of an example?
One limit for every factory treats firms that could cut pollution cheaply like firms for which it is costly, because the rule-writer cannot see each firm's costs. Cause: an information gap, so pollution falls at needless cost.
A licensing scheme requires every seller in a market to hold a permit from a public body, which checks applicants and enforces the rule.
Can you think of an example?
A council makes every window cleaner hold a licence to deter rogue traders. Vetting and enforcement cost £60,000 a year; the harm from rogue traders was about £5,000 a year. Cause: excessive administrative costs.
Check yourself
A government guarantees dairy farmers a price for milk above what buyers will pay, and buys whatever is left unsold. Stocks of milk powder pile up. Which cause of government failure does this show?
A price set by law leaves demand and supply still at work
Prices collect information about demand and supply and carry it to buyers and sellers. A price control stifles the message but does nothing to the forces behind it, so demand and supply still show up in what people do. A guaranteed price above equilibrium shows up as a surplus; a price held below it shows up as a shortage, and often as falling quality.
One policy can show two causes, so name the one doing most damage
Real policies rarely fail for one reason. The farm price support distorted the price of wheat, then buying the surplus added a bill for taxpayers. The tyre tariff raised the price of tyres, but its worst effect landed in other industries, where buyers had less to spend. To classify a case, find the mechanism that does most of the damage, name that cause, then mention the other.
Check yourself
Three of these cases show an information gap. Which one does not?
Can you think of a policy that shows two causes of government failure at once?
A city caps rents as demand for flats rises. At the capped rent more people want flats than landlords offer, so fewer flats are rented than at the market rent. That shortage comes from a price signal held below equilibrium, and since the cap was meant to help renters it is also an unintended consequence. Landlords spend less on maintenance and heating too, an unintended consequence on any reading.
If a policy changes a price, isn't that always a distortion of price signals?
No. A tax on a good with an external cost, set at the right level, makes the price carry a cost buyers and sellers were ignoring, so it corrects the signal. A signal is distorted when the policy pushes the price away from true costs and benefits, as a guaranteed farm price does. Check the direction: towards the full social cost, or away from it?
In a question built on an extract, the marks come from the link, not the label. Name the cause, point to the detail in the case that shows it, and say who loses: "Distortion of price signals: the guaranteed price is above what buyers pay, so farmers grow a surplus that taxpayers buy." If a case shows two causes, name the main one and mention the other.
Check yourself
A council bans cars from one busy shopping street to cut congestion. Drivers switch to the side streets, and congestion there gets worse. Which cause of government failure does this show?
Exam question
Explain two causes of government failure, using an example from a different market for each. [4]
First, distortion of price signals: farm price supports hold the price of wheat above equilibrium, so farmers grow more than buyers want and taxpayers pay for the surplus. Second, unintended consequences: a tariff on imported tyres protects tyre-making jobs, but buyers paying more for tyres spend less elsewhere, so jobs are lost in other industries.
Two marks for each cause: one for naming it and one for a mechanism tied to a real market. An information gap in pollution rules or excessive administrative costs in a licensing scheme also earn full marks with their mechanism.
This page sorts cases into four common causes of government failure; the specifications name others too, such as conflicting objectives and regulatory capture. A distorted price signal tells people the wrong thing, as farm price supports did when they left a surplus. Unintended consequences are responses nobody planned, like the jobs a tyre tariff cost elsewhere. An information gap leaves a rule set without the figures it needs, and excessive administrative costs make a scheme cost more than it saves. Name the cause doing most damage, then any other.