Many firms stay small because of their market, their costs or their owners' choices
Some firms serve a market too small for a large firm: a village shop, a plumber covering one town, a maker of made-to-order furniture. Where the long-run average cost curve has a wide flat bottom, a small firm produces at the same average cost as a large one and can compete with it.
Small firms also find it harder to raise money. They rely on the owner's savings and on bank loans, while large firms can sell shares or bonds. And many owners stay small by choice, to keep control of the business or because it already earns what they want.
A very large firm splits into two separate firms, each making half its old output. What do you think happens to the average cost of producing that output?
A firm past the lowest point of its long-run average cost curve is paying for its size through slower decisions and poor communication. Two smaller firms can each produce at a lower average cost.
A firm demerges when splitting up cuts its costs, sharpens its focus or satisfies a regulator
A demerger splits one company into two or more separate companies. A firm that has grown into diseconomies of scale, where layers of management and poor communication push average cost up, can split to bring each part back to a lower average cost. Parts joined by a conglomerate merger may share nothing that cuts costs, or suffer a clash of ways of working; apart, each can focus on one market. A competition authority may also require a firm to sell off parts so that the market has more rivals.
In 2022 GSK split off its consumer health business, the maker of Sensodyne toothpaste, as a separate company, Haleon, and kept its medicines and vaccines.
Check yourself
A firm produces at F, where its average cost is rising. It splits into two firms of equal size. Which point shows where each new firm produces?
Yes. Each new firm makes half of F's output, which puts it on the flat bottom of the curve, at a lower average cost than F.
B is a quarter of F's output, which is where each firm would be after a split into four. Two equal firms produce twice as much each.
D is three quarters of F's output. Two firms of equal size each produce half of it, which is further to the left, on the flat bottom.
A demerger brings gains and costs for the business, its workers and its customers
For the business, each new firm can concentrate on one market, and average cost falls if the old firm had diseconomies of scale. But the parts lose any economies of scale they shared, such as bulk buying, and pay one-off costs to separate systems and head offices.
For workers, a split can bring new managers and new routes to promotion, and each new firm needs its own head office staff; restructuring can also cut jobs or change pay and pensions. For consumers, prices can fall if the split cuts costs or creates a new rival in the same market, and rise if the parts lose economies of scale that kept costs down.
- Demerger
- A demerger is the splitting of one firm into two or more separate companies, each run and traded on its own.
- Merger
- A merger is when two formerly separate firms combine to become a single firm.
Doesn't a firm always lose out by getting smaller?
No. A bigger firm has lower average cost only while there are economies of scale to gain. Past the lowest point of the long-run average cost curve, a firm can grow so large that it is hard to manage, and its average cost rises; shrinking takes it back to a lower average cost. And where the curve is flat over a wide range of output, a small firm and a large one produce at the same average cost, so the small firm is at no cost disadvantage.
For an impact question, take each group in turn, the business, its workers and its consumers, and give a gain and a cost for each. Tie the cost side to economies of scale: a demerger lowers average cost only if the old firm had diseconomies of scale, and raises it if the parts shared economies such as bulk buying.
Check yourself
A workshop builds made-to-order kitchens for customers who live within twenty miles of it. Which reason best explains why it stays small?
Check yourself
Three of these are reasons a firm might demerge. Which one is a reason to merge instead?
Exam question
Explain one reason why a large firm may choose to demerge and one likely effect of the demerger on its consumers. [4]
The firm may have grown into diseconomies of scale, so management is slow and average cost is rising; splitting brings each part back to a lower average cost. If those lower costs are passed on, consumers may pay lower prices. But if the parts lose shared economies of scale, such as bulk buying, costs and prices may rise instead.
One mark for a reason and one for developing it, such as diseconomies of scale raising average cost; one mark for an effect on consumers and one for the reasoning that links it to costs or competition.
Firms stay small because their market is small, because a flat-bottomed long-run average cost curve lets them match large firms' costs, because they rely on the owner's savings and bank loans, or by the owner's choice. A demerger splits one firm into separate firms, to escape diseconomies of scale, to let unrelated parts focus, or because a competition authority requires it. Its effects on the business, workers and consumers turn on what happens to costs and competition.