A government that borrows competes with firms for the same savings
When a government spends more than it collects in tax, it borrows the difference by selling bonds. The funds it borrows must come from somewhere: households might save more, private firms might borrow less, or the money might come from foreign investors. Whatever the budget deficit takes, one of those three must give. If private saving and inflows from abroad stay the same, a larger deficit leaves less financial capital for firms to invest in machines and buildings.
The government borrows an extra £50 billion to pay for new spending. What do you think happens to interest rates?
The government's borrowing adds to the demand for financial capital while the supply of savings is unchanged, so lenders can charge more. The Bank sets Bank Rate, but longer-term market rates also respond to borrowing.
Extra borrowing pushes interest rates up
A larger budget deficit shifts the demand for financial capital to the right. With the supply of savings unchanged, the equilibrium interest rate rises. A survey of US studies suggests that a deficit one per cent of GDP larger raises interest rates by between half and one percentage point, other things held equal, though some studies find only a limited connection.
BeforeFirms and government together borrow Q0 at an interest rate of r0.
Check yourself
The government's budget deficit rises and it sells more bonds to cover it. Which way does the demand for financial capital move?
A higher interest rate cuts private investment and consumption
Firms borrow less to invest in physical capital when the interest rate is higher, and households borrow less for houses and cars. So the rise in government spending is partly offset by a fall in private spending, and aggregate demand rises by less than the spending itself. The direct effect of expansionary fiscal policy is not usually wiped out entirely, but the policy ends up less powerful than expected, and less private investment today means a smaller stock of capital to produce with later.
How much is crowded out depends on spare capacity and the central bank
In a deep recession firms lack both the funds and the reason to invest, and interest rates are low, so little is crowded out: in the US, crowding out appears to have been suspended during the Great Recession. If the economy is producing well below potential, a central bank may keep rates low and offset the effect. Near potential, it may raise rates to hold off inflation, making crowding out worse. Public investment that raises productivity, such as roads or education, can also add to growth rather than subtract from it.
- Crowding out
- Crowding out is when government borrowing and spending cause interest rates to rise, which reduces business investment and household consumption.
- Budget deficit
- The budget deficit is the amount by which government spending exceeds tax revenue in a year, and so what the government must borrow.
Doesn't government borrowing always crowd out the same amount of private investment?
No. Any rise in government borrowing must be matched by less private investment, more private saving or more borrowing from abroad, but which of the three gives way varies. In the mid-1980s US budget deficits rose sharply with no matching fall in private investment. In a recession with low interest rates and idle resources, crowding out may be small. Crowding out is a risk that grows with the size of the deficit and how close the economy is to capacity.
Write the chain in order: deficit, more borrowing, demand for financial capital shifts right, the interest rate rises, private investment and consumption fall, so aggregate demand rises by less than the extra spending. Then evaluate: crowding out is smaller in a recession, when rates are low and there is spare capacity.
Check yourself
In which situation is crowding out likely to be smallest?
Exam question
Explain how an increase in government borrowing might lead to crowding out. [4]
To finance a larger deficit the government sells more bonds, which increases the demand for financial capital. With the supply of savings unchanged, the interest rate rises. The higher rate makes it more costly for firms to borrow to invest and for households to borrow to spend, so private investment and consumption fall, partly offsetting the rise in government spending.
One mark each for the extra government borrowing, the rise in interest rates, the fall in private investment or consumption, and the offset to the rise in aggregate demand.
A larger budget deficit means more government borrowing, which shifts the demand for financial capital to the right and pushes interest rates up. Higher rates cut private investment and consumption, partly offsetting the rise in government spending: crowding out. How much is crowded out depends on spare capacity, on what the central bank does, and on how much saving and foreign capital is available.