Expansionary fiscal policy is tax cuts or increases in government spending designed to stimulate aggregate demand and move the economy out of recession.
Expansionary monetary policy
Expansionary monetary policy is a monetary policy that increases the supply of money and the quantity of loans in the economy.
Three readings of a slump
Can you name the three schools of thought that read a slump, and its cure, differently?
Each reading points to a different cure.
Definition
The classical view holds that flexible wages and prices return an economy in recession to full employment by itself, so no active policy is needed.
Can you think of an example?
Example
Unsold goods pile up, so prices and wages fall until buyers and employers return.
Definition
The Keynesian view holds that recessions come from too little aggregate demand, and sticky wages and prices can keep output below potential for years.
Can you think of an example?
Example
A crash cuts wealth, so spending falls and the multiplier cuts output further.
Definition
The monetarist view holds that slumps deepen when money and prices are allowed to fall, so the central bank should keep money growing steadily.
Can you think of an example?
Example
Falling prices raise the real burden of debts, so borrowers default and banks fail.
Early on, America did far less than the slump needed
The 1929 crash cut household wealth, so consumption and investment fell, and the multiplier made the fall in output much larger. The classical view, dominant until then, said falling prices would restore full employment. Instead prices fell 6.7 per cent a year from 1930 to 1933, pushing borrowers into default and banks into bankruptcy. Government spending, just 4 per cent of GDP in 1929, was too small to steady demand. Capacity was much as before, yet US unemployment reached almost 25 per cent. Keynes concluded that in a deep slump only government had the power to move aggregate demand.
1 of 3
Before the crashThe economy starts at potential output Yp, where AD0 meets SRAS at the price level P0.
A fall in spending moves the economy from Yp to Y1; demand-side policy tries to move it back.
Check yourself
Aggregate demand falls from AD0 to AD1, as US spending did after 1929, and wages are sticky. Where is the economy in the short run?
Yes. In the short run the economy moves along SRAS to where AD1 meets it: output below potential, a lower price level and high unemployment.
B is where the economy started, on AD0. Once spending has fallen, AD0 no longer describes demand, so the economy cannot stay there.
C is the classical end point, where wages and prices have fallen far enough to restore full output. With sticky wages that takes years, not the short run.
Britain kept a roughly balanced budget and recovered on cheap money
Britain's response differed. In a 2012 speech drawing on the economist Nick Crafts, the minister Vince Cable set out the record. The budget stayed roughly balanced from 1929 to 1938, and Keynes and others blamed a fiscal tightening for a second dip in 1932. In Cable's account, recovery came from money: Britain left gold in 1931, the pound fell, and real short-term interest rates fell from about 10 per cent to under 1 per cent. Cheap credit fuelled a housing boom, and with no banking crisis Britain recovered two years before America.
Check yourself
Britain kept its budget roughly balanced through the 1930s, yet recovered after leaving gold. Which reading does this evidence support most?
Take a guess
When the 2008 financial crisis hit, what do you think America and Britain did first?
Policy makers looked back to the 1930s. Both central banks cut their interest rates close to zero within months, and both governments cut taxes and raised spending for a time.
In 2008 America cut rates, created money and borrowed to spend
The Federal Reserve, the US central bank, cut its interest rate to near zero by December 2008, then created money to buy long-term bonds: quantitative easing. Early in 2009 an 830 billion dollar package of tax cuts and extra spending followed, partly offset by state and local cuts. Alan Blinder and Mark Zandi found that without it the fall in GDP would have been significantly larger. The first round seems to have worked best. Its effect was muted, probably because banks held much of the new money, and reserves nearly quintupled by early 2014 without the inflation some feared. No one can know what would have happened otherwise.
Check yourself
Quantitative easing nearly quintupled US bank reserves, yet inflation stayed low. What does this suggest?
Britain cut rates and VAT, then cut its deficit from 2010
The Bank of England cut Bank Rate from 5 per cent in October 2008 to 0.5 per cent in March 2009, then used quantitative easing. The government cut VAT from 17.5 to 15 per cent for 13 months and brought forward 3 billion pounds of capital spending, a stimulus of under 1.5 per cent of GDP. Borrowing hit 11 per cent of GDP in 2009-10; the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) found the stimulus caused only a small part of that. From 2010-11 the stimulus was withdrawn, and VAT later rose to 20 per cent.
Views on the switch differ. The OBR assumes, with conventional multiplier analysis, that tightening slows growth for a while. In 2012 Cable argued that Britain could recover while cutting its deficit if money stayed loose.
Exam tip
Name the country, episode, policy and reading. Keynesians stress fiscal action, such as the US stimulus; monetarists stress money, such as Britain's recovery from the Depression on a balanced budget. Then judge what success turned on: whether banks were lending, how far demand had fallen and how much room the budget had.
Check yourself
Three of these were part of the UK's demand-side response to the 2008 crisis. Which one was not?
Exam question
Evaluate the view that monetary policy did more than fiscal policy to end the Great Depression and the 2008 recession in the US and the UK. [12]
For: Britain kept its budget roughly balanced in the 1930s yet recovered after leaving gold, as real interest rates fell from about 10 per cent to under 1 per cent and cheap credit fuelled investment and house building; in 2008 both central banks cut rates close to zero and used quantitative easing, and the first US round seems to have helped; the UK fiscal stimulus was small, and most of the extra borrowing came from the recession itself. Against: monetary policy weakens in a deep slump with a banking crisis, because banks hold new money rather than lend it, as the US experience after 2008 suggests; Keynesians point to Blinder and Zandi's finding that the US fiscal stimulus made the fall in GDP significantly smaller, and Keynes blamed Britain's 1932 tightening for a second dip. Judgement: monetary policy did more where banks still worked, as in 1930s Britain; where the banking system broke, as in 2008 and the US in the 1930s, fiscal support arguably mattered more, though the counterfactual can never be known for certain.
Levels reward accurate knowledge of both episodes in both countries, analysis of how each policy moves aggregate demand, evaluation using the Keynesian and monetarist readings and the limits of each tool, and a judgement that names what the answer turns on.
What to take away
Early in the Depression the US did far less than the slump needed; Keynes concluded that government must move aggregate demand. Britain kept its budget roughly balanced and recovered on cheap money after leaving gold. In the financial crisis both countries cut rates almost to zero, used quantitative easing and added a stimulus; Britain later switched to cutting its deficit. Success depended on whether banks were lending.